E46 330i Preventative Maintenence
E46 330i Preventative Maintenence
Author
Discussion

dr_gn

Original Poster:

16,992 posts

215 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
Guys,

Just bought the car, 68K on it. Full BMW history up to a year ago, then one oil service at an indy earlier this year. At the moment I'm thinking of replacing:

Water pump.
Thermostat.
Header tank.
Coolant.

as a precautionary measure. Is there a kit available for the whole cooling system overhaul? Any other belts or sensors required here? What's the damage in terms of cost for this? I'll be doing all work myself.

And

Air filter.
Oil filter.
Plugs.
Charcoal Cabin filter.

If not, what are good brands to look for (been on Euro Car parts website, and there is a variety of prices and brands for most items).

Anything else I should look at replacing? Time will tell, but my intention is to keep the car for several years.

Thanks in advance.

road_rager

1,091 posts

230 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Front suspension bushes, might be worth a refresh as they wear pretty fast

rumple

15,415 posts

182 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Cooling system overhaul is a very good idea, suspension bushes etc try mettle hd or lemforder, or OEM BMW stuff, try your dealer for parts I've been pleasently suprised a few times, when the weather gets better my be worth removing you arch liners cleaning the inner wings and hammeriting em

dr_gn

Original Poster:

16,992 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Thanks guys.

The front wishbones have only done a few hundred miles, not checked the rears.

I just called the local BMW dealer parts department, and fair enough the parts are top price, but they at least offered me -10% when I asked - becasue it was an old car. The water pump is an exchange unit, modified. Presumably it's a metal impeller now.

Cheers.

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
You missed the most unreliable part of the cooling system - radiator.

dr_gn

Original Poster:

16,992 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
You missed the most unreliable part of the cooling system - radiator.
I looked at the radiator - it looks in good condition, not bowed or anything. I was just going to flush it out.

You'd replace it as a matter of course then?

ETA the guy at BMW parts dept. said they'd sold loads of thermostats for 330i's, but hardly any water pumps. He was asking why I wanted to replace it. I wonder if it was a service replacement item at some point - recall type of thing?


Edited by dr_gn on Tuesday 24th April 19:27

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
It's the weakest part of the system, so if you are going to the trouble of renewing stuff then yes.

rumple

15,415 posts

182 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
dr_gn said:
Fox- said:
You missed the most unreliable part of the cooling system - radiator.
I looked at the radiator - it looks in good condition, not bowed or anything. I was just going to flush it out.

You'd replace it as a matter of course then?

ETA the guy at BMW parts dept. said they'd sold loads of thermostats for 330i's, but hardly any water pumps. He was asking why I wanted to replace it. I wonder if it was a service replacement item at some point - recall type of thing?


Edited by dr_gn on Tuesday 24th April 19:27
Personnely id get a wahler thermostat, metal impellor waterpump, antifreeze from bmw, if the rad looks ok why replace, does the temp gauge sit right in the middle and not move, if so id just do the pump and antifreeze, these arent unreliable systems, but they have a bad name because if you overheat em its all over, dont get the pump from bmw, the metal ones are after market, mine cost 40 quid if i remember right

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
rumple said:
Personnely id get a wahler thermostate, metal impellor waterpump, antifreeze from bmw, if the rad looks ok why replace,
If the header tank looks ok why replace? If the thermostat looks ok why replace?

Either do nothing or do it all. It's the rad that goes first so to replace all that stuff and not do the rad because it 'looks ok' is just confusing.

A faulty thermostat isn't going to leave you by the side of the road with steam coming from the bonnet so I'm not sure why you'd replace it before it begins to show signs of needing replacement.

rumple

15,415 posts

182 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
rumple said:
Personnely id get a wahler thermostate, metal impellor waterpump, antifreeze from bmw, if the rad looks ok why replace,
If the header tank looks ok why replace? If the thermostat looks ok why replace?

Either do nothing or do it all. It's the rad that goes first so to replace all that stuff and not do the rad because it 'looks ok' is just confusing.

A faulty thermostat isn't going to leave you by the side of the road with steam coming from the bonnet so I'm not sure why you'd replace it before it begins to show signs of needing replacement.
You could say that about any car, replacing everything would be quite a bill, how far do you take it, my thermostat went so i did my pump at the same time, i did the pump because someone told me it was still plastic,on my previous car i had a waterpump fail, {328}, so thats the biggie for me, also i put bmw antifreeze in every 2 years anyway, the rest, only if its broke, cars are dear enough to run as it is without blowing hundreds replacing perfectly good parts, you may see it different thats fine, now the OP will see both of our points of view, so all bases covered;)

Tim330

1,346 posts

243 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
I'd do the water pump. Mine went a few years ago, had to get the car recovered from the office.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
rumple said:
Fox- said:
rumple said:
Personnely id get a wahler thermostate, metal impellor waterpump, antifreeze from bmw, if the rad looks ok why replace,
If the header tank looks ok why replace? If the thermostat looks ok why replace?

Either do nothing or do it all. It's the rad that goes first so to replace all that stuff and not do the rad because it 'looks ok' is just confusing.

A faulty thermostat isn't going to leave you by the side of the road with steam coming from the bonnet so I'm not sure why you'd replace it before it begins to show signs of needing replacement.
You could say that about any car, replacing everything would be quite a bill, how far do you take it, my thermostat went so i did my pump at the same time, i did the pump because someone told me it was still plastic,on my previous car i had a waterpump fail, {328}, so thats the biggie for me, also i put bmw antifreeze in every 2 years anyway, the rest, only if its broke, cars are dear enough to run as it is without blowing hundreds replacing perfectly good parts, you may see it different thats fine, now the OP will see both of our points of view, so all bases covered;)
I agree. Where do you stop? You might as well replace all the engine hoses at the same time. Plus the brake lines will probably have a small amount of corrosion so replace those, etc, etc.

I'd just do the water pump and anti-freeze change. Then enjoy the car smile

dr_gn

Original Poster:

16,992 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
OK guys - Don't want to casue any trouble.

I think it's an established fact that the cooling system on these things isn't the best.

I've got £350 for my old knackered car that I didn't expect to get, so my intention was to spend this on precautionary maintenence on my new car.

As Fox suggests I'll get a new radiator, water pump, BMW coolant, and while I've got it in bits I'll do the thermostat too. With what's left I'll get the aircon sorted and leave it at that for now.

That way if the worst happens, at least I tried.

rumple

15,415 posts

182 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
You could send me a crate of spitfire, after all I tried to save you a few quid

dr_gn

Original Poster:

16,992 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
rumple said:
You could send me a crate of spitfire, after all I tried to save you a few quid
I appreciate it (but you might also have cost me a hell of a lot more). Better safe than sorry under the circumstances I reckon smile

dr_gn

Original Poster:

16,992 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
From Independant suppliers, seems like there are:

EIS or Nissens Radiators.

KWP or Circoli Water pumps.

Wahler Thermostats.

Or of course at slightly higher cost, original BMW parts.

Any reccomendations?



Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
My original BMW radiator lasted 5 years. It was replaced with a Nissens radiator. This also lasted 5 years hehe

dr_gn

Original Poster:

16,992 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
My original BMW radiator lasted 5 years. It was replaced with a Nissens radiator. This also lasted 5 years hehe
That would only equate to 25k miles for me!

My first Honda Prelude (original) radiator only lasted 5 years too.

buzzer

3,621 posts

271 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Manual or auto? If its an auto I would change the gearbox oil...

I would change the brake fluid

I would squirt a bit of waxoyle inside the rear arches...

Matt_N

9,045 posts

233 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
I'd go for the Nissens radiators, had one in my track car as the cheap re-core one before it only lasted a year and it's been good for 3 years now, must be pretty good.

A friend also has a Nissens one in his Saxo race car, again it's proved to be worth the money.