330ci Auto vs Manual
330ci Auto vs Manual
Author
Discussion

aruck

Original Poster:

831 posts

270 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
Afternoon! I'm currently looking for a 05/06 330ci Cabriolet. I want a manual but getting one within a reasonable distance with low enough miles is proving quite difficult. I am wondering if I should consider the auto as there are more around. Does anyone have any experience with the auto or ideally both? The figures state that it is slower. Is this noticeable? Is the auto a good box?
Thanks

Mudfugly

108 posts

202 months

Sunday 20th May 2012
quotequote all
We own an 04 330ci Sport Convertible with the auto box, and previously we had a 330ci coupe with a manual box.

In the real world the auto is no slower, and it's a joy to drive, so easy, you can just tootle around in full auto, or put it into sport mode, thats fun, or manual sequential should you wish.


laingy

676 posts

272 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
auto box is excellent, works very well with the car

Vee

3,109 posts

265 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
My experience is somewhat different.
Ran a 330i auto saloon alongside a manual 330ci.
Both sport, both 2002 cars with around 70k on when sold.

The auto was noticeably slower than the manual.

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
aruck said:
Afternoon! I'm currently looking for a 05/06 330ci Cabriolet. I want a manual but getting one within a reasonable distance with low enough miles is proving quite difficult. I am wondering if I should consider the auto as there are more around. Does anyone have any experience with the auto or ideally both? The figures state that it is slower. Is this noticeable? Is the auto a good box?
Thanks
I've driven both. My 330i is manual, although the 330i auto I drove was only on a test drive.

The auto box has it's reliability problems AFAIK, and the steptronic fetaure seems pointless - it appears to just allow you to decide when you want a very slow gearchange.

The manual box - on my car and by the sounds of it on many similar cars - is not the nicest in the world (it's a bit notchy and can be difficult to change from 1st to 2nd consistently smoothly.

Pay your money and take your choice.

FWIW I'd risk an auto next time, seems to suit the car better IMO.

ETA, didn;'t read the op properly - mine is an '02 E46, not sure if they're the same.


Edited by dr_gn on Monday 21st May 12:05

aruck

Original Poster:

831 posts

270 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
I borrowed my dad's '06 325 convertible last week which is a manual and didnt have any detrimental thoughts about the gearbox. Car felt quite sluggish after my Focus ST hence why I definitely want a 330. Just struggling to find a manual. Have never driven an auto accept on holiday in USA driving long straight roads. Think I may find that the auto irritates me if it doesnt change quick enough when I want it to.

The Auto also appears to do less MPG according to the stats? and less 0-60.

Guess I will just keep looking for the right manual.

Cheers

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
aruck said:
I borrowed my dad's '06 325 convertible last week which is a manual and didnt have any detrimental thoughts about the gearbox. Car felt quite sluggish after my Focus ST hence why I definitely want a 330. Just struggling to find a manual. Have never driven an auto accept on holiday in USA driving long straight roads. Think I may find that the auto irritates me if it doesnt change quick enough when I want it to.

The Auto also appears to do less MPG according to the stats? and less 0-60.

Guess I will just keep looking for the right manual.

Cheers
Auto felt fast enough to me, probably becasue the shifts are pretty seamless.

I think the auto is less economical (depending on how you drive obviously).

The steptronic doesn't give fast shifts at all, just over-rides the normal auto shift points. Real world I found it totally pointless: if you want to drive flat out, just floor the accelerator in "D", if you want to drive slowly, don't.

liller

1,151 posts

200 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
I chose the manual over the auto purely for future reliability issues. I was looking at cars around the 100k mile mark and as such didn't want to be hit with a massive auto box repair bill after 10k miles or so. I'm not saying that they all fail around this mark, it's just my judgement after reading a lot about the reliability of the BMW auto box used in the E46. If you can find one where the transmission fluid has been changed as part of it's regular maintenance then you'll probably be OK also, I wouldn't be that worried about it if the car had only done 50k miles or so.



Mudfugly

108 posts

202 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Forget MPG, these cars are what they are, low to mid 20's, manual 2-3 mpg better, what sort of drive do you want, relaxed, the big engine suits the auto, and in the vert I like cruising along enjoying the scenery.

I believe the auto box is more of an issue with the diesel, which you wont find in a vert, with mine I had the oil and filter changed, cost £150 from my Indy, just as a precaution.