Heads up , masterchef new series on at nine tonight
Heads up , masterchef new series on at nine tonight
Author
Discussion

jas xjr

Original Poster:

11,309 posts

270 months

Tuesday 17th January 2012
quotequote all
Unfortunately for me with torode in . Will still watch it though smile

CatJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Tuesday 17th January 2012
quotequote all
I'm watching.

Guffy

2,372 posts

296 months

Tuesday 17th January 2012
quotequote all
Big fan of Masterchef and I really liked the Monica/Roux combo of the Professional series, see how they hash this one up now!

GALLARDOGUY

8,160 posts

250 months

Tuesday 17th January 2012
quotequote all
I used to prefer this amateur version, but I like the professional's one more now.

Solely I think due to the expertise and insight of Michel Roux.

Mr Torode is a poor imitation, I'm afraid.

MSport Calendar

13,300 posts

315 months

Wednesday 18th January 2012
quotequote all
The problem I have with Civilian Masterchef is the whole proposition is flawed.

The contestants all witter on that "my life long dream is to be a professional chef", but there aren't really any barriers to entry into the profession other than time and effort.

Every local college runs courses in catering with minimal entry requirements. Then get an entry level job in a restaurant and spend several years 'making your bones' and working your way up the ladder.

The Professional series makes more sense as it's about elevating chefs and their restaurants to 'celebrity chef' and/or Michelin status.

jas xjr

Original Poster:

11,309 posts

270 months

Wednesday 18th January 2012
quotequote all
MSport Calendar said:
The problem I have with Civilian Masterchef is the whole proposition is flawed.

The contestants all witter on that "my life long dream is to be a professional chef", but there aren't really any barriers to entry into the profession other than time and effort.

Every local college runs courses in catering with minimal entry requirements. Then get an entry level job in a restaurant and spend several years 'making your bones' and working your way up the ladder.

The Professional series makes more sense as it's about elevating chefs and their restaurants to 'celebrity chef' and/or Michelin status.
Trouble is everybody wants overnight success . Maybe originally the idea was to find talented home chefs and leave it at that.
The programme is possibly seen as a shortcut to a celebrity / top class career or a basis on which to start a business.
No need to struggle as a sous chef for x amount of years.

Still makes good tv though smile

mercfunder

8,535 posts

204 months

Wednesday 18th January 2012
quotequote all
MSport Calendar said:
The problem I have with Civilian Masterchef is the whole proposition is flawed.

The contestants all witter on that "my life long dream is to be a professional chef", but there aren't really any barriers to entry into the profession other than time and effort.

Every local college runs courses in catering with minimal entry requirements. Then get an entry level job in a restaurant and spend several years 'making your bones' and working your way up the ladder.
But "cooking" is the new rock and roll!

I agree if you wanted it that badly you would quit your job and go and do it,but it all adds to the heavily manufactured drama that is this show, personally I struggle to watch it without thinking of the John Culshaw piss-take of it.

Nom de ploom

4,890 posts

205 months

Wednesday 18th January 2012
quotequote all
i had this argument with the missus last night when I said I'd liek to go on it just to see if I can win it.

I've not ambitions to be a professional chef. and she was like, well thats the whole point of winning it so you can be a chef in a restaurant.

no it isn't. x-factor is about "winning" a recording contract. masterchef is about winning masterchef imho.

just because most of the ppl on it want to cook professionally is irrelevant.