5 Series....A man in need of guidance (and balls...)
5 Series....A man in need of guidance (and balls...)
Author
Discussion

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all

Hi chaps,

I've searched here and found some great info but its all over the shop...

I am now in the situation of going from my 320ED company hack, to having to purchase my own car. Budget is circa 15-17.5k, ideally looking for the best car I can for the money (no cars over 50k miles ideally). So i thought i'd put some questions out there, maybe you could give me some quick and blunt answers?!

1) 525d (09plate) OR 530d (57/08plate) OR 535d (07plate)
2) What would you deem acceptable mileage? (I will be doing 20k p.a at least)
3) Remap a 525d? (Warranty implications)
4) Reliability woes? (I've read about swirl flaps on 30d's, and small turbo issues on 35d's?)
5) Insurance...will it be a small fortune!? (I'm 28, reasonable area, 7yrs no claims, business use)

I 'want' a 535d because its the best one, i'm relatively young and enjoy a spirited drive, but the inner wimp in me is terrified of HUGE bills on these 6 cylinder engines, what would you do?

Also, i'd have to borrow the money against my car allowance, so feel free to make other suggestions..(No A6's, needs a big enough boot for a push chair)

Cheers

Chris

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Don't think the service costs will be a huge difference, bit more on tyres and brakes for the higher power ones and extra oil on service but you will probably only need one service if you are doing 20k miles. Say £600 more a year for a 535 over a 520, big difference in economy though with 535d getting low 30s and 520 mid 40s or more depending on if you went for a manual rather than auto, could be over £1000 difference in fuel doing 20k miles.

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Anyone else?

Any insight into the general reliability of the 3 engines? I assume LCI is still massively prefered regardless of the model?

Cheers

Chris

CrazyHorse

93 posts

259 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Chr1sch said:
No A6's, needs a big enough boot for a push chair
Chris
I'm not sure about shape to get a pushchair in, but A6's are quoted as having a bigger boot than the 5 series (565 v 500 ltrs as I remember ... I am so sad!). Having driven them both though (535d and 3.0tdi), I'd say the Bmer was the better drivers car and faster as a 535d. The Audi's has a lovely interior though.

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
My friend has an A5 3.0 tdi and they go well and agreed have a lovely interior but i really cant stand the styling of the A6, its so bland. I currently squeeze the pushchair into the boot of my 320d saloon reasonably well but I am banking on the 5 having a bigger boot...

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
If you're looking at an LCI 535d with under 50k miles these cars will surely meet the criteria for BMW warranty. Purchase that then no worries for big bills?

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Good point, can you buy a BMW warranty if it is purchased outside of the BMW network?

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Chr1sch said:
I am now in the situation of going from my 320ED company hack, to having to purchase my own car. Budget is circa 15-17.5k, ideally looking for the best car I can for the money (no cars over 50k miles ideally). So i thought i'd put some questions out there, maybe you could give me some quick and blunt answers?!

1) 525d (09plate) OR 530d (57/08plate) OR 535d (07plate)
2) What would you deem acceptable mileage? (I will be doing 20k p.a at least)
3) Remap a 525d? (Warranty implications)
4) Reliability woes? (I've read about swirl flaps on 30d's, and small turbo issues on 35d's?)
5) Insurance...will it be a small fortune!? (I'm 28, reasonable area, 7yrs no claims, business use)
Coming from a 320, I'd go 325 or 525 or just maybe the 530.
535 would be mostly pointless in the UK, a large jump and you
leave yourself no room for the next car.

At the ages you mention, any mileage under about 150k would be fine.
These machines are designed and built to run flat out all day
every day on the unlimited autobahn, and have a design lifetime
of about ten years, so at 50K UK miles they aren't even run in.

I wouldn't bother with remapping. You'll substantially reduce
the number of insurance companies willing to accept you, when
you could have merely gone out and got a larger engined car anyway.

Insurance you can get quotes over t'InterWeb.

Be warned that newish 5 series are large cars, almost the
size that the old 7 series used to be. Have a think about
garage size and the usual UK car park space size.

bigdom

2,360 posts

176 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
So long as its FSH, if you can get the reg and service details you can call them they'll tell you whether they will cover and the cost

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Excellent, thanks gents, I'm torn, I've spent ages in a 320 looking at 330's and thinking 'bd' lol, so now a 535 seems oh so tempting!

As for parking etc, you raise a fair point, sadly until someone buys our bloody house I'll be parking it on the road :-s

sp222

203 posts

180 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
I went from a 320d E61 to a 525d a couple of years ago - mines an Oct 07 LCI Touring.

You sound like you want a step up in power from the 320d and I reckon that the 525 probably isn't quite enough - the extra power is blunted by the weight. I'd probably go for a 530d and when I swap mine out I'll be getting an F10 530d.

Mines at 92000 miles now and hasn't had any issues - the only cost that will piss you off are the tyres - servicing isn't too bad - the 3 litre engine means servicing is higher than in the 320d, but that's it.

If you can get one with leather and Sat nav, do it, especially with a young child.

I did initially find the 525d disappointing, but once you remember that it's more of a barge than the 3 series, the autobox and extra comfort make sense - I got my wife a 123d so that gets taken when I want to have some more fun.

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Brilliant thanks - that is really useful!

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Gents what annual tax bills can I expect on an 07 30 or 35d?

Also when did the LCI take place, I've seen a nice 57 plate is that about the earliest? (I thought i read 2008 but that could have been a 3 series?)

dandle

32 posts

183 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
LCI was intorduced from March 2007 build date. Most 07s are LCIs but just double check, a few pre lCI cars might have been registered later so on 07 plates.

530dTPhil

1,421 posts

249 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
I had an E39 530d from new and covered 125,000 miles in five and a half years with no dramas or big bills (except turbo at 70K but that seemed to be an issue on 2002 models). This one was remappped at 70K by E-maps to 230 BHP when the turbo was replaced.
This was followed by an ex-demo E61 530d LCI(2000 miles when bought). I had this remapped by E-Maps to 270 BHP and ran the car for 125,000 miles in three and a half years with no problems whatsoever.
This was replaced in April 2011 by an ex-demo F11 530d (2000 miles) which has now done 38,000 miles, More torque and feels quicker than the E61; does around 40 mpg in general usage.

I think high mileage isn't an issue as long as they have been properly looked after, not ragged from cold and not turned off immediately after some hard exercise.
I had the E61 (auto) remapped because it felt much slower in the mid range than the manual E39 but it's personal opinion. For sure, the 535d is very quick but how often can you really use all of the performance in normal usage?

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
Excellent thanks Phil, trying to establish the right course of action post company car...

530dTPhil

1,421 posts

249 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
Think carefully about the Sport or SE choice. The E39 and E61 were Sports and the suspension on runflats (17" and 18" respectively) was very firm. I stuck with run flats rather than changing to non run flats.
The F11 is an SE on 19" wheels with switchable ride and adaptive drive (?) and the ride is excellent.
I know I am getting on a bit but the smoother SE ride is a big improvement over the Sport models, again personal opinion.

Chr1sch

Original Poster:

2,592 posts

224 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
Guys I've found the perfect spec'd 530d but it's older than I wanted - a 2006 model with 30k miles.

Would an 06 plate be a bad idea?! I.e swirl flap issues etc as its not an LCI

530dTPhil

1,421 posts

249 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
LCI engines are better on fuel and, if I remember correctly, the auto box is greatly improved which also impacts on improving the fuel consumption. I believe that the ride quality is better on runflats on the LCI cars.
There are other improvements that I cannot recall.

Short answer is that an LCI car is the better option.

Edited by 530dTPhil on Friday 27th April 21:52

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
Chr1sch said:
Guys I've found the perfect spec'd 530d but it's older than I wanted - a 2006 model with 30k miles.

Would an 06 plate be a bad idea?! I.e swirl flap issues etc as its not an LCI
The pre LCI ones are horrid, the interior is just a mess of weird shapes and crap plastics.