Could a Porsche last 24 hours?
Could a Porsche last 24 hours?
Author
Discussion

RichB

Original Poster:

56,206 posts

313 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
Just saw Johnny Senna's post about TVRs and track days, which got me thinking... I recently saw 2 x TVRs complete the Le Mans 24 hour race, so a 100% record there then. At the same race I notice several Porsches fail before the completion of 24 hours. Are they are not as reliable as I understood? Rich...

N17 TVR

2,937 posts

300 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
And watch out for those clutches on the Boxster 'S' !

They had a 100% failure on the Drivel programme a few years ago - far better to buy a Tamora, they had 100% reliability.

German technology - "well known" for being unreliable !

DustyC

12,822 posts

283 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
Dose der Würmer hat geöffnet

fatbuttfast

136 posts

290 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
RichB said:
At the same race I notice several Porsches fail before the completion of 24 hours. Are they are not as reliable as I understood? Rich...


Your right those Porsche GT3's are crap after all they only took the first six places in the Le Mans GT class

cuzza

2,042 posts

282 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
Hardly fair!

TVR got 2/2 home but, the first one was 27 laps behind the Porsche that won the class (almost certainly due to time in pits being fixed)

Porsche got 7/11 cars home. They took the top six places in the class.

Ferrari got 1/2 cars home but finished 16 laps behind the winning Porsche.

The Morgan finished but was so far back it was unclassified.

I think it's a fantastic engineering feat to get these cars to do 300+ laps of the track, flat out and still be running at the end.

Well done TVR for getting to the end this year and having the best looking car there. Well done Porsche - still the benchmark.

sacha

509 posts

283 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
how many porsche retirements??? 30%?? tvr 100% finishing record!!

GregE240

10,857 posts

296 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
N17 TVR said:
And watch out for those clutches on the Boxster 'S' !

They had a 100% failure on the Drivel programme a few years ago - far better to buy a Tamora, they had 100% reliability.

German technology - "well known" for being unreliable !
Change the record mate.

N17 TVR

2,937 posts

300 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
cuzza said:

TVR got 2/2 home but, the first one was 27 laps behind the Porsche that won the class (almost certainly due to time in pits being fixed)


I wonder how much the difference in R&D + race budget had to do with it as well ?



N17 TVR

2,937 posts

300 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
GregE240 said:

N17 TVR said:
And watch out for those clutches on the Boxster 'S' !

They had a 100% failure on the Drivel programme a few years ago - far better to buy a Tamora, they had 100% reliability.

German technology - "well known" for being unreliable !

Change the record mate.


Happy to Greg, as long as the '12' inch re-mix of "all TVR's are unreliable" gets to gather some dust as well.

It's all tongue in cheek, but I am amazed that you are still so touchy about something that wasn't even shown.....

RUSSELLM

6,002 posts

276 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
If we're talking reliability, my missus's 1.1 litre rover metro has just completed 60,000 miles on it's first engine,

I reckon it would piss 300 laps round some french fields

RUSSELLM

6,002 posts

276 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
It is a 24 "week" race isn't it ?

cuzza

2,042 posts

282 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
N17 TVR said:

cuzza said:

TVR got 2/2 home but, the first one was 27 laps behind the Porsche that won the class (almost certainly due to time in pits being fixed)



I wonder how much the difference in R&D + race budget had to do with it as well ?





Probably quite a bit!!

I was trying to point out that even though they got both cars home which is obviously quite important this is a race and they were miles behind.

Do you honestly think that if 11 TVRs started the race, they'd all finish?

RichB

Original Poster:

56,206 posts

313 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
cuzza said:
Do you honestly think that if 11 TVRs started the race, they'd all finish?
Do you honestly think I expected anyone to take the thread seriously? Rich...

N17 TVR

2,937 posts

300 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
Oh god, now you are invoking the law of averages, statistics, diminishing returns etc.

On the basis that 2 out of 2 finished = 100% reliability, why shouldn't 11 ?

I assume that someone with a better grasp of maths will have a good reason

p.s. we are meeting up with some of the Morgan boys tomorrow, so i can ask them the same question


RichB

Original Poster:

56,206 posts

313 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
N17 TVR said:
we are meeting up with some of the Morgan boys tomorrow, so i can ask them the same question
No, ask them if they can run thier engines on Ribena with a dash of petrol mixed in? Apparently it didn't run out fuel at the top of Mulsanne but the driver did need some refreshment after spending 3 x hours trying to get it re-started. Urr hummph! Rich...

cuzza

2,042 posts

282 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
RichB said:

Do you honestly think I expected anyone to take the thread seriously? Rich...


Sorry - am taking everything a bit seriously today

granville

18,764 posts

290 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
N17 TVR said:
...I am amazed that you are still so touchy about something that wasn't even shown.....


Perhaps I can explain the tetchiness?

Said mockney rebel has suffered something beyond ignominy today; something so degrading and unthinkable that even mockular contemplation of it's implications could have one cast down into a frenzied whirlpool of mental self-loathing, pity and ultimately, destruction.

Due to the Marxist-Leninists controlling his region's Highway Agency, Sir Thomas has had to stoop lower than man has ever gone this very morn...

He took the train.

Greg, we fortunate vermin du nord will toast your speedy recovery this evensong and trust in the power of prayer that this travesty of transportational affliction is but a brief abberration in a sea of otherwise perfectly maintained car-shod coneyance.

You capitulating peasant.

N17 TVR

2,937 posts

300 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
RichB said:

Apparently it didn't run out fuel at the top of Mulsanne but the driver did need some refreshment after spending 3 x hours trying to get it re-started. Urr hummph! Rich...


The Morgan pits did get the award for Best Support & Prep of the car (which is why it spent 3 hours parked on the Mulsanne )..........oh' and also for having drivers with urine rated at 97 octane.


N17 TVR

2,937 posts

300 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
derestrictor said:


He took the train.



Ah, that explains it then..........

....it wasnt because the Porsche was broken was it

Sorry Greg, I'm already reaching for the coat

gary_tholl

1,013 posts

299 months

Wednesday 7th July 2004
quotequote all
cuzza said:
Hardly fair!

TVR got 2/2 home but, the first one was 27 laps behind the Porsche that won the class (almost certainly due to time in pits being fixed)



Uh, 27 laps over 24 hours is 1.125 laps down per hour, at (approx) 4 min per lap means that each hour the first TVR lost only 4.5 minutes on average to the fastest Porsche. Which works out to being 92.5% as fast as the Porsche. I know, I know, lies, damn lies, and statistics and all that... still you get the idea.

I'd say that is pretty damn good for their second year there. I also believe that they are still running smaller restrictors and ballast (not sure on that), due to not having sold enough road cars.

Now, if you consider how much time, money, effort, and experience has gone into Porsche racing compared to the Tivs... I would guess that the TVR's will be fighting the top Porsches in the next few years for class wins. Here's hoping anyway.

Gary