Am I doomed to remain Ferrari-less?
Discussion
Have been trying to buy a Ferrari for the past few months but everytime I get close it all goes pear-shaped.
First attempt was for a 16M. OK, not very close. Made a low offer to someone emigrating that they didn't accept.
Second attempt was for a CS. Roughly agreed price with seller (subject to inspection). Car had just had service with cam belts. Seller acts all innocent, saying car is perfect. But when I speak to dealer that did the service they tell me the rear brake discs need replacing (5000). So no deal.
Third attempt: see another CS at a specialist. Like the car. See it three times and drive it. When I sit down to do the deal the seller tells me the car had been in a front end smash. Lovely. No deal.
Fourth attempt. Another CS. This time I get the car inspected by F dealer. All ok except all four brake discs need replacing! But: seller agrees reduction in price to cover brakes. Deal back on. Purchase going to happen tomorrow. Then: someone I know on another forum alerts me that the car has also had damage in the past. Really annoyed that it wasn't picked up in the inspection. Confront seller: yes, first owner had had panel damage. Grrrrr. Deal off!
Is there some higher power at work here (god of Porsche?), trying to prevent me from buying my first Ferrari?
First attempt was for a 16M. OK, not very close. Made a low offer to someone emigrating that they didn't accept.
Second attempt was for a CS. Roughly agreed price with seller (subject to inspection). Car had just had service with cam belts. Seller acts all innocent, saying car is perfect. But when I speak to dealer that did the service they tell me the rear brake discs need replacing (5000). So no deal.
Third attempt: see another CS at a specialist. Like the car. See it three times and drive it. When I sit down to do the deal the seller tells me the car had been in a front end smash. Lovely. No deal.
Fourth attempt. Another CS. This time I get the car inspected by F dealer. All ok except all four brake discs need replacing! But: seller agrees reduction in price to cover brakes. Deal back on. Purchase going to happen tomorrow. Then: someone I know on another forum alerts me that the car has also had damage in the past. Really annoyed that it wasn't picked up in the inspection. Confront seller: yes, first owner had had panel damage. Grrrrr. Deal off!
Is there some higher power at work here (god of Porsche?), trying to prevent me from buying my first Ferrari?
Nope,
Standard stuff with buying cars in general.
One thing though, what constitutes a 'smash' bad parking, 10mph or something worse?
A lot of these cars will have been driven and at some point will have been the victim of errors of judgement.
If they are up front, if the car is repaired perfectly and you take it on at the right price then is it worth considering?
Otherwise keep searching, there are perfect undamaged cars out there, but it's rare you'll find something with that level of tech that wont need something doing. especially brakes which are (even carbons) wear items.
Standard stuff with buying cars in general.
One thing though, what constitutes a 'smash' bad parking, 10mph or something worse?
A lot of these cars will have been driven and at some point will have been the victim of errors of judgement.
If they are up front, if the car is repaired perfectly and you take it on at the right price then is it worth considering?
Otherwise keep searching, there are perfect undamaged cars out there, but it's rare you'll find something with that level of tech that wont need something doing. especially brakes which are (even carbons) wear items.
As has been suggested, you may need to rethink your expectations. Any car of that vintage is going to need some kind of work Realistically no one is going to sell a car that has everything done without adding a premium to the price, particularly with the more exotic variants like CS's
Everyone wants a "perfect' car, but it comes at a price.
Best of luck with your first F car, it will have been worth the wait I'm sure.
Regards,
Neil
Everyone wants a "perfect' car, but it comes at a price.
Best of luck with your first F car, it will have been worth the wait I'm sure.
Regards,
Neil
I take the point about perfection having a price but my main problem is sellers lying or hiding defects. I am ok about buying a car that needs work (not accident damaged as I fear it would make th car even more difficult to resell) but I am not ok agreeing a price on the basis of the car having no defects when the seller knows it is not true.
Perhaps the accident damage wasn't too bad on CS number three but I lost confidence in the seller.
Hopefully it will be worthwhile. Just really p***** off yesterday as was really excited about buying the car today.
Perhaps the accident damage wasn't too bad on CS number three but I lost confidence in the seller.
Hopefully it will be worthwhile. Just really p***** off yesterday as was really excited about buying the car today.
Is brake disc wear a defect?
Brake disc wear is, in my limited experience with Porsche, something dealers focus quite pedantically on. It's an easy sale for them, and a lucrative one. Not saying the second car you saw didn't need rear brakes doing, but could they have lasted until the next service, or a few months into ownership?
They are also, as highlighted, a wear item not a defect.
Perhaps you should've bought the second car?
Brake disc wear is, in my limited experience with Porsche, something dealers focus quite pedantically on. It's an easy sale for them, and a lucrative one. Not saying the second car you saw didn't need rear brakes doing, but could they have lasted until the next service, or a few months into ownership?
They are also, as highlighted, a wear item not a defect.
Perhaps you should've bought the second car?
The rear discs were not worn, rather there was a problem with the structure of the carbon ceramic discs. Car had been used on track (just once) but it can happen. Same with the third CS. F dealer said that could result in failure. With such cars th brakes and tyres are most important items and not prepared to skimp on them. With new rear discs car would have been too expensive for mileage and private sale.
Bad luck Schnellmann.
I do agree with you that people should be upfront about issues and in particular previous damage needs to be disclosed. I would also be very reluctant to buy a car if the seller had not disclosed everything.
The right car is out there. Just have to keep looking.
Onno
I do agree with you that people should be upfront about issues and in particular previous damage needs to be disclosed. I would also be very reluctant to buy a car if the seller had not disclosed everything.
The right car is out there. Just have to keep looking.
Onno
Schnellmann said:
...With new rear discs car would have been too expensive for mileage and private sale.
Judging by your expectations with the others, would it have been though?Personally I think CS prices are a tad stiff at present. But it looks like they all have issues that you don't want to contend with (which is perfectly fair enough).
Assuming the car needing brakes ticked all the other boxes that the others didn't, is that worth the differential to you once the brakes are fixed? After all, discs are wear items. But a car that's been accident damaged will always have that status.
Also...if you only ever want to pay xx under what cars are available for, I fear you'll be Ferrari-less for a very long time. Perhaps your experiences to date are indicating that you're a bit shy of the market price wise...?
willy wombat said:
Given your problems acquiring your first Ferrari, maybe you need to change your user name to notsoschnellmann (and then change it back when you make that first F car purchase).
I still have the 993 so not necessary. Still, when i get an F I could change it to nochschnellermann 
Murph7355 said:
Judging by your expectations with the others, would it have been though?
Personally I think CS prices are a tad stiff at present. But it looks like they all have issues that you don't want to contend with (which is perfectly fair enough).
Assuming the car needing brakes ticked all the other boxes that the others didn't, is that worth the differential to you once the brakes are fixed? After all, discs are wear items. But a car that's been accident damaged will always have that status.
Also...if you only ever want to pay xx under what cars are available for, I fear you'll be Ferrari-less for a very long time. Perhaps your experiences to date are indicating that you're a bit shy of the market price wise...?
Car needing rear brakes also needed full respray of front end because of stone chips and bad scrape to front bumper. I figured that into price and it woud have been around CHF 110'000. But with rear brakes it woud have been CHF 119'000. My base case (and the car I will most likely buy on Tuesday if I don't have another problem!) is a red CS at a F dealer at CHF 125'000. At 110'000 a private buy made sense but at 118'000 I think better to pay extra for lower mileage dealer car. Just the way I see it of course. Personally I think CS prices are a tad stiff at present. But it looks like they all have issues that you don't want to contend with (which is perfectly fair enough).
Assuming the car needing brakes ticked all the other boxes that the others didn't, is that worth the differential to you once the brakes are fixed? After all, discs are wear items. But a car that's been accident damaged will always have that status.
Also...if you only ever want to pay xx under what cars are available for, I fear you'll be Ferrari-less for a very long time. Perhaps your experiences to date are indicating that you're a bit shy of the market price wise...?
Schnellmann said:
Have been trying to buy a Ferrari for the past few months but everytime I get close it all goes pear-shaped.
First attempt was for a 16M. OK, not very close. Made a low offer to someone emigrating that they didn't accept.
Second attempt was for a CS. Roughly agreed price with seller (subject to inspection). Car had just had service with cam belts. Seller acts all innocent, saying car is perfect. But when I speak to dealer that did the service they tell me the rear brake discs need replacing (5000). So no deal.
Third attempt: see another CS at a specialist. Like the car. See it three times and drive it. When I sit down to do the deal the seller tells me the car had been in a front end smash. Lovely. No deal.
Fourth attempt. Another CS. This time I get the car inspected by F dealer. All ok except all four brake discs need replacing! But: seller agrees reduction in price to cover brakes. Deal back on. Purchase going to happen tomorrow. Then: someone I know on another forum alerts me that the car has also had damage in the past. Really annoyed that it wasn't picked up in the inspection. Confront seller: yes, first owner had had panel damage. Grrrrr. Deal off!
Is there some higher power at work here (god of Porsche?), trying to prevent me from buying my first Ferrari?
Was the 16m andrewd's? And he didn't accept CS money for it........how greedy of him First attempt was for a 16M. OK, not very close. Made a low offer to someone emigrating that they didn't accept.
Second attempt was for a CS. Roughly agreed price with seller (subject to inspection). Car had just had service with cam belts. Seller acts all innocent, saying car is perfect. But when I speak to dealer that did the service they tell me the rear brake discs need replacing (5000). So no deal.
Third attempt: see another CS at a specialist. Like the car. See it three times and drive it. When I sit down to do the deal the seller tells me the car had been in a front end smash. Lovely. No deal.
Fourth attempt. Another CS. This time I get the car inspected by F dealer. All ok except all four brake discs need replacing! But: seller agrees reduction in price to cover brakes. Deal back on. Purchase going to happen tomorrow. Then: someone I know on another forum alerts me that the car has also had damage in the past. Really annoyed that it wasn't picked up in the inspection. Confront seller: yes, first owner had had panel damage. Grrrrr. Deal off!
Is there some higher power at work here (god of Porsche?), trying to prevent me from buying my first Ferrari?

marcusjames said:
Was the 16m andrewd's? And he didn't accept CS money for it........how greedy of him 
Oh..it was a bit more than that...closer to double CS - but still at a discount to advertised prices (what a dealer would offer). Odd thing is, I didn't really have a 16M on the shopping list but now that one got away it feels like an unscratched itch so think I will have to buy one at some point (ok - not really any hardship there 
).marcusjames said:
Was the 16m andrewd's? And he didn't accept CS money for it........how greedy of him 
Oh..it was a bit more than that...closer to double CS - but still at a discount to advertised prices (what a dealer would offer). Odd thing is, I didn't really have a 16M on the shopping list but now that one got away it feels like an unscratched itch so think I will have to buy one at some point (ok - not really any hardship there 
).marcusjames said:
The CS is a great car, the 16M is a different league.
Ok but if I go straight for the 16m, woud I enjoy a CS later? Thought process is buy a CS now and try scud or 16m later as easier to trade up, although saying that I've had at least one model of each generation of 911 (excluding 991 of course) but not in chronological order.Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




