E36 Clutch
Author
Discussion

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Clutch slipping badly on my rare drive to work this morning. Car has down 85k miles so is this new clutch time?

First time this has happened.

Cheers.

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
probably.

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Doh!

Mr Clutch is quoting £350 which seems reasonable. They did my discs and pads last time and I'm still stopping.

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
My Indie is telling me that something called the dual mass flywheel will need replacing as well and that I'll be looking at £1200, gulp!

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
If its just slipping I doubt the dmf will need doing, just buy a quality clutch kit from gsf for approx 150 and take it to a garage to fit it, it's only 3 hours max to do that job.
Mr c will fit a re manufactured clutch and it will be st, and you will need your dmf and oil and every thing else they can sell you.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
The above, I wouldn't use Mr C's.

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Cheers. The car has been juddering from standstill for the past few months. Would this be the DMF?

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
Juddering is probably due to the clutch rather than the flywheel.

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
Be aware that if the clutch starts slipping badly, it does tend to destroy the dual mass flywheel (and unlike standard flywheels, dual mass flywheels cannot really be re-faced so have to be replaced).

Also be aware that if the dual mass flywheel is damaged and you don't replace it, it will quickly wear out the new clutch plate due to friction damage.

It's all very well people saying: "Don't bother replacing the flywheel!", but they're not the people who could end up paying for a second replacement clutch and a flywheel if the old flywheel chews up the new clutch plate.

If you trust your indie not to fleece you, get him to check the condition of the flywheel and go off what he tells you.

(BMW recommend changing the dual mass flywheel every second clutch change regardless of condition, and will advise to replace the flywheel if the face is damaged due to the clutch slipping).

bodhi

14,819 posts

260 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
Didn;t think the E36 had a DMF? My old 328i certainly didn't.....

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
Still thinking of going the Mr Clutch route as I can't afford/justify the £1200-£1500 quotes from Indies and BMW. If I buy a clutch, as one of you lot suggested, I can just see the garage moaning about the fact that it is not an item bought from them so they can't guarantee the work.

I had this when the Jaguar dealer that was servicing my Disco 3 called to say it needed a new tyre at £300 yikes I bought and fitted the same tyre for £100 from an old Land rover grass roots type garage but Jaguar had me sign some sort of disclaimer.

My Beemer has just done a tank of petrol at 16mpg so it's starting to cost me already.

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
rarther you than me, the thought of having to take my car to them makes my stomach churn and I come over with a cold sweat.

I will say a prayer for you.


croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
biggrin Thanks Steve. It's that or scrap the car which will be a real shame as it's a pretty pristine example of a 323i SE from 1998 and owned by me from 6 months old but with a slipping clutch and a warning from the last MOT about the steering rack. All expensive stuff.

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
Now a guy that actually knows me at my local Indie is telling me that the only E36 with a DMF is the M3 thus the job will be ONLY £490 for my 323. Can anyone confirm the news about the DMF as the local BMW dealer has told me that it does have one. Maybe he thought I said E46.

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
If its got air conditioning its got dmf, I doubt you will need the fly wheel. Just buy a clutch and give someone 125 notes to fit it. Job jobbed:-)

BlitzE34

284 posts

181 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
I think they Might a dual mass flywheel. If it does, Euro car parts sell a solid flywheel conversion kit which includes a clutch kit for £275.



http://www.carparts4less.co.uk/cp4l/c/BMW_3+Series...

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for that, ta. Now trying to get hold of a workmate's brother who is a BMW mechanic and does a bit of work in his spare time.

BlitzE34

284 posts

181 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
On BMW ETK it lists a 323i having a dual mass flywheel right from when it was first introduced. Solid flywheels seem to be a common upgrade as they are lighter and can be skimmed to lighten further and also last much longer then dual mass.

Edited by BlitzE34 on Tuesday 8th May 14:20

croyde

Original Poster:

26,527 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
Cheers Blitz. I did manage to look my engine up on a parts order site and the M52 170bhp does have, as you say, a DMF.

My Indie is saying that it shouldn't need changing but they might find, when it's all apart, that it is damaged which will double the cost from £500 to a grand. Bit of a gamble and although I do bet but never more than a fiver on a 2/1 biggrin

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
I am not sure where these prices are coming from, £500 for a clutch and £1000 if it need a dmf? Since when has a dmf been £500?

I have mates in the trade, big parts supplier and they sell very few, can't remember the last time he supplied a dmf for one of these cars.

It's a 3 hour max job, what hourly rates are you paying?

If a quality clutch is £150 and the bill would be 500 that's £116 an hour labour.