The internet works!!!!!
The internet works!!!!!
Author
Discussion

Liquid Knight

Original Poster:

15,754 posts

205 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
A few weeks ago I witnessed this collision...

http://youtu.be/UGcyxjqt2mk

...a few people asked me what I thought happened so I posted this...

http://youtu.be/ya9RhHiJtfQ

...I gave a copies of the original recording to the Police, Fire service and the local councils Highways Agency.

My concludion that the slip road was too short and contributed to the collision was agreeded with by the Police, Fire Service and yesterday I got an email from the Highways Agency saying they are going to redesign the junction and will have new plans by the end of the year.

Result. smile

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

188 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
I emailed Warrington Council stating that worn road markings were causing drivers to choose the wrong lane on approach to a major junction, resulting in potential collisions.

They wrote back to me a few weeks later saying they would re-paint the road markings by the end of October.

Still waiting for it to be done...

SLCZ3

1,277 posts

227 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
To my mind the slip road "junction" mislead, the car turning right, into thinking she/he had right of way. The driver of the, right turning, car should not have assumed it was safe to cross oncoming traffic, in other words he/she was a complete imbecile.

tescor

530 posts

250 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Good on you for making the videos and trying to make a difference clap

There's a similar junction to this turning towards Twyford\Ruscombe, from the A4 at the Wyvale Nursery. The slip road from the main road (A4) has to give way for traffic cutting across the A4 (i.e. turning right from the opposite direction). It looks like a very complicated solution to what should be a simple junction!


littlebasher

3,915 posts

193 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
My favorite bit is at 02:58 when that Blue Mk 4 Escort drives past....They do still exist and we now have proof!

off_again

13,917 posts

256 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Well done!

And for all of those Brake morons - road safety is not all about speed, its about sensible road design!

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
What a great name: Clenchwarton. Sounds like some muscle spasm affliction that affects womens' genitals.

Chrisw666

22,655 posts

221 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Sorry but the person who drove in front of the van was a fking moron.

Alex

9,978 posts

306 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Good work! Although the music hurts my ears.

Liquid Knight

Original Poster:

15,754 posts

205 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Alex said:
Good work! Although the music hurts my ears.
It's preferable to my passenger who forgot the camera was on and decided to call all her friends to have a gossip about it rather than call the Police. rolleyes

Terrorvision on the second video because it was the only track on my laptop the same length. wink

BazzaH

308 posts

214 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
mnkiboy said:
I emailed Warrington Council stating that worn road markings were causing drivers to choose the wrong lane on approach to a major junction, resulting in potential collisions.

They wrote back to me a few weeks later saying they would re-paint the road markings by the end of October.

Still waiting for it to be done...
The ones on the run upto the the M62 junction?

Or further down the A49 near to McDonalds that has 2 centrelines in the road that are both faded and no-one knows which to use?

Liquid Knight

Original Poster:

15,754 posts

205 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Chrisw666 said:
Sorry but the person who drove in front of the van was a fking moron.
While I agree that anyone would have looked twice to make sure in respect she saw a van slowing at the end of the slip road, no signal but hey it's a van and acted instinctively. As I already stated by the time she realised she had made the mistake it was too late for either driver to do anything about it. For our point of view and with the clarity of hindsight we can name call if we wish but we all make mistakes.

There have certainly been enough collisions and near misses on that junction to prove that it is more than driver error causing problems.

Mr Whippy

32,155 posts

263 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Eh, the van didn't have a flasher on, and no matter how long the slip road is, people can enter it wherever they like along it. So a longer slip road won't prevent these types of accidents.

Seems to be a solution based on assumptions.

Drivers deciding to cross the flow of traffic when they turn right, will have to assume that oncoming traffic WILL enter the slip road at it's furthest extent if they are turning down the same road they are.
However in this example, if the turning driver assumed the van was going to enter the slip road, then they clearly thought they were going to enter it very late anyway.
So drivers who turn across the flow of traffic already show they DON'T assume drivers will be in the slip road at it's extents if they are intending to turn.


I'd say something else here is the cause of the accidents. Perhaps separating the slip road away from the main carriageway before joining with the lane of the side road would be a better idea, so the slip road becomes a fork from the main carriageway you have to get into, which is a more positive movement for traffic turning across the main carriageway to see (less likely to mis-read someone's intended path)


Hmmm

Dave

Liquid Knight

Original Poster:

15,754 posts

205 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
I'd say something else here is the cause of the accidents. Perhaps separating the slip road away from the main carriageway before joining with the lane of the side road would be a better idea, so the slip road becomes a fork from the main carriageway you have to get into, which is a more positive movement for traffic turning across the main carriageway to see (less likely to mis-read someone's intended path)

Dave
That's how it was before they made it "safer".

At 0.33 to 0.35 you can see the old slip road that made the junction into a triangle.

Matthen

1,413 posts

173 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
tescor said:
Good on you for making the videos and trying to make a difference clap

There's a similar junction to this turning towards Twyford\Ruscombe, from the A4 at the Wyvale Nursery. The slip road from the main road (A4) has to give way for traffic cutting across the A4 (i.e. turning right from the opposite direction). It looks like a very complicated solution to what should be was a simple junction!
EFA - They changed that junction and made it worse, just like they have at the winnersh junction of the A329m and the A327 junctions through shinfield. Then they say their isn't enough money to resurface the desperatly poor roads around this area.

Really gets on my nerves (especially the traffic lights they put on roundabouts.)

/Rant

On a more positive note - good work OP, Hopefully the local authority will take note now :-)

Engineer1

10,486 posts

231 months

Friday 2nd December 2011
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Eh, the van didn't have a flasher on, and no matter how long the slip road is, people can enter it wherever they like along it. So a longer slip road won't prevent these types of accidents.

Seems to be a solution based on assumptions.

Drivers deciding to cross the flow of traffic when they turn right, will have to assume that oncoming traffic WILL enter the slip road at it's furthest extent if they are turning down the same road they are.
However in this example, if the turning driver assumed the van was going to enter the slip road, then they clearly thought they were going to enter it very late anyway.
So drivers who turn across the flow of traffic already show they DON'T assume drivers will be in the slip road at it's extents if they are intending to turn.


I'd say something else here is the cause of the accidents. Perhaps separating the slip road away from the main carriageway before joining with the lane of the side road would be a better idea, so the slip road becomes a fork from the main carriageway you have to get into, which is a more positive movement for traffic turning across the main carriageway to see (less likely to mis-read someone's intended path)


Hmmm

Dave
But not seeing an orange bulb blinking doesn't say much, many people don't indicate or indicate very late, Mirror Signal Manoeuvre seems to have become Signal and Manoeuvre then check no one has had to take evasive action.

It is poor road design I wonder how often the main road gets held up by the sliproad being too short, there are junctions local to me that can take 5 or 6 cars but regularly have 20-30 in them meaning the main road backs up and the junction doesn't work properly.

Liquid Knight

Original Poster:

15,754 posts

205 months

Thursday 15th December 2011
quotequote all
Just an update. Following another three collisions they've moved the schedule forward and this was what the junction looked like today. smile

http://youtu.be/B7wPy07oXqM

Hat's off the the King's Lynn and West Norfolk Borough Council for pulling their collective finger out and getting it done.