E46 M3 - Anything to watch for?

E46 M3 - Anything to watch for?

Author
Discussion

pdavison

Original Poster:

1,637 posts

279 months

Thursday 29th July 2004
quotequote all
I am considering an E46 M3 as the replacement for my Cerbera.

Is there anything in particular to watch out for? I'm test driving the SMG version this evening and I will (following reading the various posts) give it time before I judge what I think of it.

Also I've heard that cars without sat nav and 19'' alloys are difficult to sell (the one I'm looking at has neither of these options), is this the case and do the 19'' wheels adversely effect the handling?

Any pointers would be much appreciated.

douglasr

1,092 posts

274 months

Thursday 29th July 2004
quotequote all
19" wheels cannot be repaired by conventional means. Check for kerbing and damage.
Check SMG is latest software version.

pdavison

Original Poster:

1,637 posts

279 months

Thursday 29th July 2004
quotequote all
How do tell which software version it is?

jamesmac

102 posts

264 months

Thursday 29th July 2004
quotequote all
www.bm3w.co.uk

All you need to know here. Very good info for buying.

Jim

Zod

35,295 posts

260 months

Thursday 29th July 2004
quotequote all
The handling is good with both 18" and 19" wheels. The difference comes (obviously) from the difference in sidewall height. There are advantages and disadvantages to both.

Alf Essex

1,467 posts

263 months

Thursday 29th July 2004
quotequote all
pdavison said:
I am considering an E46 M3 as the replacement for my Cerbera.

Is there anything in particular to watch out for? I'm test driving the SMG version this evening and I will (following reading the various posts) give it time before I judge what I think of it.

Also I've heard that cars without sat nav and 19'' alloys are difficult to sell (the one I'm looking at has neither of these options), is this the case and do the 19'' wheels adversely effect the handling?

Any pointers would be much appreciated.


Hey mate,

I'm moving from the Tuscan S to the M3 SMG version and test driving car on Saturday...so would be great to here your views in advance post your drive this evening!

If all goes well I am placing my despoit Monday with delivery mid-Sept...already seen car already fully spec'd...

Alan.

PetrolTed

34,432 posts

305 months

Thursday 29th July 2004
quotequote all
Ask about replacement engines. They're more commonly required than you might think...

pdavison

Original Poster:

1,637 posts

279 months

Friday 30th July 2004
quotequote all
Rights guys here are my impressions and a few other questions...

First of all the car looks great, I like the fact it's understated yet subtly aggressive (if that's possible).

The interior was well laid out with an execitive feel to it, but a little dull in the black leather (not sure if another colour would brighten things up a bit). The seats are one of the most comfortable I've sat in with just about every adjustment you could wish for (and a few that you wouldn't!).

And onto the bit that I thought would make me hate the car ... the gearbox. I did the usual learner driver changes to start with, but after about 5 minutes (and yes I was surprised too), I got the hang of it. A little lift off between changes and it was as smooth as a normal manual. The best bit was the amount of adjustment you can make to it by playing through the different modes. With it on it's fastest setting I do believe that it can change faster than you could in a manual. The best bit it when you take it to the next level by selecting sport mode. The car responds so much quicker and feels more aggressive.

Also, I approached a long road with speed humps, so I selected auto mode and drifted along with very little effort, somthing that would be very handy for sitting in traffic.

My only query is why you would drive it in anything below the 4-6 setting (near the highest) because that's what the car is all about. The auto shift is very poor when you're pushing it, but then if you're pushing it you probably wouldn't select auto!

Overall (as you can probably tell) I'm very impressed. I just have a couple of questions, how much does it cost to renew the BMW warantee (it's up in March '05)? How long do the clutches tend to last on these SMG's (this car had 11k between services so I guess it hasn't been driven too hard)?

The big question is should I go for this or an early 996??

Raks

1,868 posts

259 months

Friday 30th July 2004
quotequote all
because you said 'early 996' you're better off the the E46 - proven technology by now rather than still in development for that kind of money.

plus, you said well spec'd and you probably wouldn't get a well spec'd 996

All IMHO of course !!

veetwin

1,565 posts

259 months

Friday 30th July 2004
quotequote all
BMW Warranty renewal should set you back £450. Paul, any difference between the performance of the E36 and E46 that you would care to share. No one else need answer this, I thank you.

pdavison

Original Poster:

1,637 posts

279 months

Friday 30th July 2004
quotequote all
James,

Interesting point. It's a while since going in your E36 and owning mine. I would say one of the biggest differences is the rev limit, one it's higher and two it feels as though it gets there so much quicker. It certainly feels quicker and I know that on paper it's quicker but in the real world I still think it would be a closely run thing.

From the relatively brief run I've had in the E46, I think the biggest difference will be when you get to the higher speeds (i.e. 70mph+ on a private road). I believe the E46 would be quite a bit faster at these speeds.

If I go ahead with the purchase I'll let you know and you can see what you think!

texan

227 posts

241 months

Friday 30th July 2004
quotequote all
I bought my M3 SMG convertible just over a month ago and am delighted with it.

I was hesitant about the SMG gearbox, but am now very glad I chose it. The automatic mode is good if you are on the phone or in motorway type traffic jams. One disadvantage of mine is that being LHD, you can't fondle a passenger at the same time as changing up the gears. The car shifts down automatically as you decelerate, so you don't need access to the downshift.

I have the 19" wheels, but took the insurance package tha the garage offered which covers wheels and tyres for three years for $350. Definitely worth it if I have so much as one puncture.

Go fo rthe SMG if you want something a bit out of the ordinary, and a bit more fun. After a bit of practice the gear chanegs can be silky smooth, and if nothing else it's cool to have your hands on the steering wheel for change-ups.

I didn't think the car was that fast when I test drove it, but now that I've had some fun with it I'm pretty impressed. It's a bit lurchy in first and second, and especially in sports mode, but I had it over 130 last weekend for several miles and it wanted to go faster.



Alf Essex

1,467 posts

263 months

Friday 30th July 2004
quotequote all
Well I'm test driving the new M3 tomorrow (saturday)...will let you know what I think.

Alan.

Alf Essex

1,467 posts

263 months

Saturday 31st July 2004
quotequote all
ok well I test drove the car this morning and was very impressed with it (that coming from a Tuscan S driver!) who said he would never own a BM! lol

The SMG was great fun and would need more time to get used to it but have to say I was hooked! The car was great fun in sport mode....

So was able to get a spec in for Mid-Sept'54 delivery Spec as follows;

Titanium Silver with Black Nappa Leather
Elec fold exterior mirrors
front centre arm rest
front seat heating
nav system professional + tv
bluetooth
6 disc cd
harman kardon hi-fi
19 spoke wheels
SMG

Got tracker horizon thrown in also...

Can't wait for Sept and now just need to get rid of the Tuscan S and Peugeot 206gti. lol

Alan.









>> Edited by Alf Essex on Saturday 31st July 15:49

Laingy

676 posts

243 months

Saturday 31st July 2004
quotequote all
I think the TV is the biggest waste of money, I have one and never use it, cant remember the price but seems a lot for something that is never used. Also the reception in London tends to be average too.

douglasr

1,092 posts

274 months

Sunday 1st August 2004
quotequote all
Wrong colour inmho. Collegue at work has carbon black and Imola red interior. Carbon black is not available on the other models in the range, and every BM you see seems to be silver these days.

Alf Essex

1,467 posts

263 months

Monday 2nd August 2004
quotequote all
douglasr said:
Wrong colour inmho. Collegue at work has carbon black and Imola red interior. Carbon black is not available on the other models in the range, and every BM you see seems to be silver these days.


My initial car was going to be the carbon black but then I saw the car in flesh and it didn't show all the lines on the car...so thats why I chose Silver. I might now be thinking of going for the blue leather interior on the silver just as its different...what people think of the blue leather as opposed to the black?

Alan.

Alf Essex

1,467 posts

263 months

Monday 2nd August 2004
quotequote all
In fact just did a search on used BMW and all are silver with black leather! So think I need to change...will keep the silver but have blue leather instead to be a little different

Alan.

Zod

35,295 posts

260 months

Monday 2nd August 2004
quotequote all
Go for individual black/blue leather. Looks superb.

stuwest, I don't think Ted appreciates that kind of thing.

pdavison

Original Poster:

1,637 posts

279 months

Monday 2nd August 2004
quotequote all
The one I drove is silver with black but it's now sold. I think in an ideal world I would opt for carbon black with the red leather.

However, I'm still undecided as I want to try an early 996 and a late 993 to see which I prefer.