Glass flbre oil filter.
Glass flbre oil filter.
Author
Discussion

chimaeras

Original Poster:

109 posts

191 months

Saturday 26th November 2011
quotequote all
Has anybody had any experience with the Glass fibre filled oil filter as sold on Fleabay item number 330641837975. They seem a good idea, but everything with an advantage has a disadvantage !!

carsy

3,019 posts

196 months

Saturday 26th November 2011
quotequote all
No experience yet, but i will be doing an oil change in the next few weeks and i have decided to give on a go.

Pupp

13,010 posts

303 months

Saturday 26th November 2011
quotequote all
Clearance can be marginal for them due to the length of the canister. Some get away with them; some have struggle

Chimpabollics

9,637 posts

210 months

Sunday 27th November 2011
quotequote all
I'm on my second one.

They are a tight on the front cross member tubing, but they do fit.

Once you get it square on the thread and wind it on a few turns there are no clearance issues.

No idea if it performs better but the theory seems good and for only a few extra quid over a paper element filter I figure it may be worth it in the long term.

If nothing else the extra size gives you a bit more oil in the system & perhaps a slightly better oil cooling effect.

chimaeras

Original Poster:

109 posts

191 months

Sunday 27th November 2011
quotequote all
Hi, Thanks for your comments. Its great to get feedback before making a decision !!
Sometimes you see something that seems great, only to find there is a fundamental flaw !
Thanks again, i am going to buy one now.

SILICONEKID340HP

14,997 posts

262 months

Sunday 27th November 2011
quotequote all
Is that the old style oil filter? my Dads 62 Cresta has the same style filter.If there that good why did they move on to the sealed throw away type..

TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Sunday 27th November 2011
quotequote all
It sounds good.. but I wonder what actual testing’s been done on it.. over X number of hours.. against a bench mark engine running on a standard filter??....
One thing that does spring to mind.. is how well the filter element is constructed in the first place?… Could there be any loose particles / dust in there that will go into your engine… after all, it’s glass… and could that damage the engine more than paper particles??...

Just a thought??

phillpot

17,520 posts

214 months

Sunday 27th November 2011
quotequote all
SILICONEKID340HP said:
Is that the old style oil filter?
No, take a look here

Got one on my V6 S3 (remote filter kit fitted) guess only time will tell if any better or worse.

Goaty Bill

1,779 posts

182 months

Monday 28th November 2011
quotequote all
TVR Beaver said:
It sounds good.. but I wonder what actual testing’s been done on it.. over X number of hours.. against a bench mark engine running on a standard filter??....
One thing that does spring to mind.. is how well the filter element is constructed in the first place?… Could there be any loose particles / dust in there that will go into your engine… after all, it’s glass… and could that damage the engine more than paper particles??...

Just a thought??
Probably better to research via Cummins Filtration or Fleetguard Filters.

Fram + others also use similar/same technology, I don't think it is anything especially new or exotic.

The fact that Cummins (diesel engines) and Fram make these would seem to indicate that they work. biggrin


TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Monday 28th November 2011
quotequote all
Goaty Bill said:
Probably better to research via Cummins Filtration or Fleetguard Filters.

Fram + others also use similar/same technology, I don't think it is anything especially new or exotic.

The fact that Cummins (diesel engines) and Fram make these would seem to indicate that they work. biggrin
Indeed... if Fram use it already... thats probably what I have fitted hehe Just thought it was something new???....
Obviously not bow....

Just get a Fram then??

Goaty Bill

1,779 posts

182 months

Monday 28th November 2011
quotequote all
TVR Beaver said:
Indeed... if Fram use it already... thats probably what I have fitted hehe Just thought it was something new???....
Obviously not bow....

Just get a Fram then??
They may still do the 'cheap ones' too! AFAIK

The original link posted was to a very small vendor it seemed.
Providing names for actual manufacturers was just some guidance smile

I stand corrected however, it seems it is fairly new if the comparison / review I just found is somehting to go by, as they say the Fram filter used paper in 2008.

If I know 'the owner formerly known as Chimpafrolics', he will have given it a few googles before making his decision to use one the first time.
That said, he didn't choose Fram soooooo.

You may want to do a little more general research to feel safe in your ultimate choice.

The ones phillpot referenced at Here are apparently made by Fleetguard who is owned(?) by Cummins.