Middle Class Scroungers to keep benefits?
Middle Class Scroungers to keep benefits?
Author
Discussion

Fittster

Original Poster:

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
"Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt has said the government is looking at ways to make controversial plans to cut child benefit "fairer".

He spoke as David Cameron also hinted moves to scrap the benefit for families where one parent earns more than about £44,000 a year could be amended.

The PM acknowledged there was an issue with the threshold - amid criticism it unfairly hits single earner families.

But Treasury sources said there had been no change in policy.


http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-16539428

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Oh another U turn

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
What is the OP's view on "fairness".

Is it right that a couple earning combined income of £80,000 can still receive the benefit but a couple with a combined earnings of £45,000 don't?

I genuinely believe that people earning over a certain level should not get this benefit - but the current simplistic plans are extremely unfair and unjust.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Scrounger is a bit harsh.

Child benefit has always been paid regardless of income. They plan is to cut it when earnings hit a certain threshold, which sounds fair enough you could argue.

But I wouldnt call somebody a scrounger for claiming a universal benefit, just because they have a fairly well paid job!

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Jimboka said:
Scrounger is a bit harsh.

Child benefit has always been paid regardless of income. They plan is to cut it when earnings hit a certain threshold, which sounds fair enough you could argue.

But I wouldnt call somebody a scrounger for claiming a universal benefit, just because they have a fairly well paid job!
Correct in theory. But you have read how this cockeyed methodology of assessment is being implemented, I assume?

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
What is the OP's view on "fairness".

Is it right that a couple earning combined income of £80,000 can still receive the benefit but a couple with a combined earnings of £45,000 don't?

I genuinely believe that people earning over a certain level should not get this benefit - but the current simplistic plans are extremely unfair and unjust.
Well said!

Happy82

15,078 posts

200 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Child benefit should be cut for everyone or left as it is, it's unfair to discriminate against those who work hard. If anything, we should be discouraging the workshy from breeding.

Benny Saltstein

809 posts

244 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
I think the government realised this would be a nightmare to implement but I agree its somewhat daft that a household on £80k p/a gets any form of state benefit.

Zaxxon

4,057 posts

191 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Cut child benefits full stop.

You can't afford children? Don't have them.

Also bring in a child license. Some prospective parents should never be allowed to breed.

chimster

1,747 posts

240 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
If this cuts the tax burden then fair enough. I didn't need it when I had kids, so it's fair from my point of view. Why was it provided originally?

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
rhinochopig said:
Eric Mc said:
What is the OP's view on "fairness".

Is it right that a couple earning combined income of £80,000 can still receive the benefit but a couple with a combined earnings of £45,000 don't?

I genuinely believe that people earning over a certain level should not get this benefit - but the current simplistic plans are extremely unfair and unjust.
Well said!
I concur.

And I don't and will not be having any children.

roachcoach

3,975 posts

186 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
You know its a fked up situation when you'd be better off refusing rises/taking a pay cut to not be worse off.

Fittster

Original Poster:

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
What is the OP's view on "fairness".

Is it right that a couple earning combined income of £80,000 can still receive the benefit but a couple with a combined earnings of £45,000 don't?

I genuinely believe that people earning over a certain level should not get this benefit - but the current simplistic plans are extremely unfair and unjust.
I'd remove child benefit completely (along with other vast areas of the welfare state).

Neither the couple with a joint income of 80K or a couple with a single income of 45K should be subsidized by the take payer. If you remove the benefit from the couple with the 45K earner at least you have reduced the problem by 50%.

As for people on 45K whining about 'fairness' of a free taxpayer handout, my answer is ahh, didums.

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
chimster said:
If this cuts the tax burden then fair enough. I didn't need it when I had kids, so it's fair from my point of view. Why was it provided originally?
Missing the point completely. The NOTION of only giving a benefit to someone who needs it is correct.

But the way THIS benefit is being rationed is just plain bonkers.

As I said earlier, some people who are better off will still get it whilst others who are worse off will lose it.

It needs a serious rethink.

roachcoach

3,975 posts

186 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Neither the couple with a joint income of 80K or a couple with a single income of 45K should be subsidized by the take payer.
Its fairly obvious that people in those groups are subsidising the less well off, rather than the other way around.

Someone on 45k pays more tax in two months than a years worth of CB is worth.



ETA: Eric Mc is right here imo. The government reason for the proposed solution is, basically, doing it properly is 'too hard'. That's not a good reason.

Edited by roachcoach on Friday 13th January 10:03

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I think even Milliband would be able to make something of an end to it if that was the way they went.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Jimboka said:
Scrounger is a bit harsh.

Child benefit has always been paid regardless of income. They plan is to cut it when earnings hit a certain threshold, which sounds fair enough you could argue.

But I wouldnt call somebody a scrounger for claiming a universal benefit, just because they have a fairly well paid job!
Correct in theory. But you have read how this cockeyed methodology of assessment is being implemented, I assume?
The methology is a bit cockeyed as you say.
I claimed child benefit from when my children were born, until the max age, which was last year. Under the new proposals I would have lost the benefit, which I couldnt have really complained about in the current climate.
But I did not class myself as a scrounger for claiming universal child benefit for 18ish years! If I was a scrounger, I apologise!

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
roachcoach said:
Fittster said:
Neither the couple with a joint income of 80K or a couple with a single income of 45K should be subsidized by the take payer.
Its fairly obvious that people in those groups are subsidising the less well off, rather than the other way around.

Someone on 45k pays more tax in two months than a years worth of CB is worth.
Exactly. They're not tax scroungers they're working contributors to society, just getting a small tax rebate.

As usual PHers imagine their tax is paying for anyone they disagree with regardless of how much they earn. Life's much easier if you imagine your tax contribution goes towards services you use and benefit from rather than covering all the stuff that upsets you.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
el stovey said:
roachcoach said:
Fittster said:
Neither the couple with a joint income of 80K or a couple with a single income of 45K should be subsidized by the take payer.
Its fairly obvious that people in those groups are subsidising the less well off, rather than the other way around.

Someone on 45k pays more tax in two months than a years worth of CB is worth.
Exactly. They're not tax scroungers they're working contributors to society, just getting a small tax rebate.

As usual PHers imagine their tax is paying for anyone they disagree with regardless of how much they earn. Life's much easier if you imagine your tax contribution goes towards services you use and benefit from rather than covering all the stuff that upsets you.
You've done it now! Cue the impotent indignant rantings of the private health care and private schooling - I hardly use any public services - brigade.

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Friday 13th January 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Quite right.

Hammer those who work hard and do well to pay for those who never have and never will.


Sick.