Maserati Quattroporte - why not?
Maserati Quattroporte - why not?
Author
Discussion

Storer

Original Poster:

5,024 posts

246 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
This has probably been covered before but I couldn't find it.

I am thinking of adding an upmarket 4 door sporting saloon for family outings / foreign trips to the Storer fleet.

Why or why not a Quattroporte? Experience rather than hearsay preferred.



Paul

craigjm

21,698 posts

231 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
I had one for a while, nice car, great noise, loved the looks. The things i didn't like about it were the very firm seats, old fashioned looking sat nav and sat nav / phone dash buttons that looked and felt like they came out of a cheap Peugeot. Avoid the semi auto and go for the ZF box and when you put your foot down all of the niggle things are forgotten as the sound fills the air.

Storer

Original Poster:

5,024 posts

246 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
I already have 2 manual cars for spirited driving and an auto 4x4 for load lugging / off roading and the idea of this car is rapid cross continent cruising so I planned to go auto but with grunt.

The auto on the Maserati is not supposed to be the smoothest but is the auto good enough to make it a comfortable mile muncher?



Paul

craigjm

21,698 posts

231 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Storer said:
I already have 2 manual cars for spirited driving and an auto 4x4 for load lugging / off roading and the idea of this car is rapid cross continent cruising so I planned to go auto but with grunt.

The auto on the Maserati is not supposed to be the smoothest but is the auto good enough to make it a comfortable mile muncher?



Paul
Do you mean the early semi automatic box? its awful to be honest. The later ZF box transforms the car.

JDH1

1,017 posts

270 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
A friend had one for the semi auto box (for about a fortnight!) and I can vouch for the earlier comments about the semi auto box. On a more general note, I'm not sure why you would buy one if you already have other cars for 'spirited driving'. It will be more expensive, less reliable, more expensive to run, less practical and worse (by most objective and rational measures) than the equivalent Mercedes. On the plus side, it looks nice, sounds good and it's a Maserati. Not sure there's much more to the decision than that.

jamesparrett

62 posts

186 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
it all depends on how much you are looking to spend. The 4.2 with the ZF Auto gearbox are fantastic cars - especially in Sport GT guise... The later 4.7 cars ('S' or 'GTS') are very different vehicles to drive indeed. Also, the navigation and audio systems were updated when it was launched along with a different nose and rear end. All depends on budget i guess!

Colossus

337 posts

245 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
Here we go again, the "expert" opinion that a Maser will be less reliable than an equivalent Merc! what I love about this is that someone with no actual knowledge or experience of actually owing and running a Maserati feels qualified to perpetuate an urban myth that these cars will self destruct faster than Lyndsey Lohan in a brewery!

OK lets put this into perspective, I am on my third Maserati and cannot think of a better large saloon to own and use than a QP. Forget Mercs, not only are they terminally dull (OK some of the AMG's might be slightly more fun to drive but it is relative) but actually they are prone to faults and problems like every other manufacturer, Mercs ain't what they used to be. In contrast I owned a 4.2 QP GTS for a year and literally nothing went wrong, broke or fell off. In that time I went to the South of France and back and regularly used it for the daily commute and school run, all of which it took in its stride. Infact all on my Maseratis have been significantly more reliable than the M series Bimmers I used to run, that was until I saw the light. These are incredibly well engineered cars to own and drive, BUT they need to have been used regularly and properly maintained. If they haven't they will be a can of worms waiting to unleash themselves on the unsuspecting.

If I had a criticism of my QP it would be that the 4.2 does not have enough torque for the size and weight of the car, a problem that the 4.7 addresses. I would also go for the auto, which is very good although I understand the auto box in the 4.7 is better than the 4.2 which I had. I currently own a GranTurismo S which has been an absolute joy to run and gives an unrivaled balance of practicality and sportiness in a package that looks and goes incredibly well. As such ignore the doom merchants, the QP is a stunning car and incredible value second hand, just make sure you get any potential car properly inspected and then enjoy one of motoring's greatest rides.

JDH1

1,017 posts

270 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
Colossus said:
Here we go again, the "expert" opinion that a Maser will be less reliable than an equivalent Merc! what I love about this is that someone with no actual knowledge or experience of actually owing and running a Maserati feels qualified to perpetuate an urban myth that these cars will self destruct faster than Lyndsey Lohan in a brewery!

OK lets put this into perspective, I am on my third Maserati and cannot think of a better large saloon to own and use than a QP. Forget Mercs, not only are they terminally dull (OK some of the AMG's might be slightly more fun to drive but it is relative) but actually they are prone to faults and problems like every other manufacturer, Mercs ain't what they used to be. In contrast I owned a 4.2 QP GTS for a year and literally nothing went wrong, broke or fell off. In that time I went to the South of France and back and regularly used it for the daily commute and school run, all of which it took in its stride. Infact all on my Maseratis have been significantly more reliable than the M series Bimmers I used to run, that was until I saw the light. These are incredibly well engineered cars to own and drive, BUT they need to have been used regularly and properly maintained. If they haven't they will be a can of worms waiting to unleash themselves on the unsuspecting.


If I had a criticism of my QP it would be that the 4.2 does not have enough torque for the size and weight of the car, a problem that the 4.7 addresses. I would also go for the auto, which is very good although I understand the auto box in the 4.7 is better than the 4.2 which I had. I currently own a GranTurismo S which has been an absolute joy to run and gives an unrivaled balance of practicality and sportiness in a package that looks and goes incredibly well. As such ignore the doom merchants, the QP is a stunning car and incredible value second hand, just make sure you get any potential car properly inspected and then enjoy one of motoring's greatest rides.
I don't recall saying that I had "no actual knowledge or experience of actually owing and running a Maserati," but rather that I had a friend who had owned the specific model the op is interested in and the box was awful. Reliability may well have improved since I had mine, but I doubt beyond all recognition. Lovely cars, but the point I was making was that with a number of spirited cars already at his disposal and the use he intends for the car, (how much performance can you exploit with a car full of kids and luggage?) it may not be the best option. You put up a fine defence for the marque, nevertheless.

AJSG

327 posts

218 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
[quote=Storer]I am thinking of adding an upmarket 4 door sporting saloon for family outings / foreign trips to the Storer fleet./quote]

I had a 2005 QP for 4 years, before that a 3200GT for 3 years. I love the QP, it was shockingly reliable, and is still in my opinion the best looking 4 door super saloon out there.

The new one is very nice but considering the prices of some older ones you would be crazy to buy the new one quite as yet.

Mine had the simple semi-auto, which if you drive in full-auto is absolutely fine as long as you remember to anticipate changes by lifting off slightly. In traffic I would recomend manual in full sport mode.

I drove mine for 4 years in traffic every day, took it on high speed runs to Italy and in the UK. Changed the clutch once on year 3.

Whatever you do, do not buy a low milage one. I'd say 5000-6000 miles per year is a good number.

Fragility is down to mainly one thing; battery...

The main dealers are total muppets and neither ones I used ever put it on a charger whilst working on it. This caused 100% of problems suffered over a 4 year period. I bought a caravan battery (big old thing) which I keep in the garage and on a trickle charge. Whenever it cam back from a service I'd leave the battery in the boot for a week. Saved me 3 times, till I move my servicing to an independant, then it became redundant.

sjn2004

4,051 posts

268 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
JDH1 said:
Colossus said:
Here we go again, the "expert" opinion that a Maser will be less reliable than an equivalent Merc! what I love about this is that someone with no actual knowledge or experience of actually owing and running a Maserati feels qualified to perpetuate an urban myth that these cars will self destruct faster than Lyndsey Lohan in a brewery!

OK lets put this into perspective, I am on my third Maserati and cannot think of a better large saloon to own and use than a QP. Forget Mercs, not only are they terminally dull (OK some of the AMG's might be slightly more fun to drive but it is relative) but actually they are prone to faults and problems like every other manufacturer, Mercs ain't what they used to be. In contrast I owned a 4.2 QP GTS for a year and literally nothing went wrong, broke or fell off. In that time I went to the South of France and back and regularly used it for the daily commute and school run, all of which it took in its stride. Infact all on my Maseratis have been significantly more reliable than the M series Bimmers I used to run, that was until I saw the light. These are incredibly well engineered cars to own and drive, BUT they need to have been used regularly and properly maintained. If they haven't they will be a can of worms waiting to unleash themselves on the unsuspecting.


If I had a criticism of my QP it would be that the 4.2 does not have enough torque for the size and weight of the car, a problem that the 4.7 addresses. I would also go for the auto, which is very good although I understand the auto box in the 4.7 is better than the 4.2 which I had. I currently own a GranTurismo S which has been an absolute joy to run and gives an unrivaled balance of practicality and sportiness in a package that looks and goes incredibly well. As such ignore the doom merchants, the QP is a stunning car and incredible value second hand, just make sure you get any potential car properly inspected and then enjoy one of motoring's greatest rides.
I don't recall saying that I had "no actual knowledge or experience of actually owing and running a Maserati," but rather that I had a friend who had owned the specific model the op is interested in and the box was awful. Reliability may well have improved since I had mine, but I doubt beyond all recognition. Lovely cars, but the point I was making was that with a number of spirited cars already at his disposal and the use he intends for the car, (how much performance can you exploit with a car full of kids and luggage?) it may not be the best option. You put up a fine defence for the marque, nevertheless.
Well I've had the one with the "awful" gearbox for nearly 4 years now and don't find it a problem. Would I want to commute and sit it traffic jams all day? No. But the OP has already said he wants it as a weekend car. Reliability? Never broken down or left me stranded.

Kids don't weigh much anyway so I doubt the handling would suffer much with a few in the back so your performance shouldn't be affected.LOL

In summary to the original poster, do a forum search and you'll see over the years who the real owners are vs the "my uncles cats neighbours dad/Clarkson receiters" story type people. Better still, go over to Sportsmaserati.com and read up there.

yetie

377 posts

238 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
i wish they'd have a manual box , i want one when i'm a little older yes

EC2

1,547 posts

284 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
I have had three Maserati Coupes over the last decade and loved them all. The Granturismo is a step up in quality and the auto box is a peach. I would thus guess that the full auto QP would easily give you what you want.

Aeroresh

1,429 posts

263 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
I wouldnt call the semi-auto a semi-auto at all.

Sure it has a button with "auto" on but they are automated manual boxes with a clutch. Once you get over this and drive accordingly they make perfect sense and far more involving than the ZF unit.

Anyone who calls them "aweful" have obviously not learned to drive them correctlyrolleyes


J B L

4,217 posts

246 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all


Question for those in the know: when or which model year did they replace the original gearbox with the ZF one?

Aeroresh

1,429 posts

263 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
J B L said:
Question for those in the know: when or which model year did they replace the original gearbox with the ZF one?
Wasnt a direct replacement but I think the ZF auto was added around 2007. Automated manual was/is still an option

Doesnt help on autotrader, etc but pretty much all are listed as autos!. Only the gear lever is the giveaway