Diamonds
Author
Discussion

Gizmo!

Original Poster:

18,150 posts

240 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
I know this has been discussed here before but the search is borked... And the PH hive mind is never wrong. And I need a diamond and some metal to hold onto it with.

Is there a certification scheme that is better respected than others? And is it worth paying extra for that?

Probably going to see a chap in Hatton Garden with the OH to get sorted out, but any advice is welcome smile

WTD

818 posts

264 months

Tuesday 20th March 2012
quotequote all
Speak with Nightmare (Howard) on here http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/profile.asp?mem...

He sourced me a lovely loose stone, great guy to deal with as well.

Basil Brush

5,637 posts

294 months

Tuesday 20th March 2012
quotequote all
I've just gone through the buying process and ended up going for a GIA triple excellent. I used the Holloway cut advisor while I was weighing up options and was more than happy with the diamond once I saw it.

It seemed to be between AGS or GIA in terms of certification on most of the sites I came across, with AGS being arguably tighter on the top cut ratings, ie not all GIA excellent cuts would make the AGS Ideal rating.

Mobile Chicane

22,027 posts

243 months

Tuesday 20th March 2012
quotequote all
Basil Brush said:
I've just gone through the buying process and ended up going for a GIA triple excellent. I used the Holloway cut advisor while I was weighing up options and was more than happy with the diamond once I saw it.

It seemed to be between AGS or GIA in terms of certification on most of the sites I came across, with AGS being arguably tighter on the top cut ratings, ie not all GIA excellent cuts would make the AGS Ideal rating.
I don't think so.

AGS is a 'standard' for jewellers.

IDC / GIA are the standards for gemmologists.

Markp13

422 posts

191 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
1) GIA is the way forward.

2) Dominic Hackett is most definetly the man to speak to. I picked an engagement ring up from him last year and he's pricing up wedding bands just now. 020 7831 1155 or 07770 888353.

3) ps, don't do it, this engagement thing is a runaway train!!

SWAT78

1,079 posts

214 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
Nightmare is the favourite on here, although several of us including me have also bought through Blue Nile, who are online and have a huge selection of stones and settings, and I'd definitely recommend them.

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
Markp13 said:
2) Dominic Hackett is most definetly the man to speak to. I picked an engagement ring up from him last year and he's pricing up wedding bands just now. 020 7831 1155 or 07770 888353.
Seconded, you will be pushed to do better,

Gizmo!

Original Poster:

18,150 posts

240 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
Markp13 said:
3) ps, don't do it, this engagement thing is a runaway train!!
Bit late now hehe
Asked her with a temporary ring a couple of months back.

Johno

8,593 posts

313 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
Markp13 said:
2) Dominic Hackett is most definetly the man to speak to. I picked an engagement ring up from him last year and he's pricing up wedding bands just now. 020 7831 1155 or 07770 888353.
Seconded, you will be pushed to do better,
Thirded . . .

Watches, engagement ring made to a design we found and the perfect stone sought and offered with other options, wedding bands . . If he sold houses we'd probably go there too !

Basil Brush

5,637 posts

294 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
Mobile Chicane said:
Basil Brush said:
I've just gone through the buying process and ended up going for a GIA triple excellent. I used the Holloway cut advisor while I was weighing up options and was more than happy with the diamond once I saw it.

It seemed to be between AGS or GIA in terms of certification on most of the sites I came across, with AGS being arguably tighter on the top cut ratings, ie not all GIA excellent cuts would make the AGS Ideal rating.
I don't think so.

AGS is a 'standard' for jewellers.

IDC / GIA are the standards for gemmologists.
What do you mean by a 'standard' for jewellers? Of the online diamond retailers, most of the US ones (Brian Gavin, GOG, WF etc) mainly list AGS certified stones, with lots of discussion about comparison between AGS ideal and GIA excellent grades.

JOETHETOE

548 posts

248 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
I purchased a diamond ring (as well as watches) for my wife from Dominic Hackett.

Couldnt speak highly enough of him.

Suinimtao

94 posts

202 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
I would highly recommend going to see a chap called Paul Sitton at quality diamonds in hatton garden. I am very particular and he sourced me a 'perfect' in every way, GIA certified radiant cut diamond last year which would have cost alot more in other shops (even in hatton garden). I just bought the stone from him and had it set at my local jeweller to my own design although they offer a setting service too. The finished article in a high street jeweller would cost double what I paid. Paul offers advice about what you are buying and doesn't give you the salesman pressure as he knows he is cheapest. He will find exactly what you want.