Soft tops in windy weather
Soft tops in windy weather
Author
Discussion

versus

Original Poster:

612 posts

171 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
Whenever it is windy, I seem to hear of at least one death resulting from a tree falling on a car. At the same time I've also seen a dramatic increase in the amount of people buying fabric soft-top convertibles such as the Audi A3 and Mazda MX5s etc.

Whats the general take on the safety of these cars in very bad weather? Is it best not to drive them because if a tree/large object fell on one I think its pretty much game over right?

Craigyp79

618 posts

206 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
Yes, actually don't stop there, if it's even slightly breezy don't leave the house at all just to be on the safe side.

Eighteeteewhy

7,259 posts

191 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
Crazy bunch we are!

I all honesty though if a tree falling kills people in normal cars, does it really make any difference?

nottyash

4,671 posts

218 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
Whats the chances of a meteor landing on your car?
Ban soft tops for being dangerous laugh

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

215 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
That acid rains a bit dodgy aswell.

TameRacingDriver

20,105 posts

295 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
If a tree falls on any car, its game over. By and large, trees are extremely heavy, extremely solid objects that will crush any car to a pulp regardless of what roof it has or hasn't got!

I can't say I've ever noticed an increase in people buying soft tops when its windy either, although I've just bought one and it has been very windy, so you might be on to something tongue out

stackmonkey

5,083 posts

272 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
versus said:
Whenever it is windy, I seem to hear of at least one death resulting from a tree falling on a car. At the same time I've also seen a dramatic increase in the amount of people buying fabric soft-top convertibles such as the Audi A3 and Mazda MX5s etc.

Whats the general take on the safety of these cars in very bad weather? Is it best not to drive them because if a tree/large object fell on one I think its pretty much game over right?
Let's see - you have tree that possibly weighs several tons coming crashing down on you and your car, and you think that a metal or fabric roof is going to make THE difference?? wink

forsure

2,181 posts

291 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
Craigyp79 said:
Yes, actually don't stop there, if it's even slightly breezy don't leave the house at all just to be on the safe side.
Bit risky that, a tree might fall on the house.

NightRunner

12,423 posts

217 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
rolleyes

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

215 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
I had a mate who was asleep in bed and a chimney stack was blown over, through the roof and pinned him to the bed.
Better stay up then.

Craigyp79

618 posts

206 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
stuartmmcfc said:
I had a mate who was asleep in bed and a chimney stack was blown over, through the roof and pinned him to the bed.
Better stay up then.
Did he own a soft top?

VHPD

295 posts

171 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
If you have a canvas style roof just make sure you scotch guard it and all will be fine.
Re apply every 2 years thumbup

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

215 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
no, but he often came for a ride in mine,
I'm a bit worried now incase it was actually meant for me

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

215 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
VHPD said:
If you have a canvas style roof just make sure you scotch guard it and all will be fine.
Re apply every 2 years thumbup
Are we worried about attacks from the Highlands now aswell!

Eighteeteewhy

7,259 posts

191 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
Peugeot thought of this problem a long time ago...


VHPD

295 posts

171 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
stuartmmcfc said:
Are we worried about attacks from the Highlands now aswell!
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/SCOTCHGUARD-FABRIC-STAIN-PROTECTOR-4-CHAIR-SETTEE-SOFA-/140669489788?pt=UK_HomeGarden_CLV_Cleaning_CA&hash=item20c08e127c


smile

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

196 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
stuartmmcfc said:
That acid rains a bit dodgy aswell.
fk me "acid rain", ain't heard those words in ages.
Surprised the eco nuts haven't been using that one more often to frighten people into thinking they'll melt when it rains.

Op when it snowed heavily in 2010/2011 I had a st load of snow on top of the convertible I had at the time (snow is very heavy when compact as people in avalanches find out quickly) it seemed fine in that, I presume a tree would probably just about be too heavy for it though so I sold it yes

page3

5,146 posts

274 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
Eighteeteewhy said:
Peugeot thought of this problem a long time ago...

Hit it with a tree in advance?

Marty63

2,347 posts

197 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
stuartmmcfc said:
I had a mate who was asleep in bed and a chimney stack was blown over, through the roof and pinned him to the bed.
Better stay up then.
He must have used cloth sheets ??

GBDG

896 posts

177 months

Saturday 7th January 2012
quotequote all
To be fair to the OP, this is a serious danger that is underestimated by most people. I myself have already died 3 times this month from trees falling on my convertible. I'm seriously considering a hard top for my next purchase.