E46 - Wheel wobble woes - HELP
E46 - Wheel wobble woes - HELP
Author
Discussion

mike325112

Original Poster:

1,074 posts

215 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Right chaps I'm starting to get a little annoyed at my 330d at the momment, I've got a rather annoying steering wheel wobble (read shaking) when braking.

In the last week or two, I've had new front wishbone bushes and when that didn't work tried new brake discs and pads, but its still not gone away!

I'm not too annoyed with changing the bushes and the discs as the old ones were getting toward the end of their life anyway. But I don't want to keep throwing money at a problem and not getting a solution. So, anyone got any ideas what it could be that could cause a wobble when braking?

The only things I can think of are tyres (although they appear fine as I get no wobble when not braking) or something else in the suspension (wishbones? or are there any more bushes?). The cars done 85k and had a degree of wobbling under braking for a while but I just presumed it was because the bushes were shot.

Any help appreciated....


billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
I had the same problem on my E36, the wheel would wobble/vibrate badly under medium-high speed braking. To attempt to rectify this I replaced both front discs and calipers with no real improvement. Then I happened to find some nice BBS alloys which I bought 4 new Continental tyres for. I put these on and took the original BMW alloys with unmatched tyres off. The wheels were balanced, wheel alignment and tracking done. This change had the somewhat unexpected benefit of stopping the steering wheel wobble under braking. Luckily I happened to chance upon this cure before replacing expensive steering/suspension components..

JimexPL

1,455 posts

243 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Having gone through this on several bmws, new lower ball joint/wishbone cures this 99% of the time. Failing that, your steering rack probably has some internal play in it, so an exchange rack will be necessary.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Mine does this too...

Going to have the blighter poly bushed all over then see if ti is new shock time etc...

tgr

1,256 posts

202 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
As bzb implies, perhaps your wheels aren't true. bmw alloys can be soft

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Sigh.... Are you insinuating I need to buy some BBS wheels... is that it? And some nice beefy brakes to live behind them?

If I must...

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
JimexPL said:
Having gone through this on several bmws, new lower ball joint/wishbone cures this 99% of the time. Failing that, your steering rack probably has some internal play in it, so an exchange rack will be necessary.
Can the balljoints be pressed in and out of the wishbones? Read in a BMW magazine that people use E30 ones can be used in E36 wishbones.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
coombsfh said:
Can the balljoints be pressed in and out of the wishbones? Read in a BMW magazine that people use E30 ones can be used in E36 wishbones.
They're alloy arms, BMW do not sell separate ball joints for the arms, whether they are E46 or E30 arms.

Believe pattern E30 arms, eg Lemforder, which are steels not alloy, do have replaceable ball joints.

BMminiparts sell the BMW value line wishbone kit (2X wishbones, 2X bushes plus associated hardware) for E46 Msports for £270+VAT plus a bit of delivery, my local dealer wants £463.83 +VAT for the same kit.

Oxhead

92 posts

187 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Had the same problem myself, turned out to be a warped brake disc caused by a sticking brake calliper, took the calliper of and replaced all the seals, gave it a good clean and it sorted it out! Might be worth a look, easy to do if you're handy with a socket set!

8Tech

2,221 posts

229 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Firstly, which wishbone bushes did you use? Cheap and nasty ones can last no time at all and if installed out-of-line, will fail almost immediately.

Fit Powerflex bushes and be done with that problem FOREVER.

Next, check for a sticky caliper, this will cause brake judder.

Finally, were the balljoints checked when the wishbone bushes were done? If not, they should have been.

Yes, you can install solid E30 balljoints into the later arms but its more expensive than buying complete, decent quality arms.

Mudfugly

108 posts

202 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Suspect sticking brake caliper(s), are you also getting a steering wheel shake around 35-40, not under braking ?

kentmotorcompany

2,471 posts

241 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
I suspect tyres, especially if they are one or more of the following:

1) Mismatched, including one older than the other.
2) Cheap Brands.
3) More than half worn.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
Mudfugly said:
Suspect sticking brake caliper(s), are you also getting a steering wheel shake around 35-40, not under braking ?
My guess too. Mine has this issue - getting it fixed later this week hopefully.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st May 2012
quotequote all
I am relatively handy with a socket set BUT have NO time as I ddo work stuff from 0600 - 1900 and then have to exercise every day.

Will just throw it at the BMW specialist garage (Clayton Cars) and then see what they reckon...

mike325112

Original Poster:

1,074 posts

215 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
Right - quick update...

The new wishbone bushes are OEM, pads and discs are textar discs with Afe pads. When I did the brakes I checked the calipers and gave thema good clean too - they are definately not sticking.

I think its the tyres - they are some cheapies that were on the car when we bought it. Im going to swap them with the rears at the weekend and see if that makes a difference.

Cheers for all the suggestions though chaps.

kentmotorcompany

2,471 posts

241 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
mike325112 said:
Right - quick update...

The new wishbone bushes are OEM, pads and discs are textar discs with Afe pads. When I did the brakes I checked the calipers and gave thema good clean too - they are definately not sticking.

I think its the tyres - they are some cheapies that were on the car when we bought it. Im going to swap them with the rears at the weekend and see if that makes a difference.

Cheers for all the suggestions though chaps.
Tyres will be different sizes front to rear.
Although I don't see why you couldn't swap the wheels over for a short test drive to confirm if it makes a difference and then spend the money on tyres after that.


mike325112

Original Poster:

1,074 posts

215 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
kentmotorcompany said:
Tyres will be different sizes front to rear.
Although I don't see why you couldn't swap the wheels over for a short test drive to confirm if it makes a difference and then spend the money on tyres after that.
Thats interesting - mine has 225/45 R17s on all round. Its running 68M style wheels - I wonder if that has something to do with it. It had 225/45's on when we bought it...

Looking at this http://www.alloywheelsdirect.net/bmw_alloy_wheels/... I should have different wheels!!!!

Any ideas how I'd tell the wheel size?




E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
mike325112 said:
Thats interesting - mine has 225/45 R17s on all round. Its running 68M style wheels - I wonder if that has something to do with it. It had 225/45's on when we bought it...

Looking at this http://www.alloywheelsdirect.net/bmw_alloy_wheels/... I should have different wheels!!!!

Any ideas how I'd tell the wheel size?
If it's not on the front face of the wheel, around the 'BMW' centre cap then it will be on the inside of the spokes, should be 7.5x17 front and 8.5x17 rear. It maybe that someone has just fitted the wrong size tyres on the rear, 225/45 instead of 245/40's on the rear wheels.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
Sorry to keep jumping in on this thread but it sounds like your problem is identical to mine.

When I corner hard to the right the wheel "tramps" (read bumps up and down) too easily. Furthermore, if I am on any radius of right hand bend and I apply brakes, it shakes like hell.

I know the RCA bushes need doing, as do the RTAB's but I reckon it could be a buggered shock or rubbish tyres since I have "Jinyu" something or others on there.

Will keep posting till it is fixed.

Is it always prudent to do the whole wishbone as well as lollipop just to avoid future failure of balljoints or just change them if needed?

Best,

Fred.

Road2Ruin

6,557 posts

247 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
I had this problem years ago on my saab... Turned out to be the tyre the garage said I must have hit a pot hole and weakened it somehow! The only way I could isolate it was to put the spare on and drive it. As you probably dont have a spare see if you can borrow one from somewhere to try.