Another 330D VS 530D
Another 330D VS 530D
Author
Discussion

dema

Original Poster:

380 posts

206 months

Friday 18th May 2012
quotequote all
Looked at E39 530D sport for a while now and tonight, out of curiosity I had a look at couple of E46 330D, power and speed figures are very similar with the exception that the E46 seems more economical and also more expensive even comparing with same miles and year of the bigger sister.

Am I missing something? What drives the difference in price?

Requirements are: 3.0L diesel, estate (don't need a massive space but starting a new family),manual, M sport.

thanks

Vee

3,109 posts

265 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
E 39 has been 2 generations old for over a year, e46 is only just so. E39 is also a1996 design, e46 a few years newer.

NickXX

1,647 posts

249 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
The e39 is a 1996 car, e46 is 1998. The 330d was used from 2000 onwards in both though I believe. The engine was the same in both initially (M57), but the 330d got the M57N in 2003 (204bhp).

I had the choice between 330d and 530d in 2006. I went for the 330d as I preferred the look of the e46, and wanted the better handling car.

Tea Pot One

1,870 posts

259 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
530d feels far bigger and heavy ... 330d far more sporty .... depends what you want .... personally, having had a 330i touring E46 and driven loads of E39 530d's I would choose the 330d every time.

I didn't find the 530d that much more roomy or bigger load space wise ... but I guess it depends what you are trying to put in it smile

dema

Original Poster:

380 posts

206 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks guys,

Well, the car HAS to be fun to drive and a the smaller 330 would have enough space for our needs.

Will look around...

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Had both, well a 530d saloon and 330d touring and saloon.

530d is most likely an auto, hence the poorer consumption. Big and comfortable, but as someone said above, legroom in the back is not much better given the difference in size relative to the E46. Up front there is plenty of space and personally I find the seats more comfortable, with a longer squab for leg support.

330d was more common in a manual, and I'm currently getting c 37mpg whereas my 530d auto only managed about 32-34mpg, but the E46 is generally a lot better on a long motorway run Depends what your driving style is like I suppose. The E46 is big enough to get 2 dogs in the boot (just), but with the seats down there is plenty of room - we had a 5' display cabinet in the boot of mine. Still comfortable, just not quite as good as the E39, but then I'm 6'2 and like a bit of space.

Both can be chipped quite nicely (I used DMS before) and that makes quite a difference, to both performance and economy, in a good way. I'd say that you have to go and try both before you make a decision, but in any event buy on condition, not mileage. Both have weak points in design - E46 front suspension arms are only good to 100k max, E39, ermmm, dunno smile.


bolide

582 posts

285 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
E39 Touring has much, much more load space than an E46 and it's deeper, wider and better-shaped

Nick Froome

dema

Original Poster:

380 posts

206 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
SO, 330 drives better, has better mpg and cost more. The 530 is bigger, looks nicer (old school) cost less and less mpg

Not easy...

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Get both ...

Go on, you know you want to!!!

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
The 3 Series is a generally more appealing car on the used market than the 5 Series. It's perceived as easier to live with, cheaper to run, etc etc. The reality is there isn't much in it but its perception not reality that shapes price, therefore we end up with the ability to buy a 530d for less than a 330d. That said the 530d Sport Touring is probably the most expensive of the E39's left - they are almost M5 money at times.

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
NickXX said:
The engine was the same in both initially (M57), but the 330d got the M57N in 2003 (204bhp).
Not quite true. They shared the same engine for a very short space of time - only in mid 2000. At the E39 facelift in October 2000 the 530d gained the 193bhp variant. In March 2003, prodution of the E39 530d Saloon ended and at the same time the E46 330d gained the 204bhp engine which it kept for another 18 months before production ended for the E90. The result is that like for like (ie, age) a 530d and a 330d offer about the same performance - as the power deficit of the 330d is countered by its marginally lighter weight.

Tourings of each carried on for an extra 6 months or so.

The E39 Touring loadspace is genuinelly useful - it will, for example, swallow a double fridge/freezer. The E46 is more of a 'lifestyle' estate and is less about carrying enormous amounts of junk and more about being a more practical alternative to the Saloon.

Edited by Fox- on Monday 21st May 19:15

dema

Original Poster:

380 posts

206 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks all for the useful info.. I guess a test drive is now due as both have + and - making equals.

Would love have both but at that point I would probably go for a proper M of some sort smile

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Personally I think the E39 is the better car (But then I would!) but it really is a personal preference thing. Another nod in the E46's favour is you will find seeking out a 530d Sport Manual Touring to be a very very difficult task as there are very few of them. They registered only 100 of them - compared with 600 330d Sport Touring Manuals.

dema

Original Poster:

380 posts

206 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
Yep, I noticed that on both models...

So far I only found one car that fits my spec and budget around here, unfortunately the trader isn't replying to the e-mails which is not a good start frown

I start wondering if I should looking for SE models and get a bumper for around £80 as the car will be lowered anyway

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
Lowering an estate? Hmmm best you stick with an e46 if you want to spoil it tongue out

dema

Original Poster:

380 posts

206 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
tongue out

Sump

5,512 posts

198 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
I lowered my E46. It was the eibach pro kit, I think it dropped the car by around 100mm to 150 mm.

Filled the arches alot nicer. Didn't notice anything else.

dema

Original Poster:

380 posts

206 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
100 sounds good plus multi spoke BMW wheels

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
100mm drop?!

Sump

5,512 posts

198 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Nooooo 10mm.

I think it was 10mm at the back and like 15mm at the front or something like that.

Bloody hell, 100mm is like chavtastic.