M54 B30 oil consumption, new Castrol Edge?
Discussion
My Z4 engine would use about 2l tops between 15k services.
Then at 91k miles I had my last service, and INSP1.
Then when 3k miles after the service popped up it was time to start topping it up again.
I bought the Castrol Edge 5W30 as usual, but it seemed really thin (level in the container was like looking at water). It also said 'new formula' on the container.
Anyway I put it in, and it seemed to get through that oil pretty sharp ish.
Then I bought another one, and now I've used all that one up too.
So I've done about 8k now and used the initial BMW oil, and two litres of 'new' Edge.
I'd say consumption has nearly doubled and the only thing I can say has changed so suddenly is having had the service and also this new formula oil... which as said looked terribly thin when sloshing it in the container and also pouring it into the car.
I'm also sure my mpg has improved a bit, maybe 2mpg, so not sure if that is the cost of a thinner oil?!
Has anyone else noticed increased oil consumption with the 'new formula' Edge oil?
Thanks
Dave
Then at 91k miles I had my last service, and INSP1.
Then when 3k miles after the service popped up it was time to start topping it up again.
I bought the Castrol Edge 5W30 as usual, but it seemed really thin (level in the container was like looking at water). It also said 'new formula' on the container.
Anyway I put it in, and it seemed to get through that oil pretty sharp ish.
Then I bought another one, and now I've used all that one up too.
So I've done about 8k now and used the initial BMW oil, and two litres of 'new' Edge.
I'd say consumption has nearly doubled and the only thing I can say has changed so suddenly is having had the service and also this new formula oil... which as said looked terribly thin when sloshing it in the container and also pouring it into the car.
I'm also sure my mpg has improved a bit, maybe 2mpg, so not sure if that is the cost of a thinner oil?!
Has anyone else noticed increased oil consumption with the 'new formula' Edge oil?
Thanks
Dave
Bit of an update on this.
About 6 weeks ago I bought a 1l top-up of Mobil 1 5W30 and that seems to have gone in 6 weeks/1500miles.
I think the lower it gets the faster it burns it off, as if you keep it brimmed right at the top it doesn't seem to get through it as fast...
Not really sure it's hard to get a good reading of the level on these cars such is the settle time/thermal expansion etc...
Any way, I've bought a 5l from Halfords for £40 which seems great value for top-ups or a full service, the Castrol stuff is £4l for £45!
Oil service is due in 5k mile so will see how long this latest 1l of top-up lasts and report back.
Generally though my mpg is quite a bit better these days, a combo of the new Asymmetric and these thinner but more burny oils?
Man maths still says it's cheaper to buy expensive tyres + oil more often as the fuel costs are king even at only 2mpg improvement!
Cheers
Dave
About 6 weeks ago I bought a 1l top-up of Mobil 1 5W30 and that seems to have gone in 6 weeks/1500miles.
I think the lower it gets the faster it burns it off, as if you keep it brimmed right at the top it doesn't seem to get through it as fast...
Not really sure it's hard to get a good reading of the level on these cars such is the settle time/thermal expansion etc...
Any way, I've bought a 5l from Halfords for £40 which seems great value for top-ups or a full service, the Castrol stuff is £4l for £45!
Oil service is due in 5k mile so will see how long this latest 1l of top-up lasts and report back.
Generally though my mpg is quite a bit better these days, a combo of the new Asymmetric and these thinner but more burny oils?
Man maths still says it's cheaper to buy expensive tyres + oil more often as the fuel costs are king even at only 2mpg improvement!
Cheers
Dave
1 litre of oil every 600 miles is acceptable according to BMW.
The problem stems from the cars being driven too cautiously during their running in periods when new, apparently.
People used the old method of never exceeding 3000 rpm for the first few thousand miles of driving which resulted in glazing of the cylinder bores.
I believe the owners manuals actually advised that the cars should be driven right throughout the rev range, but should not be red-lined. Unfortunately, too many owners thought they knew better than BMW's engineers!
The problem stems from the cars being driven too cautiously during their running in periods when new, apparently.
People used the old method of never exceeding 3000 rpm for the first few thousand miles of driving which resulted in glazing of the cylinder bores.
I believe the owners manuals actually advised that the cars should be driven right throughout the rev range, but should not be red-lined. Unfortunately, too many owners thought they knew better than BMW's engineers!
Cheers for the replies!
That is pretty cheap for the Castrol and Vauxhall/GM oil at the appropriate retailers
I guess while oil is so relatively cheap and the fuel so expensive it makes sense to pay for oil that makes your mpg higher
Just a pain having to keep topping it up
Cheers
Dave
That is pretty cheap for the Castrol and Vauxhall/GM oil at the appropriate retailers

I guess while oil is so relatively cheap and the fuel so expensive it makes sense to pay for oil that makes your mpg higher

Just a pain having to keep topping it up

Cheers
Dave
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




