Is this a super car? Only you lot can say really...
Discussion
I embroiled myself in quite a long winded argument with my younger brother last night, which has now spilled into the TGL office this morning all over the following question: Is an Audi R8 a supercar?
I thought there was no better, or more impartial place to ask this question that this forum.
My feeling is that it's mid-engine layout, two seats, low slung design coupled with a piece of glass mounted over the engine and a £100K price tag makes it a super car. However, only the very bottom rung of super cars, in the same way that a Mazda MX-5 is a sportscar, but for me only the bottom rung.
The arguments include its rivals like the 911 and XKR are sportscars, not super cars, and even range as wide as 'can a manufacturer who makes A3s and A4s ever make a super car?'
But then would you count a LF-A as a super car, even though Lexus made it?
The traditional super cars of old; Diablos and 355s have been overtaken by their younger siblings (Aventador, Enzo) in a new so called 'hyper car' class - so could an R8 be a junior super car? leaving the super car class to 458s and MP4-12Cs?
I thought there was no better, or more impartial place to ask this question that this forum.
My feeling is that it's mid-engine layout, two seats, low slung design coupled with a piece of glass mounted over the engine and a £100K price tag makes it a super car. However, only the very bottom rung of super cars, in the same way that a Mazda MX-5 is a sportscar, but for me only the bottom rung.
The arguments include its rivals like the 911 and XKR are sportscars, not super cars, and even range as wide as 'can a manufacturer who makes A3s and A4s ever make a super car?'
But then would you count a LF-A as a super car, even though Lexus made it?
The traditional super cars of old; Diablos and 355s have been overtaken by their younger siblings (Aventador, Enzo) in a new so called 'hyper car' class - so could an R8 be a junior super car? leaving the super car class to 458s and MP4-12Cs?
If an R8 is not a super car then nor is a Gallardo, the R8 V10 is effectively a Gallardo in drag. From personal exp I would say it is actually the better road car. Where it sits in the hierarchy? I would say it’s a junior super car along with its contempory's. But the game has moved on, we now have the MP4-12C and the 458 that have moved that sector upmarket in price and to much higher performance level where the lines between junior and full fat super car have become very blurred.
Within two years the new R8 will be out and will again take the fight to the likes of McLaren and Ferrari. In theory they will also be joined by a new Gallardo.
But here’s the thing the new 911 is apparently very good with performance very close to the last generation of Ferrari's and Lambo's. This car will be joined by the entry level McLaren which will form the basis of the junior super car ranks. So I think we are now looking at a three tier setup. Hyper cars including the likes of the Aventador and the new Enzo at the top, the 458, MP4, new Gallardo and new R8 in the middle with the 911, entry level Mac and the new R4 bringing up the rear
Within two years the new R8 will be out and will again take the fight to the likes of McLaren and Ferrari. In theory they will also be joined by a new Gallardo.
But here’s the thing the new 911 is apparently very good with performance very close to the last generation of Ferrari's and Lambo's. This car will be joined by the entry level McLaren which will form the basis of the junior super car ranks. So I think we are now looking at a three tier setup. Hyper cars including the likes of the Aventador and the new Enzo at the top, the 458, MP4, new Gallardo and new R8 in the middle with the 911, entry level Mac and the new R4 bringing up the rear
Angelis said:
For me 50% of a supercar is the performance and 50% the looks and for me the Audi lacks the latter.
I have to admit that the looks of the Gallardo do nothing for me; does that mean I do not regard it as a junior supercar? The answer to that would be no. I appreciate it for what it is; I just don’t like it personallyThe term 'supercar' was invented by the late great LJK Setright. He was a brillaint motoring journalist from the 60/70/80/90's. mainly wrote for Car magazine but others too both here and the US.
His definition was applied to the then crop of high performance cars such as the daytona, bora, countach etc
His justiciation, was a car which excelled and led in performance and handling.
Consequenlty if we were to try to apply that justification, then the R8 clearly comes within that definition.
His definition was applied to the then crop of high performance cars such as the daytona, bora, countach etc
His justiciation, was a car which excelled and led in performance and handling.
Consequenlty if we were to try to apply that justification, then the R8 clearly comes within that definition.
johns355 said:
It's an expensive Audi- not a supercar! To say the older supercars have been overtaken by the newer hyper-cars is wrong- they're just newer supercars! Just because they're quicker doesn't make them any better supercar IMO. I personally feel it's all about the breeding!!
Ok if we apply your logic how would rate a GTR. It has super car beating performance, history and breeding, a great deal of which is steaped in very sucessful racing that makes Lamborghini's efforts look a little limp.The thing is the word "Supercar" has never been properly defined. When LJK Setright invented the term he had no idea how the sector was going to develop. Hot hatches now have performance that would shame the LJK era supercars. Defining the sector now I think is almost impossible
Thanks for the link 70Proof - after reading 6 pages of arguing, I think I've realised that there isn't one right answer. One chap was even arguing that a 458 wasn't a super car, which would be news to Ferrari and anyone who's dropped £200K on one...
Interesting that the divider for most people on the is/isn't it a supercar in relation to the R8 is its engine. Strange that a sportscar could transform into a super car simply by adding a larger engine, and some visual tweaks most members of the public couldn't spot. Which I suppose is my point, a C63 AMG isn't a super car even though its had a unique engine added - the R8 has everything you broadly ask of a super car, then you add the Lambo derived V10 and you're there, surely?
Interesting that the divider for most people on the is/isn't it a supercar in relation to the R8 is its engine. Strange that a sportscar could transform into a super car simply by adding a larger engine, and some visual tweaks most members of the public couldn't spot. Which I suppose is my point, a C63 AMG isn't a super car even though its had a unique engine added - the R8 has everything you broadly ask of a super car, then you add the Lambo derived V10 and you're there, surely?
Edited by topgeartowers on Friday 10th February 16:03
Edited by topgeartowers on Friday 10th February 16:04
topgeartowers said:
Thanks for the link 70Proof - after reading 6 pages of arguing, I think I've realised that there isn't one right answer. One chap was even arguing that a 458 wasn't a super car, which would be news to Ferrari and anyone who's dropped £200K on one...
Interesting that the divider for most people on the is/isn't it a supercar in relation to the R8 is its engine. Strange that a sportscar could transform into a super car simply by adding a larger engine, and some visual tweaks most members of the public couldn't spot. Which I suppose is my point, a C63 AMG isn't a super car even though its had a unique engine added - the R8 has everything you broadly ask of a super car, then you add the Lambo derived V10 and you're there, surely?
I only say the V10 is and the V8 isn't for me because the V10 adds character to the R8. The noise of that engine from an LP560 is awesome, the slight visual tweaks make it a bit better looking too. But yes, IMO the V10 engine adds character to it. Interesting that the divider for most people on the is/isn't it a supercar in relation to the R8 is its engine. Strange that a sportscar could transform into a super car simply by adding a larger engine, and some visual tweaks most members of the public couldn't spot. Which I suppose is my point, a C63 AMG isn't a super car even though its had a unique engine added - the R8 has everything you broadly ask of a super car, then you add the Lambo derived V10 and you're there, surely?
Edited by topgeartowers on Friday 10th February 16:03
Edited by topgeartowers on Friday 10th February 16:04

R8 is a supercar. Mid engined, exotic looks, V8 or V10 engine. Price tag circa £100k +. 355, 430, SLS, Gallardo also in this category. Its easy to tell the difference between a supercar or hypercar and normal sports cars really as a 5 year old kid will look at these types of cars and say, "daddy lets sell the 911 right now and go and buy one in orange for you and yellow for me"!
I wouldn't even attach "junior" supercar to cars like the 458, MC12 - they're £200k - maybe they're junior hypercars?!
911 is a sports car inc the turbo - its just a fast 911. It happens to be as capable as a few supercars with the practicality of child seats. Same with GTR, Maserati Gransport.
Aventador, Enzo, 918. CGT, Pagani, Koenigseggy, Diablo, Murci, F40, Jag XJ220, 959 are proper hypercars - in their day they were the ultimate.
I wouldn't even attach "junior" supercar to cars like the 458, MC12 - they're £200k - maybe they're junior hypercars?!
911 is a sports car inc the turbo - its just a fast 911. It happens to be as capable as a few supercars with the practicality of child seats. Same with GTR, Maserati Gransport.
Aventador, Enzo, 918. CGT, Pagani, Koenigseggy, Diablo, Murci, F40, Jag XJ220, 959 are proper hypercars - in their day they were the ultimate.
IMI A said:
R8 is a supercar. Mid engined, exotic looks, V8 or V10 engine. Price tag circa £100k +. 355, 430, SLS, Gallardo also in this category. Its easy to tell the difference between a supercar or hypercar and normal sports cars really as a 5 year old kid will look at these types of cars and say, "daddy lets sell the 911 right now and go and buy one in orange for you and yellow for me"!
I wouldn't even attach "junior" supercar to cars like the 458, MC12 - they're £200k - maybe they're junior hypercars?!
911 is a sports car inc the turbo - its just a fast 911. It happens to be as capable as a few supercars with the practicality of child seats. Same with GTR, Maserati Gransport.
Aventador, Enzo, 918. CGT, Pagani, Koenigseggy, Diablo, Murci, F40, Jag XJ220, 959 are proper hypercars - in their day they were the ultimate.
Lol 355, 430...£100k plus..then you say that the 911 turbo (£100k+) doesn't fall into the 'Supercar' category....oh and the SLS is front-engined....I wouldn't even attach "junior" supercar to cars like the 458, MC12 - they're £200k - maybe they're junior hypercars?!
911 is a sports car inc the turbo - its just a fast 911. It happens to be as capable as a few supercars with the practicality of child seats. Same with GTR, Maserati Gransport.
Aventador, Enzo, 918. CGT, Pagani, Koenigseggy, Diablo, Murci, F40, Jag XJ220, 959 are proper hypercars - in their day they were the ultimate.
it's subjective to a huge degree...if Audi had badged the R8 as a Lamborgini, no one would have thought twice about it being classed as a 'HyperCar'...or 'Supercar'...my personal view? The term 'Supercar' is dead...
rubystone said:
IMI A said:
R8 is a supercar. Mid engined, exotic looks, V8 or V10 engine. Price tag circa £100k +. 355, 430, SLS, Gallardo also in this category. Its easy to tell the difference between a supercar or hypercar and normal sports cars really as a 5 year old kid will look at these types of cars and say, "daddy lets sell the 911 right now and go and buy one in orange for you and yellow for me"!
I wouldn't even attach "junior" supercar to cars like the 458, MC12 - they're £200k - maybe they're junior hypercars?!
911 is a sports car inc the turbo - its just a fast 911. It happens to be as capable as a few supercars with the practicality of child seats. Same with GTR, Maserati Gransport.
Aventador, Enzo, 918. CGT, Pagani, Koenigseggy, Diablo, Murci, F40, Jag XJ220, 959 are proper hypercars - in their day they were the ultimate.
Lol 355, 430...£100k plus..then you say that the 911 turbo (£100k+) doesn't fall into the 'Supercar' category....oh and the SLS is front-engined....I wouldn't even attach "junior" supercar to cars like the 458, MC12 - they're £200k - maybe they're junior hypercars?!
911 is a sports car inc the turbo - its just a fast 911. It happens to be as capable as a few supercars with the practicality of child seats. Same with GTR, Maserati Gransport.
Aventador, Enzo, 918. CGT, Pagani, Koenigseggy, Diablo, Murci, F40, Jag XJ220, 959 are proper hypercars - in their day they were the ultimate.
it's subjective to a huge degree...if Audi had badged the R8 as a Lamborgini, no one would have thought twice about it being classed as a 'HyperCar'...or 'Supercar'...my personal view? The term 'Supercar' is dead...
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



