2001 E46 330i Touring - the ride's too hard.
2001 E46 330i Touring - the ride's too hard.
Author
Discussion

993kimbo

Original Poster:

3,003 posts

216 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Morning all,

Anything I can do to make the ride more comfortable in my 2001 330i Touring? The suspension components are all fine.

2001 330i Touring
17" wheels
Bridgestone Potenza tyres 225 x 45 x 17 - half worn.

In an ideal world I'd put 16" wheels on with 50-55 profile rubber but it can't be done apparently.

Someone suggested buying tyres with a softer sidewall?

Any ideas?

_bryan_

250 posts

210 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
You say all the suspension components are fine but when we're the dampers last replaced?

They might not be leaking but if they're a bit tired there'll be next to no damping left in them, leading to a harsh ride.

993kimbo

Original Poster:

3,003 posts

216 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks Bryan,

No record of them being replaced since new (2001), but the car only has 64,000 miles on it.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Thats 11 year old components - even with the best will in the world, rubber bits do perish.

What do you mean by "too hard"?

993kimbo

Original Poster:

3,003 posts

216 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Some would call it firm, firm but sporty etc. It just doesn't feel like a luxury estate which I think it should be.
It's more like a performance hatchback. On bad roads, you feel it.

I'm convinced it's the low profile tyres.

Jobbo

13,912 posts

295 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Yours is an SE presumably? The 330i does need 17"s to clear the front brakes, so whoever told you that 16"s don't fit was correct.

My specialist has a 318i SE on 15"s and a 320td Compact on 17"s (the ones pictured below which are 7" wide), and the ride isn't that much worse in the Compact, so perhaps you should go for narrower wheels and tyres.



Since I've sold my 330i, I can't check what the tyre options stated on the sticker in the driver's door jamb are but I suspect 17x7 with 205 section tyres (and maybe 50 profile?) would be on there.

993kimbo

Original Poster:

3,003 posts

216 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks Jobbo, currently have 225 x 45 x 17 fitted, but indeed the door jamb says 205 x 50 x 17 can be used.

I have winter tyres in that size and to be honest I can't really tell the difference when they are on, although in theory they should be more comfortable.


Edited by 993kimbo on Saturday 19th May 20:02

Jobbo

13,912 posts

295 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Ah; well at least you know without spending anything! You'd need an E39 5-series on 16"s to have a proper ride I guess.

While I must be more tolerant than you since I didn't find my 330i Sport on 18"s all that bad, I am appreciating the refinement and ride of its replacement 5-series.

993kimbo

Original Poster:

3,003 posts

216 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
It used to be okay but I think the roads are just getting worse. I hate the ones that sound like machine gun fire in the car. I'll look into the 5-series I think. Thanks.

bolide

582 posts

285 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
I had a 330i Sport Touring last year on 18s and thought the ride very acceptable - and I am really fussy

I'd start with replacing the ARB bushes and have a look at all the other suspension bushes at the same time. The tyres are probably part of the problem but if your winter tyres are as bad maybe you just don't like the basic setup

I don't think E46s really do "luxury estate". My E39 doesn't, either, but I am about to replace lots of bushes & fit new tyres so that may do the trick

Nick Froome

Edited by bolide on Saturday 19th May 22:49

993kimbo

Original Poster:

3,003 posts

216 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks Nick,

I think that may be the problem - BMW don't 'do' Luxury Estate. I'd hate to throw money at it and still not be happy. (story of my life).
Maybe a Mercedes would give me the ride I'm after?

ghibbett

1,920 posts

216 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
993kimbo said:
Maybe a Mercedes would give me the ride I'm after?
I have an E46 330i Sport (Saloon) and I personally think the ride is too firm on the 18"s. Today I drove a C63 AMG on the optional 19"s and found it rode ever so slightly better than my E46 on 18"s. I've not tried a C63 on 18"s (yet...), but it certainly shed a little light into BMW's sport/M-sport suspension setups.

bolide

582 posts

285 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
I guess it depends what kind of ride you are after and what you dislike about what you have now

I have found with lots of cars that ARB bushes make a huge difference. The ARB is the stiffest spring on the car so as the bushes wear you get a lumpy, thumpy effect as the bar moves around in the bush. This just adds to the overall bad ride you get from poor UK roads

BMWs seem to suffer badly when fitted with big wheels & tyres. All that unsprung weight can make them feel quite flat-footed. Big wheels will tend to wear the bushes more, the ride will go off and you're in a downward spiral of deteriorating ride, tyres & bushes

I've driven E46s on 18" wheels with 45 profile tyres that I thought were very acceptable. Firm, perhaps a little abrupt at times, but excellent at speed. Great body control as well

Older, softer cars like the W124 do ride well but the downsides are body roll and lack of body control at speed

Nick Froome

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
993kimbo said:
Thanks Nick,

I think that may be the problem - BMW don't 'do' Luxury Estate. I'd hate to throw money at it and still not be happy. (story of my life).
Maybe a Mercedes would give me the ride I'm after?
we had a 2002 e46 330i sport touring and currently a 2002 525i e39 sport touring. the e46 was certainly firmer in comparison to the e39 which has the air assisted suspension so you get more of that 'wafted along' feeling.

i dont think your car is the problem it might be that you need something a little less firm and 'sport' oriented from the outset as you suggest

dubbs

1,599 posts

315 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
I'm currently trying to sell my 2002 E46 330i Sport touring (shameless plug!!) and I have to agree that the suspension is rather too firm for a comfy family wagon.

You've got to really want that suspension to enjoy it - If you expect to waft around gleefully ignoring speed bumps and pot holes then it definitely isn't the car for you.

Output Flange

17,053 posts

242 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
993kimbo said:
Thanks Jobbo, currently have 225 x 45 x 17 fitted, but indeed the door jamb says 205 x 50 x 17 can be used.

I have winter tyres in that size and to be honest I can't really tell the difference when they are on, although in theory they should be more comfortable.


Edited by 993kimbo on Saturday 19th May 20:02
The difference is marginal, though.

Sidewall height is a percentage of the width of the tyre, so the sidewall height on a 225/45/17 is 101.25mm.

On a 205/50/17 it is 102.5mm.

You're getting an extra 1.25mm of sidewall - not enough to make a difference.

Your best bet would be to swap to 225/50/17 tyres instead, although you'll need to consider the effect on the speedo reading (it'll under-read compared to current).

Jobbo

13,912 posts

295 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Output Flange said:
The difference is marginal, though.

Sidewall height is a percentage of the width of the tyre, so the sidewall height on a 225/45/17 is 101.25mm.

On a 205/50/17 it is 102.5mm.

You're getting an extra 1.25mm of sidewall - not enough to make a difference.

Your best bet would be to swap to 225/50/17 tyres instead, although you'll need to consider the effect on the speedo reading (it'll under-read compared to current).
While you're right that the difference seems marginal, in practice (and it may be due to the narrower rims) I've found the 205/50R17 to be comfier than the 225/45R17. Never going to be the panacea, though.

JimexPL

1,455 posts

243 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
I've run our E46 328 on both the original factory option 17's and a set of 16's from a previous E46 that we had.

The 16's are definitely the better size if you don't want a sports car ride, particularly with a decent branded tyre. I also find it more fun at sane road speeds. The 17's will not be going back on until we sell the car.

I'd investigate to see if any of the decent after market wheels would fit over the brakes (BBS etc).

It's also worth checking with BMW to see if your car has sports suspension fitted.