another 335d thread?
another 335d thread?
Author
Discussion

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
Right well I am seriously considering a 335d next.
Completely different to the GTA i know butwith the wedding looming closer its probably the only car i want and able to persuade the missus that its a sensible option.

I know that they are meant to be seriously quick especially mapped... looking at youtube not massively slower than a V8 m3!

I know its a diesel and that diesels are meant to be ecnomical but i am also not stupid enough that a 3.0d with 2 turbos is going to return an average of 40mpg+ probably more like 30 which is still 12 more than i get now.


Ideally i want an tourer having charlie as our only child...


I could possibly by swayed by a saloon as i actually like the look of them better than the coupe.
Trouble is tourers are rare as and all seem to be over 250 miles away!
Strange how the supposedly least "sporty" shape 335 is the one i am most attracted too.. tourer then saloon and lastly the coupe?!?
Anyways for my budget it would be an early example with the lower mileage as possible prob max buget would be 13.5k which does limit my choice but this one comes in within it, so it is dooable
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classifi...335d?logcod...

Other cars i havent ruled out are a 335i which are slightly cheaper and very similar in performance but would be harder to persuade the missus that its a sensible upgrade...

also like the 123d's but for the money the big tourer is more suitable.

So basically does anyone have any experience of the 335's and what are the weakest points and what kind of service costs are to be expected?
Am sure i read somewhere the turbos have problems?

Also is there any must have / nice options to look out for?

Msport's are the prettier ones and nearly all are msports but is the msport just an external styling package?

also alot are auto's does this mean it has the paddle shift?

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
All are automatic, not 'a lot'. They do not offer a manual 335d.

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
ahh right thought i had seen a manual.... so does it have the paddle shift too?

rumple

15,415 posts

182 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
I'd go on some of the BMW forums, because what ive seen on them totaly contradicte what ive read on here about them.

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
ok mate.

whats best 3 series forum??

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
I did 130k in a 2006 saloon.

Problems

1) Turbo actuator hoses, common and easy fix
2) Front pulley went at 110k losing drive to alternator/pump etc. £330 from ECP, 1/2 a day to change it.
3) Exhaust manifold came loose causing screech, top turbo off to get to the nuts, 1/2 a day no cost.
4) Intercoler hoses are a weak spot, had 3 during my tenure.

28-30 mpg, eats brakes and tyres, but i was using it properly.

A low miler thats been chugging around town will need a DPF soon, expensive.


Easy car to live with, and an easy car to fix, barring electrical which will need plugging in at the thieves.

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
hey thanks,
nice looking car are they the alpina wheels?

so maybe a high mileage car wont be too bad? was thinking gearbox and clutch could be a weak point on the higher mileage care with all the torque?

there is a coupe for sale with 176k! which is pretty impressive but that would be too much of a risk surely...

gangzoom

9,005 posts

246 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
jamieleehodgson said:
Other cars i havent ruled out are a 335i which are slightly cheaper and very similar in performance but would be harder to persuade the missus that its a sensible upgrade...
How many miles do you actually do? Make sure you test drive a 335i and 335d before making your mind up, the engine in the 335i is fab!!!

When driven properly I get low teens in my 335i, but ever so often on a M trip with the wife I'll just stick the cruise on at 65mph move over to the inside line and enjoy watching the world rush by. At the end of the trip I put the trip computer on to show her just how economical my car is smile..slowly but surely I'm convincing her the F10 M5 wouldn't be that bad on petrol since the official figure is only 2mpg below the 335i's!!

This was 55 miles on the M1, than 15 miles M25, and the last 10 North London roads


Edited by gangzoom on Sunday 13th May 12:26

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
thanks for the response.

we will be doing about 8k per year so not many to justify the choice of a 335d over a 335i but as soon as you mention the d word then she like 99% of women immediatley think cheap to run. Which is ultimately the deciding factor.

out of interest how easy is it to get in and out of the back of the coupe's?? opens up so many more options with those on the shopping list!

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
jamieleehodgson said:
hey thanks,
nice looking car are they the alpina wheels?

so maybe a high mileage car wont be too bad? was thinking gearbox and clutch could be a weak point on the higher mileage care with all the torque?

there is a coupe for sale with 176k! which is pretty impressive but that would be too much of a risk surely...
Yes Alpinas. I sold mine for 9.5k last year. 100K miler should be fine, but price should reflect it. The 'clutch (s)' are all wet and in the box. I had mine on a few track days, it stood up well.

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
roofer said:
Yes Alpinas. I sold mine for 9.5k last year. 100K miler should be fine, but price should reflect it. The 'clutch (s)' are all wet and in the box. I had mine on a few track days, it stood up well.
9.5k sounds like someone got a good deal. what was the mileage? 130k ?

was that a trade in price?

rassi

2,518 posts

282 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
You have a GTA, with one of the greatest engine sounds ever - as much as I like my 35d engine (albeit in an X3) it does not compare to the GTA or the 35i engine in drama and sound. And if you only do 8K (and presumably a number of short journeys) the economy doesn't stack up for the 35d.

If I were you I would look for a 335i Tourer with as many options as possible, as a worthy replacement of the GTA.

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
I'm on my 2nd, both tourers and I love mine, sold the 1st one and regretted it instantly, hence why I have another with better spec than the 1st one

One thing I will say is they are good on fuel for the performance on offer, mine has been remapped by Viezu, it was rolling roaded at 361bhp at the fly (optimistic) but still does over 31 mpg in town and closer to 42 on a run, which isn't to be sniffed at IMO

Both mine needed EGR thermostats as the mpg was slightly low £30 from the dealer
Current car required a gearbox software update as it was holding onto 3rd gear
Both needed red boost pipes changed, done under warranty

I would thoroughly reccomend a remap on one, it improved my mpg by around 4.5mpg average and the increase in performance is fantastic

I was selling mine at Xmas time as we moved house, settled in fine and I was fed up of the traders calling and trying to tell me a 320d was more desirable as they were better on fuel so I should take 3k less they were offering than I was asking, and to be honest I'm glad I've kept it.

Spec wise, musts for me were

Xenons,
Heated Leather,
Prof Nav
Bluetooth
Mine has some other options but those were on my must list

gangzoom

9,005 posts

246 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
8K a year isn't a lot, just do some maths....

£1.40 for Petrol (superleaded is obviously more but it'll run fine on 95ron and makes the maths look better), assuming 24mpg for a 335i (my current average whilst doing city driving) = £2K on fuel.
£1.45 for Diesel, assuming 30mpg for a 335d = £1760 on fuel.

Assuming all else been equal is a saving of less than £300 over 12 months on fuel, or less than 80p a day difference.

Theres clearly nothing wrong with the 335d, but if the reason for buying a diesel is to save money, than your not actually saving all that money.....

Leather/SatNav/Xenons minimal spec.
USB/DAB/Folding mirrors/Folding seats are things I would have liked on my car, but I can easily live without them....However if you really want the best of the car you really need to get a LSD fitted, even stock on anything but perfectly smooth roads the traction control use to come on every time I gave it some gas. Its not cheap but has really let me enjoy the car much more. Put another £300-500 aside for a remap/JB tune (360bhp), £500-1000 for downpipes/intercooler and your be scaring M3/911s.

Actually forget everything I've said about the 335i been sensible/economical and just get a 335d and be happy, since I bought my 335i 12 months ago all I've done is spend money on mods...currently trying to justify getting the Birds suspension kit fitted at £2.5K...and I bought the 335i because the wife thought a M3 was too flash/expensive to run smile...in my defence I've not had to spend a penny on fixing/replacing anything.

Edited by gangzoom on Sunday 13th May 17:13

TX1

3,016 posts

214 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
I think Jamie would like a petrol however his mrs thinks diesel = fuel economy, so unless he buys a petrol and she does not notice he has no choice.
If you do buy a petrol and convince her its a diesel make sure she never goes to fill up.

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
jamieleehodgson said:
thanks for the response.

we will be doing about 8k per year so not many to justify the choice of a 335d over a 335i but as soon as you mention the d word then she like 99% of women immediatley think cheap to run. Which is ultimately the deciding factor.

out of interest how easy is it to get in and out of the back of the coupe's?? opens up so many more options with those on the shopping list!
Hi Jamie ,not being funny but 8k miles a year ,could be far from cheap to run if it starts to get gummed up.

Will that include Motorway hoons every few weeks?It will need it.

Good luck hunting.

itiejim

1,822 posts

236 months

Sunday 13th May 2012
quotequote all
I've recently bought a 335D coupe`, access to the rear is fine, if I'd wanted to bung the kids in it regularly I'd have bought a saloon, however, as an occasional 4 seater it's perfect.

Economy on mine is sitting around 34 mpg with mixed use and accessing the grunt when appropriate!

First impressions are that it's a great daily driver. It's never going to be an M3 substitute (any more than a 335i will), but as a sensible, usable motor which costs little to fuel I can't knock it.

Personally I wanted a D over an i, and would suggest that you get the one you prefer. The arguments about running costs are kind of irrelevant though because you'll either keep the car a long while and save due to the increased economy, or move it on sooner and retain more value than an equivalent 335i.

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for all the info, much appreciated and enjoyed reading it.

I am planning on going for a test drive in both variants in next few weeks.

As said i no doubt would prefer to drivethe petrol but its the whole arguement of chopping both cars in and getting one "diesel"

I understand the basic maths of diesel prices and mpg vs petrol prices and how many miles you do etc but for some reason olivia doesnt. Boobs.

Sounds like the repair bills have been gentle with everyone that i have read about so thats a bonus.
How much would an aftercare warranty be on a 80k mile car? I would imagine quite hefty!

As for driving style, mon-fri it will mainly be doing very short journeys commuting and weekends get driven hard and will attend some meets and hoons through lakes and hartside as there both on my doorstep. Hopefully that should clear any carbon build up?!

Whats the service intervals on both variants?? And costs?

Thanks again you have all been very helpful

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
jamieleehodgson said:
As for driving style, mon-fri it will mainly be doing very short journeys commuting
Just the job for a diesel, definately worth it.

Go and buy a V8 or something, seriously. The chances to do that are running out. You have the rest of your life to drive a diesel.

jamieleehodgson

Original Poster:

2,666 posts

225 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Just the job for a diesel, definately worth it.

Go and buy a V8 or something, seriously. The chances to do that are running out. You have the rest of your life to drive a diesel.
I think i have said it 3-4 times now.... i have to persuade the missus and the word diesel is the only word in motoring that she instantly thinks "wow he is starting to grow up and become sensible" the fact is i am not ruling the 335i out and will be driving that too after hearing most peoples gentle persuations...

I have had plenty of fun in last 3 years (clio v6, 350bhp MPS, 2 gta's, e46 M3) time to get something a bit more grown up.. even if it is just a stepping stone