£20k to replace a 350Z?
£20k to replace a 350Z?
Author
Discussion

Legend83

Original Poster:

10,413 posts

243 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Hi all,

My brother in law is looking to move on from his much loved 350Z. He wants something similar that will get him reliably to the airport (pilot) on time! He was looking at Tuscan's but decided he needs something a little more usable everyday.

So far he has only really considered the Z4C but I was thinking a 911 (996) might be in budget. Any other possibilities?

Donatello

1,035 posts

182 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
370Z?

LuS1fer

43,110 posts

266 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Mustang or Corvette? Possibly a pain if he has any tolls/barriers to operate.

SuperVM

1,098 posts

182 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
996 Turbos are about £20k for an older one, aren't they? I'm guessing he probably wants something newer than his 350Z though.

PaperCut

640 posts

168 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Cayman S?

Legend83

Original Poster:

10,413 posts

243 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Donatello said:
370Z?
Nice but I think he wants similar buy different.

Cayman is a good shout, can you get an S for £20k

kambites

70,372 posts

242 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Cayman S or Z4M are probably the two obvious ones, depending on his preferred driving style.

IMO the 911 doesn't drive as well as the Cayman so it's a bit pointless unless you need the extra seats.

rajkohli81

311 posts

227 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
997s are being offered around the trade for c£20k...e92 M3s.. SL55 AMG

Agreed Cayman S is definitely a contender though

PaperCut

640 posts

168 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Legend83 said:
Cayman is a good shout, can you get an S for £20k
Wee bit over budget, but Porsche dealer - http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3412167.htm

Plenty cheaper ones from independents and private sellers. I would have one over an older 996 personally.

I would have recommended an E46 M3 CS, but if he doesn't need the seats then Porsche would be best.

Donatello

1,035 posts

182 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Legend83 said:
Nice but I think he wants similar buy different.

Cayman is a good shout, can you get an S for £20k
The 370Z really appeals to me, I think they look lovely. Mind you, I would have huge difficulty choosing one over a Z4M or a Cayman S. Not a bad decision to be making though!

jon-

16,534 posts

237 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
A very cheap e90 M3 is a logical next step.

Parsnip

3,196 posts

209 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Would definatley be a considering a Cayman S - have driven a colleagues and it is a scalpel to the zeds sledgehammer - much more grown up and certainly more civilised, but still has the same sort of insistent feeling that it wants to be going quicker. Should be able to get a decent one for 20k with a little light haggling.

My other choice would be an XKR, but I imagine if you are talking about 911s, he is after something a bit less practical and a little more loony. May also struggle to get one in budget (from my very brief look at them)



Edited by Parsnip on Thursday 9th February 16:07

RichTBiscuit

433 posts

172 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Z4M? quicker than the zed are quite rare.

Herbs

4,995 posts

250 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Three cars on the list for me:

Porsche 911 C4S Widebody
BMW Z4M
BMW M6

All within budget and great in their own right smile

RichTBiscuit

433 posts

172 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
Slightly left field this one... But save up another 5k or so and get Maserati Gransport evil

bobbylondonuk

2,204 posts

211 months

Thursday 9th February 2012
quotequote all
I had a 350z for 3 yrs...During that time I had the chance to drive a cayman 2.9 for a couple of weeks.

OP you wont be disappointed with the cayman. Compared to the 350z having brute force and heavy controls, massive grip and a butch feel to it which I loved, the cayman was the opposite! It had nimble handling, light but sure footed, brilliant brakes and steering and a sensation completely opposite to the muscle car feel of the Z.

Both are excellent and lovely to own...it will be a good experience if you are finally moving from the Z

Legend83

Original Poster:

10,413 posts

243 months

Tuesday 17th April 2012
quotequote all
To tie this thread up, my BIL ended up getting a lovely 55 plate Cayman S in metallic grey. It seems to have all the toys except the PSE which I have told him he has to get!

He kindly let me have a drive and I am officially a Porsche convert - it is an incredible car. It is like my S/C MX5 on steroids - beautiful handling and instant throttle response. It was seriously addictive and I felt bad putting my foot down all the time!

He says a big thanks for the suggestion!

PaperCut

640 posts

168 months

Tuesday 17th April 2012
quotequote all
Legend83 said:
He says a big thanks for the suggestion!
Stop, you're making me blush!

Well done to him thumbup

lestershaw

1,591 posts

179 months

Tuesday 17th April 2012
quotequote all
6.0 Monaro
quick
handles well
sounds great
and would have some change for fuel and insurance

V6Alfisti

3,313 posts

248 months

Tuesday 17th April 2012
quotequote all
To throw something different into the sea of Porsche's and I faced a similar dilemma.

Maserati 4200 - Proven Maserati mechanics and far more durable than the 3200 or their reputation would have you believe.

EDIT: Just noticed the BIL has spoken wink

Edited by V6Alfisti on Tuesday 17th April 15:23