CS or Scud or 575 or 599 arrrrghhhhhh
Discussion
Guys all this talk of Challenge Stradales has really got me thinking of buying
However I was initially thinking of a 575 or even a 599 as they dropped to sensible money and are both great cars and very usable for touring
But all the chat about CS's has really ignited my old feelings for them such a well put together package and every drive memorable but then I look at Scuderia 430s which are coming close to CS money and thinking should I buy the younger car
Car would be used for weekends away and club meets blasting around
Is a CS or Scuderia too raw for a 300 mile weekend ? Which one gents and why sorry if being tedious
However I was initially thinking of a 575 or even a 599 as they dropped to sensible money and are both great cars and very usable for touring
But all the chat about CS's has really ignited my old feelings for them such a well put together package and every drive memorable but then I look at Scuderia 430s which are coming close to CS money and thinking should I buy the younger car
Car would be used for weekends away and club meets blasting around
Is a CS or Scuderia too raw for a 300 mile weekend ? Which one gents and why sorry if being tedious
911Thrasher said:
Sone: you don't think the CS is modern/reliable enough to cope with everyday's life?
I'm sure it's more than capable, but it's what it's doing to my wallet in the process that's the concern. We all know these cars are iconic and that does have a major effect on mileage/value. Eventually they'll end up in collections never driven and under cover, which is a shame.
I have an extremely reliable CS because I've drive it.
Only last year I did Monaco - Glos in one day, 1,000 miles, never missed a beat. The cars been all over europe, same clutch from new, still wearing the first set of break pads and probably one of the highest mileage CS's in the UK.
The CS, like the 360 onwards, is a very reliable car, if driven on a regular basis.
Only last year I did Monaco - Glos in one day, 1,000 miles, never missed a beat. The cars been all over europe, same clutch from new, still wearing the first set of break pads and probably one of the highest mileage CS's in the UK.
The CS, like the 360 onwards, is a very reliable car, if driven on a regular basis.
ditomaso said:
I have an extremely reliable CS because I've drive it.
Only last year I did Monaco - Glos in one day, 1,000 miles, never missed a beat. The cars been all over europe, same clutch from new, still wearing the first set of break pads and probably one of the highest mileage CS's in the UK.
The CS, like the 360 onwards, is a very reliable car, if driven on a regular basis.
I absolutely admire you for actually using your CS though giving it credit for making a run of 1,000 miles without breaking seems to me to be the least you should expect of a less than 9 year old car that's cost well over a hundred grand.Only last year I did Monaco - Glos in one day, 1,000 miles, never missed a beat. The cars been all over europe, same clutch from new, still wearing the first set of break pads and probably one of the highest mileage CS's in the UK.
The CS, like the 360 onwards, is a very reliable car, if driven on a regular basis.
I've found the Scuderia to be , mechanically, completely reliable in the 5,000 miles I've done including not missing a beat in its 2,500 mile euro jaunt last summer.
Which I would expect of course. Its lack of carpets detracts slightly from the touring ability, but its a relaxed enough cruiser, has no clutch of course and a suprisingly civilized ride (when in its softest setting)
Compared to the 575 I tried, either of the CS or Scuderia is much much better sounding than a stock V12 and more agile, lighter in feel and more exuberant in character.And its easy enough to keep either car out of the noisy part of its range when driving. My missus hates it when the exhaust valves open but anyone with a drop of petrol in their veins is going to want to hear them do their stuff as much as possible.
3 point belts in a daily or regular driver are a pain frankly but its more usable than a GT3 in many ways (Higher at the front, softer riding, no heavy clutch)
Right now a Scud and a 599 are about the same but in 2 years time the 599 will be quite a bit cheaper I would think.
Faced this issue myself recently (CS vs Scud).
All IMO:
CS looks better. Above 5000 rpm sounds better. Rawer feel. I think more limited production numbers so perhaps more special if keeping long-term.
Scud clearly quicker (although not sure if that is a good thing as CS already quick enough to get you in trouble!), with a lot more low-down torque. Gearbox works better. More comfortable.
I went for a CS. Partly because had an opportunity to buy a very nice one at a reasonable price. Partly because I thought that I could always swap to a Scud later.
Can't comment on the 575 or 599 as not driven either but believe them to be quite different from the 8-cylinders (have driven a 550 a couple of times and was definitely more GT than sports car).
Try them all and see which appeals most. Even if that doesn't help much with the decision making it will be fun! In any case, don't think you can really go wrong as all lovely.
All IMO:
CS looks better. Above 5000 rpm sounds better. Rawer feel. I think more limited production numbers so perhaps more special if keeping long-term.
Scud clearly quicker (although not sure if that is a good thing as CS already quick enough to get you in trouble!), with a lot more low-down torque. Gearbox works better. More comfortable.
I went for a CS. Partly because had an opportunity to buy a very nice one at a reasonable price. Partly because I thought that I could always swap to a Scud later.
Can't comment on the 575 or 599 as not driven either but believe them to be quite different from the 8-cylinders (have driven a 550 a couple of times and was definitely more GT than sports car).
Try them all and see which appeals most. Even if that doesn't help much with the decision making it will be fun! In any case, don't think you can really go wrong as all lovely.
Diamond blue said:
seems to me to be the least you should expect of a less than 9 year old car that's cost well over a hundred grand.
The more expensive it is, the less reliable it is. I thought everyone knew this by now? It is a rule that will never die because it is simply too expensive to make reliable cars - it requires huge numbers of engineers and testing programmes and supercar factories simply do not have the engineering hours available. Having said that, my 550 has been very reliable for 44k miles. In the last 200 miles, several problems have occured. I think it's entitled to throw a wobbly after 12 years.As for the original question - a CS or Scud is great for a driving weekend or even week of any mileage, absolutely fab. It's not so good if you want to do something else besides driving, with the missus for instance. I think my 550 is a great compromise for holiday trips, and the 575 and 599 are in the same vein. Great grand tourers.
Onno
JazzyO said:
Diamond blue said:
seems to me to be the least you should expect of a less than 9 year old car that's cost well over a hundred grand.
The more expensive it is, the less reliable it is. I thought everyone knew this by now? It is a rule that will never die because it is simply too expensive to make reliable cars - it requires huge numbers of engineers and testing programmes and supercar factories simply do not have the engineering hours available. Having said that, my 550 has been very reliable for 44k miles. In the last 200 miles, several problems have occured. I think it's entitled to throw a wobbly after 12 years.As for the original question - a CS or Scud is great for a driving weekend or even week of any mileage, absolutely fab. It's not so good if you want to do something else besides driving, with the missus for instance. I think my 550 is a great compromise for holiday trips, and the 575 and 599 are in the same vein. Great grand tourers.
Onno
TKH said:
Guys all this talk of Challenge Stradales has really got me thinking of buying
However I was initially thinking of a 575 or even a 599 as they dropped to sensible money and are both great cars and very usable for touring
But all the chat about CS's has really ignited my old feelings for them such a well put together package and every drive memorable but then I look at Scuderia 430s which are coming close to CS money and thinking should I buy the younger car
Car would be used for weekends away and club meets blasting around
Is a CS or Scuderia too raw for a 300 mile weekend ? Which one gents and why sorry if being tedious
I have a 16m Scuderia and for what it is worth I drive it on holiday to Spain and that is 2200 miles!!! It is comfortable, civilised and when you want to it is downright ballistic. It also is a very noticeable car to those who know their cars so you get a lot of appreciative attention. DO NOT worry about your 300 mile comfort challeneg - it will pass that no problem. Happy hunting on your difficult decision! However I was initially thinking of a 575 or even a 599 as they dropped to sensible money and are both great cars and very usable for touring
But all the chat about CS's has really ignited my old feelings for them such a well put together package and every drive memorable but then I look at Scuderia 430s which are coming close to CS money and thinking should I buy the younger car
Car would be used for weekends away and club meets blasting around
Is a CS or Scuderia too raw for a 300 mile weekend ? Which one gents and why sorry if being tedious

phwooooaaarrr that's a beauty
i guess my issue is I have a 'bonkers' car in the stable already but 50 miles is plenty its a fabulous experience but can also be a tad extreme and I also have a wonderful fast British boardroom on wheels but don't want to use too excessivley
I really have an itch for a modern Supercar that I can just jump in and go and if that means hey lets go the lakes then we can or to Silverstone GP without worrying too much about leaving parked up or if it rains
the CS or the Scuderia both sound like they will scratch the itch but the 599 or 575 also float my boat but I get the feeling they wont raise the hairs on my neck like the 360 or 430 ?
I guess I need to take the Pepsi 'Challenge' no pun intended.
Thanks
Guys
i guess my issue is I have a 'bonkers' car in the stable already but 50 miles is plenty its a fabulous experience but can also be a tad extreme and I also have a wonderful fast British boardroom on wheels but don't want to use too excessivley
I really have an itch for a modern Supercar that I can just jump in and go and if that means hey lets go the lakes then we can or to Silverstone GP without worrying too much about leaving parked up or if it rains
the CS or the Scuderia both sound like they will scratch the itch but the 599 or 575 also float my boat but I get the feeling they wont raise the hairs on my neck like the 360 or 430 ?
I guess I need to take the Pepsi 'Challenge' no pun intended.
Thanks
Guys
TKH said:
phwooooaaarrr that's a beauty
i guess my issue is I have a 'bonkers' car in the stable already but 50 miles is plenty its a fabulous experience but can also be a tad extreme and I also have a wonderful fast British boardroom on wheels but don't want to use too excessivley
I really have an itch for a modern Supercar that I can just jump in and go and if that means hey lets go the lakes then we can or to Silverstone GP without worrying too much about leaving parked up or if it rains
the CS or the Scuderia both sound like they will scratch the itch but the 599 or 575 also float my boat but I get the feeling they wont raise the hairs on my neck like the 360 or 430 ?
I guess I need to take the Pepsi 'Challenge' no pun intended.
Thanks
Guys
You have an interesting garage. You have the future investment and iconic Lambo, the tourer in the Aston and the mad dash covered with the crazy Japanese element too! Your decision on more usable (575 and 599) vs an exciting run out (Scud and CS) is not easy because you have every base covered already! Ted makes an interesting point that if its regular miles your doing the 599 is the right car - and I agree with him over the Scud.i guess my issue is I have a 'bonkers' car in the stable already but 50 miles is plenty its a fabulous experience but can also be a tad extreme and I also have a wonderful fast British boardroom on wheels but don't want to use too excessivley
I really have an itch for a modern Supercar that I can just jump in and go and if that means hey lets go the lakes then we can or to Silverstone GP without worrying too much about leaving parked up or if it rains
the CS or the Scuderia both sound like they will scratch the itch but the 599 or 575 also float my boat but I get the feeling they wont raise the hairs on my neck like the 360 or 430 ?
I guess I need to take the Pepsi 'Challenge' no pun intended.
Thanks
Guys
SO - solution - why not sell the Aston (sounds great but never really liked them myself) and sub that with a 599 and then leave the decision between the Scud and the CS. Halves your problem!!

Oooh harsh choice could never sell the Aston it is the car I fell in love with first they are simply unique a Britih brute with such charisma
But get the theory 599 is a great looker and 600+ bhp nice in anyone's book and great tourer
Scuderia epic car though saw one at Graypaul last weekend and deeply smitten
But get the theory 599 is a great looker and 600+ bhp nice in anyone's book and great tourer
Scuderia epic car though saw one at Graypaul last weekend and deeply smitten
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



