Teaching is not stressful
Author
Discussion

Lost_BMW

Original Poster:

12,955 posts

207 months

Thursday 10th May 2012
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-18025202


So says this generation's Chris Woodhead.

Settles back with popcorn to await the debate to come... smile

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
I agree with him.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
I'm not a teacher but I know having to put up with children every day would drive me towards a bottle and a shotgun.

Maybe we can see why I'm not a teacher.

Funk

27,823 posts

240 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
My mother - a teacher for some 35 years - would disagree.

pacman1

7,324 posts

224 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Can't see the problem in interaction with kids, we were all one once. It should be fun and rewarding for all conceerned. It's part of being human.smile

I think the stress comes from the present regime of leagues tables, targets and curriculum imposed on teachers from government policy.

Honestly, do we really have so many bad teachers? It's a vocational profession after all, attracting those least likely to complain, surely?

0a

24,161 posts

225 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Correct. Teachers are a protected breed - they are more stressed than any private sector worker, and despite the teachers in my year being in the lowest 10% in capability we must praise them.

As has been said here before; those that can't teach.

Teachers think any level of stress (having to turn up for a lesson, produce a plan) is stressful, yet they don't suffer at all from failing their pupils (a failure could come in 10 years time) unlike the end of month profit motive in the private sector.

Pacman1 alas yes we do have very many poor teachers. It's unfashionable to say it but it's true.


Edited by 0a on Friday 11th May 01:57

TheDiplomat

72 posts

175 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
I think one of the major issues, as said, is the poor quality of teachers. I genuinely believe that the following measures would significantly increase standards in the classroom;

- All school expenditure and teacher appointments to be decided by board of Governors. Scrap all LEAs.
- Raise the basic teacher's wage to £32,000
- Head of department to £50,000
- Head Master to £90,000

Re-aligning the pay of teachers with the other "great professions" of law and medicine would rapidly drive up teaching quality. Teaching pay has been neglected for far too long.

The pay increase would be done on one requirement: every teacher would have to re-apply for their job against any outsiders who also wanted to apply. The increase in teachers from the military, business, law, higher education and so on would probably be life changing to vast numbers of pupils. Outsiders would take a TeachFirst style, intensive preparatory course over the summer, before they started teaching.

It is indeed the case that a very sizeable number of all university graduates (but not all) who teach decide to do so because they feel it is an easy way out - they can't do anything else. I think it is awful that (like our politicians du jour) we have vast numbers of career teachers (and career politicians) who have no real world experience. They are also often too politicised and unionised.

The real damage of poor teaching is done to the kids they teach.

I would also want to introduce a tripartite schooling system, which divides off at age 14 (when most kids realise their potential) in to grammar schools, engineering/science/technical colleges and music/theatre/sporting colleges.

You will have a society with strong academics, vast numbers of well trained technicians/IT support staff/engineers/mechanics and performing artists.

Of course the Grauniad ooman rights brigade would disagree with me. I'm so sure it would work though. Thoughts?

Happy82

15,078 posts

200 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Hooli said:
I agree with him.
yes

I've often found those complaining of 'stress' in a job are either underperforming or not suitable for their choice of career.
For example,last week I heard a midwife complaining to a colleague that screaming babies were stressing her out rofl

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
0a said:
Correct. Teachers are a protected breed - they are more stressed than any private sector worker, and despite the teachers in my year being in the lowest 10% in capability we must praise them.

As has been said here before; those that can't teach.

Teachers think any level of stress (having to turn up for a lesson, produce a plan) is stressful, yet they don't suffer at all from failing their pupils (a failure could come in 10 years time) unlike the end of month profit motive in the private sector.

Pacman1 alas yes we do have very many poor teachers. It's unfashionable to say it but it's true.
How much experiencing of teaching do you have?

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
If it's such a cushy number can someone please explain the following.

"Four in ten new teachers are driven out of the profession within two years, research suggests.
Unruly pupils and red tape were cited as the main reasons for the high turnover.
The research also highlighted excessive workloads and lack of family time. The authors of the study called for a campaign to bring disillusioned teachers back into the profession.
The study, sponsored by the General Teaching Council and reported in the Times Educational Supplement, found the most common reasons for quitting within two years were 'behaviour of pupils/pupil discipline' and 'family reasons/ commitments'.
Both factors were cited by 19 per cent of leavers. Twelve per cent said they could not cope with the workloads.

Gospel of Truth

Certainly don't get that sort of drop out rate in the private sector.





Edited by Fittster on Friday 11th May 07:21

Jasandjules

72,711 posts

260 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
A friend who is a teacher says that the kids tend not to be too bad. The stress is caused by other teachers.....

W124Bob

1,863 posts

206 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Having been married to a teacher for 20 odd years I would disagree with him very strongly.His organisation,kids with problems,parents with attitude,assualt I could go on.Interestingly it was always OH's job we had to talk about,nothing much happens in my job
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-oxfordshire-1... another day.

Blackpuddin

19,611 posts

236 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
^^^^^^^^^
what he said

andymadmak

15,732 posts

301 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
If it's such a cushy number can someone please explain the following.

"Four in ten new teachers are driven out of the profession within two years, research suggests.
Unruly pupils and red tape were cited as the main reasons for the high turnover.
The research also highlighted excessive workloads and lack of family time. The authors of the study called for a campaign to bring disillusioned teachers back into the profession.
The study, sponsored by the General Teaching Council and reported in the Times Educational Supplement, found the most common reasons for quitting within two years were 'behaviour of pupils/pupil discipline' and 'family reasons/ commitments'.
Both factors were cited by 19 per cent of leavers. Twelve per cent said they could not cope with the workloads.

Gospel of Truth

Certainly don't get that sort of drop out rate in the private sector.





Edited by Fittster on Friday 11th May 07:21
My brother in law retrained to become a teacher (maths) but left after less than one year. Was he stressed? Yes and no. He says that the biggest stress was not the unruly behavior of the kids, but rather the sure and certain knowledge that he had absolutely no power whatsoever to deal with it. No sanctions, nothing. If he gave a detention the kid would either not show up, or a gobby parent would storm in threatening violence. The cane/slipper? Assault and child abuse. Shouting? mental abuse.

On this last point (the mental abuse thing) I also have some experience in school. I taught business as part of the YE scheme in a very well thought of local comp (the sort of place parents buy houses to get their kids into) The levels of discipline amongst some of the kids was utterly, utterly appalling. Kids would wander in and out of classes whenever they felt like it. Talking and larking about during lessons was the norm as far as I could see. The (female) teacher assigned to me would just talk whilst there was pandemonium in the class. She was only 30ish but you . could see she had just given up any pretence of trying to keep order. The other staff I met were often in a similar state. Clinging on to their jobs and fearful of sanctions against them if they spoke out.
In the end, in my class I raised my voice and told them all to sit down and shut up NOW! One smart arse said "you can't talk to us like that, we can get you sacked!" I simply told him that as I was a volunteer he was welcome to try, but as my salary and pension was not dependant on him I was not unduly worried, I'd drive home in my TVR and the end of the day but that for now he could still sit down and shut up, and if he didn't he could leave right now. He sat down. I then told the class (15y olds) that I would respect them and treat them as young adults on condition that they afforded me the respect I was due as a succesful business man who had come to teach them in my own time, for free. We had a brilliant lesson. The following week the headmistress came to me and said that gobby lads parents had come to school to complain about my having raised my voice to her (far from delicate little flower) son. She asked me to refrain from doing it again. I refused. I pointed out that the lesson had gone very well, so well in fact that a number of kids had come to me afterwards to say how much they had enjoyed it, and how they hadn't expected to! I said I would do things my way. In the end, the lad withdrew from the class, but the rest went on to have a brilliant year. We got through to the regional finals of the YE competition, and there were real tears from some of the kids when the course ended. That was 5 years ago and I still get e mails from some of them. One lad had told me he was planning to leave school at 16 to become a builders labourer. His teacher seemed fine with this. I told him it was his choice, but in my view he had potential for so much more. 5 years on and he's well on the way to qualifying as an architect!

I'm sorry for the ramble, but my point was that I was only able to impose the discipline because I had the POWER! For me the power was to walk away and it not affect me financially or professionaly. Few teachers have that power. And since our new liberal society has removed any possibility of physical sanctions the results are perhaps not surprising.
The fact is, had I gone home as a kid and told my mother I had been given a detention for bad behaviour she would probably have walloped me for my sins. These days it's more likely that the only walloping going on would be on the teacher by some thug thick parent whilst screaming about " it's my riiiiiiiiiiights". It's not surprising that young, idealistic teachers who probably imagine that they will inspire and lead their classes in true "goodbye Mr Chips" stylee leave in dismay as reality shatters that dream.

Edited by andymadmak on Friday 11th May 09:32

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Stress levels probably not different to many other professions.

However, I meet a lot of people who want/are training to be teachers, they appear to have very little idea of what will be involved.

It may well be the realisation of real teaching that causes stress.

Chaz9950

1,133 posts

175 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
TheDiplomat said:
I think one of the major issues, as said, is the poor quality of teachers. I genuinely believe that the following measures would significantly increase standards in the classroom;

- All school expenditure and teacher appointments to be decided by board of Governors. Scrap all LEAs.
- Raise the basic teacher's wage to £32,000
- Head of department to £50,000
- Head Master to £90,000

Re-aligning the pay of teachers with the other "great professions" of law and medicine would rapidly drive up teaching quality. Teaching pay has been neglected for far too long.
How much!!!?? yikes

Fair point, that teaching, in some schools, to some students is going to be stressful. However, it's not that bad, is it?

And holy hell - how much for a teachers salary..!!?

I've been to war, twice, for FAR less than your proposed 'basic' wage. I consider myself an instructor; I teach younger guys an engineering trade, and while I accept that men in the military may be easier to teach (although not always), I've done it in much higher stress environments.

turbobloke

117,617 posts

291 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
As per andymadmak's account, teachers need as many leadership qualities as a colonel on horseback but this was only formally acknowledged recently having been known since the dawn of politically correct time when the first bell rang on the first lesson from a teacher sent naked onto the battlefield. Technical knowledge and pedagogical skill are necessary but not sufficient, since if there is a semi-riot during 'learning activities' there may be some teaching going on as per that 30-year old, but there will be far less learning. Not all people have the innate leadership attributes or the capacity to develop them, this should be one of the key factors in the pass-fail decision for ITT.

Chaz9950

1,133 posts

175 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Totally agree.

I guess, to be a good teacher not only takes a few years of learning how to be a good teacher, but you need to have a natural skill at imparting knowledge onto others. I've only ever met a few who were VERY good, mostly just have been OK, or plain rubbish.

Jasandjules

72,711 posts

260 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
Teachers need to have the power to instill punishments as well as praise.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Friday 11th May 2012
quotequote all
I suppose it probably depends a lot on the school whether or not teaching is stressful or not.

Schools do seem to have a lot of internal politics which I'm sure can be stressful if you're caught between a warring head of department and management team. In some schools the parents are helpful and want the best for their kids while in others they're feckless and argumentative and don't see the value in education which must be hard as a teacher.