An unusual tale
Author
Discussion

groak

Original Poster:

3,254 posts

210 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
I'm 458-hunting, and last week found one that fits. A very low mileage '61 plate. Have expressed interest with owner, and have started the purchase process preamble with him. Yesterday he tells me the car's being recalled for an engine replacement!!yikes He hasn't a clue why, and the supplier AD won't tell him!! But that's got to be a £40-50k recall so obviously needs a bit of investigation on my part.

It's not something I'd heard about, but was wondering if any of the PH cognoscenti were aware of a 458 engine recall?

Funnily enough, some years ago I got an out-of-the-blue call from BMW who recalled my M3 to replace its engine for no apparent reason, so I know it CAN happen without any underlying sinister reason relating to the vehicle being recalled.

Anyone shed some light?

Rods

1,798 posts

284 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
Not heard anything, very strange.

groak

Original Poster:

3,254 posts

210 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
The mystery deepens. AD confirms the owner's story and says Ferrari won't (or haven't) told them why they want the engine. Apparently it's not a unique event - just seems that Ferrari occasionally want a look at an engine from a car for reasons of their own, and without any fault report etc from the owner. By the way, I note you're from Yorks. This car's from there. Could you recommend an indy specialist in the area who'd be prepared to check the car over for me? Thx.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
for whatever reason so be it, does sound odd.... you would think the factory would recall a used motor to study wear and tear.... recalling a newish car engine can only be because they have identified a bad batch of components.... the bonus for you is you get a car with a brand new engine....but then will the history of the car be ?tarnished.... will it affect resale if hence forth it is recorded as having an engine change..?

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
I wouldn't go near a car 200k that had this sort of work done and surely a used car would be taken from dealers stock if Ferrari were checking out how these cars are being used .
All a bit suspect if you ask me!.

Schnellmann

1,893 posts

235 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
Unless the price is much lower than market I would walk away as I think it will hit residuals. Most 458s are low mileage so prob not much benefit of new engine on any case.

R.P.M

1,982 posts

252 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
What's to say Ferrari have discovered a faulty batch of rods or such like, and want to avoid bad press by a spectacular engine failure?
It does seem unusually proactive though.

It wouldn't bother me that it has a new engine, as the vehicle sounds very low miles, but come resale in a couple of years times, when there's way more 458's on the market, it may prove trickier to shift.

groak

Original Poster:

3,254 posts

210 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the inputs, guys. TBH the car getting a brand new ferrari factory fitted engine neither bothers me on most levels, nor imo would it affect resale value at all. Why should it? It also wouldn't seem likely Ferrari have identified a faulty BATCH of anything, or become aware of an intrinsic fault, otherwise the recall would be wider than just one car. The recall hasn't been inspired either by the owner, or by the supplying AD. And this is an 800 miler, so there's nothing here that's been discovered at service or led to a warranty issue being raised.

The only thing that DOES bother me is what Rods said. It's strange. And 'strange' ain't always good. And the only thing that's been said so far that's at all reassuring is the AD supplier's commment that Ferrari just do this sometimes, though it doesn't appear so far that anyone on here's ever heard of such a thing.

The car's on Autotrader, btw. Virtually the only private sale, at £197k.

andrew

10,366 posts

223 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
if the manufacturer wanted my car's engine back and wouldn't tell me why, then i'd decline

why should i :

lose my car for a period of time ?
take the risk of something being damaged or misconnected during the swap ?
run-in another engine ?
reduce the pool of subsequent potential buyers by having what some would see as a question mark hanging over the car's history ?

groak

Original Poster:

3,254 posts

210 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
Hmmm.....now it's vanished from the autotrader listings. Maybe the owner's withdrawn it because of the recall, or maybe it was just a wind up.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
groak said:
Hmmm.....now it's vanished from the autotrader listings. Maybe the owner's withdrawn it because of the recall, or maybe it was just a wind up.
can't sell a car thats in the shop being rebuilt..... or maybe there is more to the story... walk away

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
groak said:
nor imo would it affect resale value at all. Why should it?
perceptions, all to do with perceptions.....

it is often perceived that a low mileage car is a better buy, only really true if the car is regularly warmed up, fully serviced annually, and never ragged to the line from cold

a car that has had an engine changed is perceived to have been either abused (in which case what is the state of the clutch etc) or a lemon, and though the engine has been changed, one would be concerned re any damage said faulty engine may have had on the transmission etc

JMC1

567 posts

266 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
I agree perception is every thing and you can not change that. Whether a medium mileage used car is actually better than an under used one is mostly true but the low mileage car will still sell for a higher price.
If it was my new car then I would be furious and I would insist that they swapped the whole car for another new one asap. If they were not prepared to do that then it would be the last Ferrari I would buy.

Also if I was looking for a two or three year old Ferrari and I found out that my proposed purchase had an engine change at 800 miles I would walk away and buy another.

This is all a bit hypocritical of Ferrari expecting their customer to accept this after all they perpetuate this matching numbers provenance is everything angle with their Ferrari Classiche Certification. Can you imagine the aggravation a few years down the line all the extra documentation and explanation to gain certification to say that the car is not fitted with its original engine but this was down to the factory when the car was practically brand new.

I feel for the poor guy with a new car facing this problem, I do not think he should accept it.

Back in 1973 when I was a kid my Father bought a brand new Aston Martin V8 injection which was delivered on the 1st of August for the new "M" reg. In ten months ownership the car went through four clutches which caused many arguments between him and works service as they were not keen to change these under warranty as they said he did not know how to drive the car and must be clutch riding. He correctly insisted that he was not to blame and that there must be a problem. After the car ate its fourth clutch and the argument started again my father had the car delivered and parked outside works service locked up and left. It took Aston five days to telephone him and after another row they requested the keys to carry out further investigations. Eventually after three weeks they sent the car back on a trailor with a new clutch and admitted that the car had flywheel issues which they had now replaced as well. After this the car did not eat another clutch during his next 12 months ownership although by then he hated the car and the company and eventually replaced it with a Lambo. Some times you have to stand your ground with the car companies but they do not understand the ill feeling they cause during the stand of period. My father always hated Astons after this and severely frowned upon me when I bought one and laughed heartily every time it had problems and it did have many issues.