What large well appointed Family Saloon up to £9k?

What large well appointed Family Saloon up to £9k?

Author
Discussion

Hobzy

Original Poster:

1,271 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Do approx 20k miles a year; Mostly 30 mile commute on the A3 into Portsmouth and 2 weekends a month we do 100 mile plus journeys to see family. Have between £7500 and £9000. We have had a Mazda 6 2.0 diesel for 4 years but DMF/clutch has now gone. Like the Passat but lots of scare stories. Would like something that has reasonable pace mid gear. I am assuming Diesel but am open to leftfield idea if I can get them past the Missus biggrin looking has been a minefield so far as every option seems to have an expensive issue looming just over 100k -

Is the day of the bargain diesel over with all these DMF failures?

Cheers in advance - over to you...

Edited by Hobzy on Sunday 5th February 21:00


Edited by Hobzy on Sunday 5th February 21:11

BERGS2

2,802 posts

248 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
distinctly left field, but:

}Nissan

i ran one of these last year -

very, very comfy place to be.
Awesome toys
MPG could hit 30 if driven light footed
tax isn't as bad as later (post '06?) models
lacks the chav bling of an old X5 or similar

i could easily talk myself into getting another one.

if you can live without needing too quick a car, and the mpg is not vital - id say you can do far worse...

Andy665

3,627 posts

228 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Lexus GS300 - comfortable, well equipped and what you lose in economy is more than made up for in bulletproof reliability

Hobzy

Original Poster:

1,271 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
BERGS2 said:
distinctly left field, but:

}Nissan

i ran one of these last year -

very, very comfy place to be.
Awesome toys
MPG could hit 30 if driven light footed
tax isn't as bad as later (post '06?) models
lacks the chav bling of an old X5 or similar

i could easily talk myself into getting another one.

if you can live without needing too quick a car, and the mpg is not vital - id say you can do far worse...
Hoping for better mpg than that, over 40mpg if poss, but thanks for the suggestion smile

EDLT

15,421 posts

206 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
£5k LS400 + A lot of petrol money?

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

188 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
BMW 5 series, petrol, definately not diesel though ?

NadiR

1,071 posts

147 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
BMW 5 series, there's plenty to choose from in your price bracket, whether you want an older 535d/530i or newer facelift 520d, and you can choose from SE or M Sport depending on whether you want comfort or sports suspension.

edit
Beaten to it

Hobzy

Original Poster:

1,271 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
£5k LS400 + A lot of petrol money?
This is the problem, you see. After a 3 series with a fatal camshaft sensor failure, and now the mazda (which ran perfectly until first the vacuum valve went and now the clutch) , her indoors is paranoid about getting somethingover 5yrs old and nr 100k. I'm more open to bangernomics for a barge. The gs looks lovely though, but insurance/tax must be immense.


Edited by Hobzy on Sunday 5th February 22:29

frosted

3,549 posts

177 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
08+ passats don't have many issues, my car on nearly 100k just had all injectors and loom replaced by vw for free, didn't even asked about service history or anything like that .

I would go for a quattro 3l tdi a6

Rich1973

1,198 posts

177 months

Hobzy

Original Poster:

1,271 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
When i say pace, it doesnt need to be bonkers fast - got the kit car for that. I just like a bit ofin gear oomph changing lanes wink mpg does need to be high 30s for a petrol and 40s for a smoker.

Hobzy

Original Poster:

1,271 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Rich1973 said:
Do they get anywhere near their claimed mpg?

Funnily enough i did show the boss one and she thought it was a bit old man, i liked it!

Rich1973

1,198 posts

177 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Clarkson seemed to do pretty well with one!!
Not sure - I have a XJR

Zwolf

25,867 posts

206 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
E61 530i SE Touring Manual

1 non smoking/non dog-owning owner with FBMWSH, only 66k miles and still eligible to be covered by BMW warranty if you wish. 2005, so should have the later, more powerful and more efficient Valvetronic six-pot.


Hobzy

Original Poster:

1,271 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Zwolf said:
E61 530i SE Touring Manual

1 non smoking/non dog-owning owner with FBMWSH, only 66k miles and still eligible to be covered by BMW warranty if you wish. 2005, so should have the later, more powerful and more efficient Valvetronic six-pot.

Thats lovely, but probably dont need the estate.

Theres some great options coming up - I love PH! But can peeps mention pitfalls if they know them please :-)?

Matt UK

17,709 posts

200 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Great that you are putting in some leg-work, but suggest your wife gets a user name so we can discuss directly with the decision maker wink

VidalBaboon

9,074 posts

215 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Buy a diesel that's had the DMF replaced recently?

I'd go for an A6 Avant 2.7TDi. Maybe a Le Mans if they're that cheap. Plenty of toys, heated steering wheel & seats. Lovely!

Hobzy

Original Poster:

1,271 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Bugger, sussed tongue out.

She drove an 08 2.0 passat yesterday, and liked it. I think there are more options as proved above. After 3 days of legwork I thought i'd throw it over to you lot...

craigjm

17,957 posts

200 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Rich1973 said:
This would also be my suggestion

Zwolf

25,867 posts

206 months

Sunday 5th February 2012
quotequote all
Skoda Superb

Better looking and less ubiquitous than a Passat, nicer inside too. Figures look like 30-50 mpg for the petrol.