Precista PRS 5 grief.
Precista PRS 5 grief.
Author
Discussion

andytk

Original Poster:

1,558 posts

297 months

Monday 5th December 2011
quotequote all
Afternoon all,

I don't post much in here, but do have a look in from time to time. Like a few folk on PH, this forum has a lot to answer for when it comes to watch purchases...hehe

Anyhow, I have a PRS 5 (see here http://www.watcharama.com/prs5.htm ) which has has ‘issues’ and I'm pretty fed up with it.

When I first got it, it only lasted about 2 months before the internal ratchet that holds the wind (its a manual winder) broke. Whenever it was wound up, you could actually watch the crown rotate backwards when you let it go.

So back it went under warranty and was duly repaired. After that incident I have always been careful not to wind it all the way up to the stop, and am gentle when I wind it. Incidentally Eddie at Timefactors said this was the first time that he'd heard of this happening. It appears I've been unlucky and have acquired the friday afternoon model.

I usually wind it up around the same time every day.

Anyway it went pete tong again and was duly sent back for repair. When it was returned, I pulled the crown to set the time and it (the crown) fell off in my hand. I’m not a big guy who tears stuff up hulk style so it was definitely a materials defect/fatigue issue.grumpy

So back it went (again) and was repaired.

Now I’ve got it back its out of warranty I’ve noticed that the chronograph doesn’t run right.banghead It’ll start ok, and then randomly stop (stopping the watch along with it). There is no pattern to the random stopping and as the watch has a display back, I can see that there isn’t a hair or something in it. If I stop the chrono the watch will start to run again, leading me to think that there is a friction issue with the second hand.

Not sure if I can be arsed stumping up money to have it repaired as it would seem not to hold a repair (and besides, every time I send it back, it returns with a new-and-improved-defectrolleyes)

There are a few other things that annoy me about it too, the chrono second had doesn't line up with the 12 when stopped and the chrono start stop mechanism has a quite nasty graunchy feeling to it.

I realise that this watch is Chinese made (and based on an old-but reliable design) but I’m still a tad disappointed.

The watch is now un-sellable as I couldn’t in good conscience sell it on knowing it has issues.

So has anyone else had issue with the PRS-5 (or SeaGull watches/same movement)?

Also anyone else had a sticking chronograph?

Cheers for reading my moan any advice welcome.

Andy


Edited by andytk on Monday 5th December 14:39

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Tuesday 6th December 2011
quotequote all
Have you spoken to Eddie again about the latest problem? I know it's out of warranty but it's worth a shot.
I had a Sea-Gull (the 1963 reissue, same movement as the PRS-5) that arrived broken, but I think that was likely because it had been dropped/kicked en route! It's a sturdy movement so it's a surprise to hear you've had such problems.

Ikemi

8,611 posts

236 months

Tuesday 6th December 2011
quotequote all
As Luke says, I'd speak to Eddie at Timefactors first. If it's just out of warranty and has been back for repair 3 times in 1 year(?), then perhaps Eddie might offer to fix it free of charge, as a good will gesture. Surely it's worth a go! smile

krusty

2,473 posts

280 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
LukeBird said:
Sea-Gull (the 1963 reissue, same movement as the PRS-5)
Just out of interest (sorry for the hijack) did you manage to get it fixed?
I also have a 1963 reissue that's broken that I would like repaired

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
krusty said:
LukeBird said:
Sea-Gull (the 1963 reissue, same movement as the PRS-5)
Just out of interest (sorry for the hijack) did you manage to get it fixed?
I also have a 1963 reissue that's broken that I would like repaired
I didn't, no, I returned it and had another sent out.
For yours I'd recommend sending to Steve Burrage at Ryte Time for repair, drop him a line and see what he has to say. smile

bry1975

1,246 posts

194 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
Yup Steve is a goodun and Mr Senior at the webby below.

http://www.obsoletewatchandclockparts.com/

andytk

Original Poster:

1,558 posts

297 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
LukeBird said:
Have you spoken to Eddie again about the latest problem? I know it's out of warranty but it's worth a shot.
I'd rather stick pins in my eyes than deal with him again. Last time I dealt with him he said he might have to charge for the repair (and this was while it was under warranty!!). He didn't charge me in the end, but I was left wondering.

Plus whoever his repair organisation are, they're clearly incompetent as their early repairs didn't hold and they clearly don't test watches prior to returning them, or they would have caught this problem as its quite repeatable. The chronograph won't run for more than 5 mins without stopping. (usually it won't get past 3 minutes)

As the watch isn't particularly valuable I probably won't bother to get it repaired until it goes in for a service in a couple of years time. I'll get it looked at then.

My knowledge of mechanical watches is about nil, but as the second hand is consistently stopping between 22 and 34 seconds I was wondering if it was something to do with the strength of the mechanism that re-zeros the second hand when the chrono is reset? Either that or the second hand pinion wheel is catching/rubbing on something at that point on every rotation and stalling the escapement.

I was hoping it would be a simple fix so a local watch repair outfit could adjust it without charging half the value of the watch to do so.

Andy

andytk

Original Poster:

1,558 posts

297 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
And its broken again....

Bloody ratchet mechanism's given up the ghost again, whats it made of? cheese???

Its been into a repair shop in Glasgow but they're unable to get parts so can't fix it.
Looks like I have an ornament now.

Andy

Woody

2,189 posts

315 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
andytk said:
And its broken again....

Bloody ratchet mechanism's given up the ghost again, whats it made of? cheese???

Its been into a repair shop in Glasgow but they're unable to get parts so can't fix it.
Looks like I have an ornament now.

Andy
Sorry to hear about your problems.
But I'll second one of the post above - Steve Burridge at Rytetime is a top man.
He's serviced/repaired a few of mine.
Drop him line and see what he says.