123D
Author
Discussion

acme

Original Poster:

3,036 posts

229 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
Evening all,



I’m looking for some feedback from owners of 123D’s (Coupe’s preferably), I’m considering one as it seems to be the perfect compromise; 200bhp/295lb/ft/rear wheel drive & 55mpg.



So, does it get anywhere near the 55mpg combined figure and is the M sport ride too hard? Any other tips etc or areas of weakness would be appreciated, and are there any ‘must have’ additional extras, other than a preference for Le Mans blue and cream leather I’d really like cruise too.



Plus anyone any ideas on how an iphone can integrate with one, i.e. for both music and the phone?



Cheers (thumb)

JNW1

9,540 posts

225 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
acme said:
Evening all,

I’m looking for some feedback from owners of 123D’s (Coupe’s preferably), I’m considering one as it seems to be the perfect compromise; 200bhp/295lb/ft/rear wheel drive & 55mpg.

So, does it get anywhere near the 55mpg combined figure and is the M sport ride too hard? Any other tips etc or areas of weakness would be appreciated, and are there any ‘must have’ additional extras, other than a preference for Le Mans blue and cream leather I’d really like cruise too.

Plus anyone any ideas on how an iphone can integrate with one, i.e. for both music and the phone?
I've got a 123d SE 5 door which I bought in June as a daily driver to compliment an M3 CS I had at the time. I've covered just over 9k miles in it and, while I appreciate you're looking at something slightly different with a sport coupe, there are obviously some common areas as well. For what it's worth, my thoughts are:

The engine is smooth and refined for a 4 cylinder diesel and offers decent performance. However, I doubt you'll get anywhere near 55mpg unless you drive very gently; my car is averaging more like 45mpg which is about 9mpg (17%) down on the combined figure. By way of comparison, over 60k miles the M3 consistently beat the combined figure by about 10% in similar driving conditions so I don't think the relatively disappointing economy in the 123d is a consequence of my driving style! One other thing to note is that the 123d has relatively low gearing (around 33mph/'000 revs in top) so if you do a lot of motorway work the higher geared 120d could actually be a better bet for that sort of running.

My car is still on run flats but to be frank the ride is poor even on 17" wheels. The traction control light can come on even driving in a straight line at moderate speeds across rippled asphalt and I've seen the light flash far more times in 9k miles in the 123d than I did in 60k miles in the M3. I was actually given a 118d sport as a courtesy car recently and expected that to be even worse in terms of ride quality; however, if anything it seemed slightly better which was a bit of a surprise!

The other thing that has disappointed me with my 123d is the general fit and finish inside. It would be grossly unfair to describe it as a rattle trap but the general feel and quality of the plastics really isn't great; a Golf or an A3 would be far better and in truth even the current shape Astra has the 123d beaten on that score!

In terms of must have options, xenons would probably be top of my list; my car doesn't have them and the lights are pretty awful after the xenons in the M3. My car has cruise control which works fine although the opportunities to use it are very limited; it also has rain sensing wipers and I do find those very useful (not sure if they're standard on the coupe or not).

Overall, then, I'm not really that impressed with my 123d and would probably score it at around 6 out of 10. The acid test with any car is, knowing what you know now, would you still have bought it; for me it would be a "no" for the 123d and the main reasons for that would be the disappointing economy, poor ride and indifferent interior fit and finish. However, that's just my view and I'm sure there will be plenty of other owners who think differently!


E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
ditch the run flats when the tread is getting low, they make a world of difference.

JNW1

9,540 posts

225 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
ditch the run flats when the tread is getting low, they make a world of difference.
You may well be right but I feel I'd be throwing good money after bad given my overall opinion of the car; think a more radical solution is needed and hence I will be putting the 123d down to experience and looking to see what deals are around in the new year!

gareth h

4,334 posts

261 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
I bought a 123d coupe M sport a couple of months ago to replace my e46 M3, I do 20k miles per year and thought I should get into a 50mpg car. The 123 appealed as there aren't too many rwd cars that fall into that category.
Drove it for 3 days and hated it, everything felt cheap compared to my M3, decided I was going to sell it straight away, after 2 weeks I hadn't had any serious calls so insured it and started to use it, after a few weeks it is becoming acceptable and the M3 is now up for sale. You shouldn't take this as a criticism of the 123 just that it can't compare to a well sorted M3.
I'm getting 47mpg (managed 52mpg on a 200 mile motorway trip at 70 mph ish) The suspension isn't too harsh (although my M3 had KW coilovers so it depends what you are used to driving.
In terms of extras as has been said xenons (mine doesn't have them but I wish it did) 18" rims sort out the handling a bit, mine has usb aux in to the stereo which means you can put all your music on a couple of usb sticks. Lumbar support as the standard sport seats are wanting in that area, and a remap which I shall add shortly.

eztiger

836 posts

211 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
Everything JNW1 said..

Though the end marks out of ten is probably a little harsh..but fair smile

I love mine, as a daily run around it's quick enough (just) and drives well enough dynamically to keep a bit of interest and in return the economy is pretty decent.

I don't get near the headline figures but do see 45-50 mpg over a tank (so 500ish miles to the tank). That's pretty good I reckon. It's the same as my other halfs 1l Yaris - 123d is just a little better to drive though!

But yes, ride could be called harsh. I don't personally have a problem with it (I've driven harsher) and I currently have non run flat winters on and it is much better, so I'll be ditching the summer RFT's once they're worn. Interior material quality and switchgear I find ok but the fit is appalling. Lots of squeaks and groans. They're generally 'standard' and easily fixable with a bit of poking around but that's not really the point.

Options wise I'd get as many as you can. I didn't and regret it, I'd happily have another 123d but I'd want more of a spec. I'm missing xenons, decent stereo, any sort of phone integration and heated seats. I don't have leather but not fussed about that and the idrive appeals to me in principle but I suspect might just be an expensive novelty.

In summary it's small enough to be easy to park and fit comfortably in the garage, quick enough to keep you interested, rwd, handles well (I find), comfortable and can be well spec'd inside and returns 40-50mpg and isn't bad on road tax or insurance either. It has a lot of different mechanicals than the rest of the 1 series (diesel) line so you can expect slightly higher servicing / parts prices.

If I could find another car that does all that I'd be all ears but I don't know of one at the 123d price point.

So great for a daily runner but if you're after a sports car it's not really what you want. I find the comparisons to M3's in two other posts here a bit strange - I wouldn't expect the 123 to be anywhere near them in many respects other than running costs. It seems to have developed a bit of a reputation of some sort of diesel super car on the net (along with the 335d) but it's really not, so go in with expectations set accordingly.

Though I havn't tried mine remapped wink

V8A*ndy

3,703 posts

222 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
I found the Msport suspension to be excellent. Certainly more supple than Audis Sline setup on the A3.

The seats however are not for everyone and just when I got that issue sorted by adjusting never ending, err adjustments, the wife changed it and I was back to sq 1.

Xenons are a must on this car and the Msport trim gives the car a much better quality feel.

BMW do a 197 BHP upgrade for the 120d complete with extra cooling. So 200bhp and a tall 6th would be a great compromise.

A well loved and specced 120d Mnonsense followed by a power hike would be a good call.

JNW1

9,540 posts

225 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
eztiger said:
I find the comparisons to M3's in two other posts here a bit strange - I wouldn't expect the 123 to be anywhere near them in many respects other than running costs.
Just to clarify, I wasn't trying to compare the 123d and my CS as I agree they are fundamentally different cars; mine was bought as a daily driver to compliment the M3 rather than replace it!

My reference to fuel consumption in the M3 was only to illustrate that generally I get reasonable economy out of a car and hence I don't consider the big shortfall against the combined figure in the 123d to be a consequence of my driving style.

Perhaps the comparison with how often I've seen the traction control light was a bit unfair although having said that I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a car to travel over lightly-rippled asphalt at moderate speeds and keep its driving wheels on the ground! I drove the same piece of road countless times in the CS without even being aware of how bad the road surface was and I'm sure something like a Golf or an Astra wouldn't notice it either. Perhaps the run-flats are indeed to blame but it's a poor do if you pay a premium price for a BMW and then have to shell out more money to replace the tyres in order to get decent ride quality!

GarryA

4,700 posts

195 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
acme said:
Evening all,



I’m looking for some feedback from owners of 123D’s (Coupe’s preferably), I’m considering one as it seems to be the perfect compromise; 200bhp/295lb/ft/rear wheel drive & 55mpg.



So, does it get anywhere near the 55mpg combined figure and is the M sport ride too hard? Any other tips etc or areas of weakness would be appreciated, and are there any ‘must have’ additional extras, other than a preference for Le Mans blue and cream leather I’d really like cruise too.



Plus anyone any ideas on how an iphone can integrate with one, i.e. for both music and the phone?



Cheers (thumb)
I have a 120D M Coupe but a lot is the same.....

I can get 55mpg driving like a saint (embarrassingly slow) and down to 47mpg when pressing on (cruising up to 100mph) I would say -5mpg for the 123d.

Msport ride is very hard on the run flats.

Comfort Pack is good to have as is the bluetooth prep, then you get an Iphone dock for about £100 that fits in the armrest.

Get a warranty preferably the BMW one its about £35 a month on rolling contact.

14-7

6,233 posts

222 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
I've had my 123d Coupe for 3 months now.

I have gone from an Alfa 147GTA to it and to say I feel slightly let down is an understatement.

Yes the 123d is a capable car but...... it's comfy(ish) but my right leg is aching after an hour or so in the saddle. The sound system is terrible for a £31k car. Fuel economy, well, if I drive very slowly I get 41-43mpg and spirited 38-40mpg, 1st and 2nd gear are stupidly short to the point I can't actually figure out why. Some owners say they have accidentally set off in 3rd due to all the torque. All I can say to that is bks. Mine won't pull from a standstill in 2nd without serious clutch slipping. If they do it in 3rd then their clutch won't last long.

The car overall, once moving, is comfy, settles in for long runs as long as you aren't doing 80-90 due to the short gearing. and does for the performance offer some decent economy.

Unfortunately I just wish it would grab your thrill genes a bit more. Maybe I've just bought the wrong car?

JNW1

9,540 posts

225 months

Friday 9th December 2011
quotequote all
14-7 said:
Maybe I've just bought the wrong car?
That makes two of us then! Imagine a 123d must be seriously lacking in character and soul after a 147 GTA; still, at least there's the superior fit and finish and build quality to fall back on. Actually, hang on a minute, no there isn't.....

cheddar

4,637 posts

205 months

Saturday 10th December 2011
quotequote all
Brilliant reading ^^^^this^^^^^ lot when you've just spent $50,000 on one without ever trying it.

JNW1

9,540 posts

225 months

Saturday 10th December 2011
quotequote all
cheddar said:
Brilliant reading ^^^^this^^^^^ lot when you've just spent $50,000 on one without ever trying it.
I'd had 1-series as courtesy cars (albeit not a 123d) and judged them to be ok. Suppose it goes to show that sometimes you need to spend time with a car on a variety of roads to evaluate it properly although I've bought other cars on the evidence of relatively short test drives and been very happy with them (the M3 CS being the most notable example). To a degree I admit to buying the 123d based on an expectation of what a BMW would be like to own and drive and I hold my hand up and say I got it wrong in this case; thankfully, however, I bought it second-hand and hence didn't pay anything like the sort of money you're suggesting!

My view is that one of the purposes of forums like this is for existing to owners to give feedback so potential buyers can make more of an informed decision; it therefore doesn't help that proecess if existing owners who think they got it wrong just keep quiet. If you asked for my opinion on the M3 CS you'd get a very different review so I'm certainly not anti-BMW, just trying to call it how I see it where the 123d is concerned!

Edited by JNW1 on Saturday 10th December 09:29

Bodo

12,626 posts

297 months

Saturday 10th December 2011
quotequote all
I had a 3dr 123d for three years and 60k miles. I've never reset the boardcomputer, and in the end it showed 48mpg. About 90% of the mileage was driven between 130 and 230km/h.

It had std suspension and rft. It was comfortable, as long as noone sat in the back. It was reliable, and the only things on quality were that the heated seat switch would be stick at temperatures below -3°C, and the rh side trim in the back would rattle at this temperature range, until the car has heated up.

Best extra was the keyless go.

cheddar

4,637 posts

205 months

Saturday 10th December 2011
quotequote all
JNW1 said:
cheddar said:
Brilliant reading ^^^^this^^^^^ lot when you've just spent $50,000 on one without ever trying it.
I'd had 1-series as courtesy cars (albeit not a 123d) and judged them to be ok. Suppose it goes to show that sometimes you need to spend time with a car on a variety of roads to evaluate it properly although I've bought other cars on the evidence of relatively short test drives and been very happy with them (the M3 CS being the most notable example). To a degree I admit to buying the 123d based on an expectation of what a BMW would be like to own and drive and I hold my hand up and say I got it wrong in this case; thankfully, however, I bought it second-hand and hence didn't pay anything like the sort of money you're suggesting!

My view is that one of the purposes of forums like this is for existing to owners to give feedback so potential buyers can make more of an informed decision; it therefore doesn't help that proecess if existing owners who think they got it wrong just keep quiet. If you asked for my opinion on the M3 CS you'd get a very different review so I'm certainly not anti-BMW, just trying to call it how I see it where the 123d is concerned!

Edited by JNW1 on Saturday 10th December 09:29
Not aimed at you JNW.

I slapped down my $50,000 yesterday on a 2000 mile old ex-demo that needs clearing before 2012, it's nearly $30,000 under list - no test drive, haven't even seen the inside of one.

Delivery is next week.

Having a good chuckle at all this.

Keep the reports coming.smile

JNW1

9,540 posts

225 months

Sunday 11th December 2011
quotequote all
cheddar said:
Not aimed at you JNW.

I slapped down my $50,000 yesterday on a 2000 mile old ex-demo that needs clearing before 2012, it's nearly $30,000 under list - no test drive, haven't even seen the inside of one.

Delivery is next week.

Having a good chuckle at all this.

Keep the reports coming.smile
Bon chance mon ami! smile

acme

Original Poster:

3,036 posts

229 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
Hello all,

Many thanks for the responses, especially some of the very detailed ownership experiences; nothing beats long term owners reviews. I should give some additional info as to what I’m looking for and why the 123D – I’m very lucky that it will go alongside a 993 911 so whilst I’m not looking for an out and out sports car (& I don’t expect it) I would like something quick, frugal and sporty. My current daily driver is a Golf GT TDI / 2.0 TDI, a car I’ve owned for 3.5 years/38k miles and really like – it’s reasonably quick, torquey (236lb/ft), comfortable, economical (I regularly get 55+mpg on my gentle A road commute – few opportunities to overtake and circa 50mph average), it’s practical and good for long journeys, but after 3.5years it’s time for a change. I can’t deny I’m concerned at the comments around economy (surely with stop start the 55mpg figure should be achievable) and build quality, I do seem to recall reading that one series are known for being built to a price – and it has to be said whilst the Golf is OK it’s clear that MKV’s are nowhere near as good as MKIV’s for interior plastics in particular. On the subject of extras it seems that few of the coupes are that well specced, I definitely want cruise and some kind of phone compatability but it’s the ease of selling on for which I want extras.

In particular a big thanks to JNW1 for the reply and your closing comment, my comparison is the Golf which I very often recommend, it may only be a Golf, but it is a superb car for what it is in my eyes.

Any ideas what wheel size they come with as standard? For example on the 993 I’ve steered clear of 18”s sticking to the 17”s and avoided harder dampers – I’d definitely not want anything too harsh on a daily – my commute as for most of us I suspect is fairly rough. Plus any ideas on winter tyres, I’ll probably buy a spare set of rims, steelies even, but I suspect knowing BM there’s some additional cost factor to consider??

V8A*ndy - any ideas on the cost of the remap for the 120d, I really like that idea, possibly even applicable to the 320d, an M Coupe one of them appeals too???

One question for all you guys, and please bear with me on this one, I recently asked on PH about another car I’m considering and in the main I got very negative responses, is it that only those with negative ownership experiences have replied, or is it that in your experience on the BMW forum (I’m usually to be found in the Porsche one) that this is the overall consensus of opinion? Clearly I’ve enjoyed owning the Golf and don’t want the move to a new daily driver to be a backward one.

I also read the 530i v’s 530d thread and it seems older BM diesels suffer a number of very expensive problems??

Many thanks in advance for any reponses; cheers.

eztiger

836 posts

211 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
acme said:
I can’t deny I’m concerned at the comments around economy (surely with stop start the 55mpg figure should be achievable) and build quality,
The mpg is really a question of how you drive it and what your commute will look like. Very very light on the throttle (i.e none at all) and 99% motorway / downhill and yes you'll hit 55 average. Instant readings on motorways at 50-70 can easily be got into the 50's / 60's / 70's depending on the road camber and speed. Remember you have a twin turbo setup here which kicks in early down the rev range. You're borderline always spooling the turbo no matter what you do when applying throttle - so stop start traffic / in town traffic kills mpg whilst you're tootling about in the (almost pointless ratio wise) 1st gear. The stop start system doesn't really make much difference. 2-3 mpg maybe. Just the amount of diesel you'd use whilst sitting stationary. Worth having, but it's not really a huge improvement.

I would budget for 45mpg. I get a smidge more out of mine but that's reasonably gentle driving. I've never breached 50 for a tank. http://www.fuelly.com/driver/boom/123d if you're interested. I have half a hope an air and fuel filter change might get me a few more but...

Again variable some people have no trouble getting 50+ but the average across lots of drivers and cars does seem to settle at 45.

Build quality is poor but does seem very variable on the individual car. Some people have absolutely no issues but I'd suggest it's more common that you do have some. But it is a budget car relative to the bmw range. I find in terms of the cash they cost it's not very acceptable (but live with it as the rest of the car makes up for it) but in terms of bottom of the range for the brand perhaps the odd fixable squeak and rattle can be lived with. Perhaps smile

A test drive will answer that pretty quickly for you.

acme said:
Any ideas what wheel size they come with as standard? For example on the 993 I’ve steered clear of 18”s sticking to the 17”s and avoided harder dampers – I’d definitely not want anything too harsh on a daily – my commute as for most of us I suspect is fairly rough. Plus any ideas on winter tyres, I’ll probably buy a spare set of rims, steelies even, but I suspect knowing BM there’s some additional cost factor to consider??
17s as standard. I believe due to the caliper size you can't go down smaller. Cost wise you just have to know you're stuck with 17's. You can usually pick up a second hand set of 17" alloys on ebay at the right time of year (i.e not now!) for a few hundred quid. The fitment is reasonably standard, I think you can pick up a lot of 3 series wheels that will fit etc so plenty of choice and a big market out there. Then tyre wise again you're stuck with 17"s. BMW put 205/50/17 on all round if I recall with their official winter package so good start point there.

Official BM package for 17" alloys and set of tyres is ~1500 from your dealer. You might get a couple hundred off that for haggling / if they're in a good mood.

acme said:
V8A*ndy - any ideas on the cost of the remap for the 120d, I really like that idea, possibly even applicable to the 320d, an M Coupe one of them appeals too???
Depends who you go with. £3-500 I reckon ball park but I've not had mine done so let someone else give you a better figure smile

acme said:
One question for all you guys, and please bear with me on this one, I recently asked on PH about another car I’m considering and in the main I got very negative responses, is it that only those with negative ownership experiences have replied, or is it that in your experience on the BMW forum (I’m usually to be found in the Porsche one) that this is the overall consensus of opinion? Clearly I’ve enjoyed owning the Golf and don’t want the move to a new daily driver to be a backward one.
Rare you'll get all the people posting with positive experiences, after all not much to say. So there's an inherent bias for only hearing the bad things about a car. Which is no bad thing. And, to be honest, it's not like the bad points coming up for the 123d are anything like 'gearbox made of cardboard, engine goes pop every 2 miles' so unattainable manufacturer mpgs and some ropey interior trim isn't too bad as far as the most common complaints go smile

Have a nosey through babybmw.net you'll have more opinions there too to help you.

I'd suggest trying to get a decent test drive of one. Reset the average mpg and make sure you can get a decent length of time behind the wheel, see what it turns out. Keep your ear out for trim rattles and see what you make of the cabin materials.

acme said:
I also read the 530i v’s 530d thread and it seems older BM diesels suffer a number of very expensive problems??
No problems inherently I'm aware of with the 123d engine. Though you do have the generic CR diesel issues in the wings / dpf / injectors etc etc. You take your chance with them on any modern diesel really - if that's not palatable then you're back to petrol.


JNW1

9,540 posts

225 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
acme said:
possibly even applicable to the 320d, an M Coupe one of them appeals too???
Before I bought my 123d I half thought about buying a 320d from a local independent and with the wisdom of hindsight I think that would have been a better bet for me. For a given amount of money you obviously get a car that's older and/or higher mileage but on the plus side you get a more roomy and better finished interior, improved ride quality and, from what I can gather, fuel consumption that's a fair bit better as well. Certainly an option worth considering IMO!

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
To the OP its a known fact your current golf 2ltr diesels far more frugal than a 120d so you may get a shock with the 123d.

It may be on a par with a 118d from what ive heard.