From Earth to the Moon
Discussion
Eric Mc said:
Watch it from time to time. It is very well done and pretty accurate in its telling of the overall story.
+1I go through phases of watching it from end to end.
I've also got a series of Nasa documentaries detailing various elements of the missions - the computer, space suit, etc. Very interesting viewing.
Eric Mc said:
"Moon Machines"?
Another excellent series.
Although the documentary on the Command Module does continue the myth of the Block II Command and Service Module as being designed as a "fix" for the original Block I Command/Service Module that was involved in the 1967 pad fire.
Not true.
Thats the one. Love it.Another excellent series.
Although the documentary on the Command Module does continue the myth of the Block II Command and Service Module as being designed as a "fix" for the original Block I Command/Service Module that was involved in the 1967 pad fire.
Not true.
But I didn't know that about the CM, on PH you learn something new every day.
Apollo was originally initiated as a project in 1959. It was designed as the follow up to the original Mercury project. Its original aims were to allow a three man crew to stay in space in earth orbit for up to 14 days. It was also assumed that it could perform circumlunar missions of around 11 days.
The Mercury spacecraft order had gone to the McDonnell Corporation.
The Apollo spacecraft contract went to North American Inc.
North American began initial design work in 1959, two years before the first Mercury flight.
In 1961 President Kennedy committed the US to landing a man on the moon by 1970.
NASA decided that it would be best to make use of the Apollo hardware already in development - so the Apollo Command/Service Module layout, which had already been agreed on, was retained as part of the moon landing scenario.
In 1962, NASA decided that the best approach to landing on the moon was to use a specialised landing craft called a Lunar Excursion Module which would rendezvous and dock with the already partially designed Command/Service Module.
Immediately a problem was recognised. The original Apollo design had no provision for docking. It had no docking probe nor did it have a docking tunnel. Also, it had been assumed in 1959 that no one in their right mind would want to leave the safety of a spacecraft in space - so its main hatch was designed to stay firmly shut and bolted in place.
With the new requirement of a crew transfer between a Command Module and a Lunar Module , it was felt that should there be a problem with the docking probe and tunnel which might prevent an internal crew transfer, it would be a good idea that the Command Module hatch could be opened in space to allow an external crew transfer by EVA.
With all these changes it was decided that a Mark II version of the Command/Service Module would have to be built to carry out lunar landing missions.
However, to keep the momentum of the programme going, it was also decided that the original more limited version of the Apollo spacecraft be continued with as this would allow earlier tests of Apollo systems such as orbital manoeuvering and guidance and navigation.
The Mark I design came to be referred to as the Block I and the newer design was called the Block II.
The very first Apollo mission, Apollo 1, was due to be carried out using a Block I capsule. After the fire, the decision was made to drop Block I modules from the manned flight manifest although at least one Block I module did make an unmanned flight.
The "myth" is that the outward opening hatch came about because of design changes after the fire. The truth is that the outward opening hatch was already designed and being fitted to Block II modules months before the fire.
The main lessons learned from the fire was to ensure that quality control at North American was improved and that non-flamable materials were used more extensively in the Command Module. There were also changes made to the atmospheric constituents of the spacecraft whilst it was sitting on the pad and during the first few minutes of flight.
And that is the whole story of the Block I Command Module versus the Block II Command Module.
The Mercury spacecraft order had gone to the McDonnell Corporation.
The Apollo spacecraft contract went to North American Inc.
North American began initial design work in 1959, two years before the first Mercury flight.
In 1961 President Kennedy committed the US to landing a man on the moon by 1970.
NASA decided that it would be best to make use of the Apollo hardware already in development - so the Apollo Command/Service Module layout, which had already been agreed on, was retained as part of the moon landing scenario.
In 1962, NASA decided that the best approach to landing on the moon was to use a specialised landing craft called a Lunar Excursion Module which would rendezvous and dock with the already partially designed Command/Service Module.
Immediately a problem was recognised. The original Apollo design had no provision for docking. It had no docking probe nor did it have a docking tunnel. Also, it had been assumed in 1959 that no one in their right mind would want to leave the safety of a spacecraft in space - so its main hatch was designed to stay firmly shut and bolted in place.
With the new requirement of a crew transfer between a Command Module and a Lunar Module , it was felt that should there be a problem with the docking probe and tunnel which might prevent an internal crew transfer, it would be a good idea that the Command Module hatch could be opened in space to allow an external crew transfer by EVA.
With all these changes it was decided that a Mark II version of the Command/Service Module would have to be built to carry out lunar landing missions.
However, to keep the momentum of the programme going, it was also decided that the original more limited version of the Apollo spacecraft be continued with as this would allow earlier tests of Apollo systems such as orbital manoeuvering and guidance and navigation.
The Mark I design came to be referred to as the Block I and the newer design was called the Block II.
The very first Apollo mission, Apollo 1, was due to be carried out using a Block I capsule. After the fire, the decision was made to drop Block I modules from the manned flight manifest although at least one Block I module did make an unmanned flight.
The "myth" is that the outward opening hatch came about because of design changes after the fire. The truth is that the outward opening hatch was already designed and being fitted to Block II modules months before the fire.
The main lessons learned from the fire was to ensure that quality control at North American was improved and that non-flamable materials were used more extensively in the Command Module. There were also changes made to the atmospheric constituents of the spacecraft whilst it was sitting on the pad and during the first few minutes of flight.
And that is the whole story of the Block I Command Module versus the Block II Command Module.
I am just a total Apollo nut.
If you are interested, watch this James Burke documentary from 1979. In particular, listen to the little spat that develops between astronauts Jim McDivitt and Harrison Schmidt over the Block I v Block II debate at 25 minutes in. I'm with McDivitt on this point - as he was part of the post fire Block II asessment team and knows what he is talking about.
If you are interested, watch this James Burke documentary from 1979. In particular, listen to the little spat that develops between astronauts Jim McDivitt and Harrison Schmidt over the Block I v Block II debate at 25 minutes in. I'm with McDivitt on this point - as he was part of the post fire Block II asessment team and knows what he is talking about.
I went to the US recently and stayed with some friends (who are a tad older than me). Fantastic, friendly people. We nipped around to see his mum, who is in her 80s now. I walked in and on the wall was a great big portait of Ed White, the first American to walk in space and who died in the pad fire. It turns out he was my friends uncle. His mum knew all the old astronauts and it was just an amazing experience to be there.
Sadly there was another portrait, which was of his other Uncle who was shot down and killed flying F-105s in Vietnam. Very humble people, but absolute treasures.
Sadly there was another portrait, which was of his other Uncle who was shot down and killed flying F-105s in Vietnam. Very humble people, but absolute treasures.
Many of the Apollo era astronauats harbour guilt feelings about having missed out on serving their country "properly" in the Vietnam War. It is strange to think that these guys who did something so unique in history still consider themselves ordinary combat airmen at heart and that their true calling was to fly combat for their country.
They were all great men and they sometimes need reminding of that.
They were all great men and they sometimes need reminding of that.
Streetrod said:
Was a bit bored last night so dug out my box set and started watching this again. I had forgotten how good a series this was. If you have never seen it and are interested in the Apollo missions then I highly recommend you grab a copy
Thanks SR i will get a copy sounds like my sort of thing other then cars What was the problem?
Was the story not exciting enough?
It is based on real events - and indeed, it is based very closely on those events. Like people who say they don't get "Band of Brothers", they seem to think of these films/series as a work of fiction which perhaps isn't exciting enough.
They are not truly works of fiction. They are dramatised history - and very well done at that.
For me Apollo is one of the most exciting real events I ever lived through and I think "From the Earth to the Moon" captures the essence of the real events extremely well.
Was the story not exciting enough?
It is based on real events - and indeed, it is based very closely on those events. Like people who say they don't get "Band of Brothers", they seem to think of these films/series as a work of fiction which perhaps isn't exciting enough.
They are not truly works of fiction. They are dramatised history - and very well done at that.
For me Apollo is one of the most exciting real events I ever lived through and I think "From the Earth to the Moon" captures the essence of the real events extremely well.
Eric Mc said:
What was the problem?
Was the story not exciting enough?
It is based on real events - and indeed, it is based very closely on those events. Like people who say they don't get "Band of Brothers", they seem to think of these films/series as a work of fiction which perhaps isn't exciting enough.
They are not truly works of fiction. They are dramatised history - and very well done at that.
For me Apollo is one of the most exciting real events I ever lived through and I think "From the Earth to the Moon" captures the essence of the real events extremely well.
Eric you really do get a bit stroppy if people don't like the things you do and have the audacity to post anything other that 100% accurate technical agreement with your opinion? No need for your responses sometimes, there really isn't.Was the story not exciting enough?
It is based on real events - and indeed, it is based very closely on those events. Like people who say they don't get "Band of Brothers", they seem to think of these films/series as a work of fiction which perhaps isn't exciting enough.
They are not truly works of fiction. They are dramatised history - and very well done at that.
For me Apollo is one of the most exciting real events I ever lived through and I think "From the Earth to the Moon" captures the essence of the real events extremely well.
I quite liked Earth to the Moon, but on the subject of the Moon missions I really, really enjoyed and much prefered "In the shadow of the moon" by Ron Howard.
Overall I think it's a must more enjoyable take on the amazing achievements as it looks more at the human element. The fact that it has no narration apart from the voices of the crews themselves is at times very moving and always very humbling.
You misunderstand me. I am not criticising someone else's opnion. Just flummoxed that they don't "get" a telling of a true story.
What aspect of the programme didn't they get?
If they were willing to explain the reason why they don't like something then it might be understandable. For instance they might think the dialogue is trite, or the acting unrealistic, or the facts not adhered to, or they don't like the camerawork.
All I was hoping for was a bit of an explanation as to why someone finds a realistic telling of a story dificult to "get".
If the story was pure fiction and purely an "artistic" endeavour then I wouldn't even have asked the question.
I like "In the Shadow of the Moon" too. But then I like most documentaries about Apollo. Having said that, the very first proper film documentary on Apollo, "Moonflight One". which was made in 1970, is very poor with a disjointed imagery and a rambling, almost incomprehensible, narrative.
What aspect of the programme didn't they get?
If they were willing to explain the reason why they don't like something then it might be understandable. For instance they might think the dialogue is trite, or the acting unrealistic, or the facts not adhered to, or they don't like the camerawork.
All I was hoping for was a bit of an explanation as to why someone finds a realistic telling of a story dificult to "get".
If the story was pure fiction and purely an "artistic" endeavour then I wouldn't even have asked the question.
I like "In the Shadow of the Moon" too. But then I like most documentaries about Apollo. Having said that, the very first proper film documentary on Apollo, "Moonflight One". which was made in 1970, is very poor with a disjointed imagery and a rambling, almost incomprehensible, narrative.
jingars said:
Civpilot said:
Eric you really do get a bit stroppy
Indeed he does. Opinions are not facts; they don't have to be explained or justified. To anyone.Gassing Station | TV, Film, Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





Thanks Eric, I think you may have missed your calling as an aeronautical historian. Great explanation
