It's a duel to the death, 370z v Z4m coupe
It's a duel to the death, 370z v Z4m coupe
Author
Discussion

sidekickdmr

Original Poster:

5,213 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
Looking to buy a new car literally in the next couple of days but am at a loss which to go with?

Z4m coupe
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3456900.htm

Pros:
Always wanted one
Presumably quicker
More "excucitive"

Cons
Smaller (I'm 6'6)
Higher maintenance costs
Older
No warranty
Higher miles
Not as many toys


370z
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3481525.htm

Pros
Every toy imaginable
Newer with warranty
Bigger
Misses prefers it

Cons
It's still a datsun
Simular to my 350z
More expensive to buy

Any real life experience of either and if it was your money, what would you have?


BriC175

961 posts

211 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
One question...

What's 'excucitive'? biggrin

Tuvra

7,927 posts

256 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
Are they more expensive to buy? I have seen them going for £16k which seems incredible value!! The SLK55 AMG & 3.4 Cayman also coming down to these levels now which may also be a superb alternative:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3409503.htm
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3284431.htm

El Capitano

1,157 posts

224 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
for me, without a doubt the Z4MC. And spend some of the money saved on the 370 on some nice CSL alloys....

cocopop

1,300 posts

236 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
El Capitano said:
for me, without a doubt the Z4MC. And spend some of the money saved on the 370 on some nice CSL alloys....
yes This would also be my choice

SWoll

22,995 posts

289 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
Why don't you just drive them both and then decide?

Quite possible that you could immediately dislike/not feel comfortable in one or other and then the decision is made for you.

Both have got their strengths/weaknesses but IMO the Z4MC is a bit more special. Drive one...

Tuvra said:
The SLK55 AMG & 3.4 Cayman also coming down to these levels now which may also be a superb alternative:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3409503.htm
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3284431.htm
SLK55 makes a wonderful noise but has image problems and not sure how good it is dynamically?
If you buy a 3.4 cayman I think you'd likely always be wishing you could have afforded the S.

OP, have I already mentioned that you need to test drive them?


Edited by SWoll on Tuesday 13th December 09:25

sidekickdmr

Original Poster:

5,213 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
SWoll said:
Why don't you just drive them both and then decide?

Quite possible that you could immediately dislike/not feel comfortable in one or other and then the decision is made for you.

Both have got their strengths/weaknesses but IMO the Z4MC is a bit more special. Drive one...
Driven them both, both very nice in different ways, but didn't prefer one to the other!

sidekickdmr

Original Poster:

5,213 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
Tuvra said:
Are they more expensive to buy? I have seen them going for £16k which seems incredible value!! The SLK55 AMG & 3.4 Cayman also coming down to these levels now which may also be a superb alternative:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3409503.htm
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3284431.htm
I'm already stepping a bit close the the "hairdressers car" line! They overstep that mark a bit for me I'm afraid! (and yes I know, I'm sure they are great drivers cars etc but just not for me!)

Agoogy

7,274 posts

279 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
sidekickdmr said:
Tuvra said:
Are they more expensive to buy? I have seen them going for £16k which seems incredible value!! The SLK55 AMG & 3.4 Cayman also coming down to these levels now which may also be a superb alternative:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3409503.htm
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3284431.htm
I'm already stepping a bit close the the "hairdressers car" line! They overstep that mark a bit for me I'm afraid! (and yes I know, I'm sure they are great drivers cars etc but just not for me!)
You can't accuse these car's of being haridresser's cars but at the same time have a 370Z in your line up...I mean they are the biggest chest wig and medallion car out there no?
Do I care? no
should you? no
These tags as to what a care are boring in the extreme I don't buy into them and neither should you.

BMW for me out of the two you prefer.
It looks better inside and out.

MarkRSi

5,782 posts

249 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
sidekickdmr said:
Cons
It's still a datsun
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm Datsun



cloud9cool

snorkel sucker

2,726 posts

234 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
If you are willing to dismiss a Cayman due to it being a 'hairdresser's' car, and the 370z as being a Datsun, then it sounds like image takes precedence in your decision making.

Go for the BMW - you'd fit right in with 99% of owners

CypherP

4,459 posts

223 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
I'd personally go for the 370 as something a bit different. Can't deny that the Z4M is a fantastic car, but IMO so too is the 370Z. Quite rightly you've also mentioned it would be newer, with warranty, have the extras that you may not get with the Z4M and still sound and look great.


fizz47

3,252 posts

241 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
Having driven both (each at a week at a time) I would go for the Z4 anyday of the week.

While the 370 is not a bad car it just felt a little lacking and a bit cheap compared to the BMW. Also found the BMW a lot more rewarding to drive but that may be more down to my style of driving.

However I would get the SLK55 AMG ahead of both of them.

Turbo Harry

5,196 posts

268 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
SWoll said:
If you buy a 3.4 cayman I think you'd likely always be wishing you could have afforded the S.
Bend.

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
Z4M is an aaaaaaaawesome car but be warned about the running costs.

I have a Z4C and chose it over the M because it's just as fun to drive but costs a lot less to run.


Cactussed

5,364 posts

244 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
Z4M. No brainer, just for the engine.

sidekickdmr

Original Poster:

5,213 posts

237 months

DeadMeat_UK

3,058 posts

313 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
You seem to be more worried about image than what the cars are actually like to drive. I would suggest the BMW in that case.

Otherwise, test drive, see which one "feels" most right. The winner will just reveal itself.

PS It may not help your balanced, personal view, but the Z4M was the most disappointing car I've driven recently. It seems somewhat flat and had little spirit, as well as needing quite a concentrated effort to unlock the performance.


sidekickdmr

Original Poster:

5,213 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
All of you saying I am worried about image couldn't be further from the truth!

Hell I drive a bright orange Nissan and a pug 107.

I just don't like porche or merc unless it's a proper one (e.g. The cayman looks a bit pants but love the 911gt3 RS)


John D.

21,177 posts

240 months

Tuesday 13th December 2011
quotequote all
sidekickdmr said:
All of you saying I am worried about image couldn't be further from the truth!

Hell I drive a bright orange Nissan and a pug 107.

I just don't like porche or merc unless it's a proper one (e.g. The cayman looks a bit pants but love the 911gt3 RS)
laugh