A couple of questions about my new E46 328i
Discussion
Hi guys,
I've recently bought this '99 328i saloon:

I'll have a thread in Readers' Cars as soon as I can with all the details and my experiences so far, I owe it to PH because it's largely due to advice from here that I ended up with this car! Absolutely lovely, and very highly specced.
I do have a couple of questions, though. The car doesn't sound quite right - I feel like I have the full 190bhp I should, but there's a deep booming sort of noise from the engine at lower revs which I didn't expect. Basically, under load below 4krpm it sounds like a four-pot with a loud exhaust, except the noise is definitely engine side, ie. in front of me. It is also persistent at an 80mph cruise, and sometimes actually gets louder on the overrun. I'm thinking of perhaps some sort of exhaust manifold gasket leak? Is it a common thing you guys have heard of?
Also, I could do with a new key as the one I have is looking a bit tired and the lock button is a bit dodgy. It's a three-button type (big round lock button, smaller unlock and boot release, all rubberised black). Is it possible to simply get a different case, cut the key to suit and transplant the innards?
I've recently bought this '99 328i saloon:

I'll have a thread in Readers' Cars as soon as I can with all the details and my experiences so far, I owe it to PH because it's largely due to advice from here that I ended up with this car! Absolutely lovely, and very highly specced.
I do have a couple of questions, though. The car doesn't sound quite right - I feel like I have the full 190bhp I should, but there's a deep booming sort of noise from the engine at lower revs which I didn't expect. Basically, under load below 4krpm it sounds like a four-pot with a loud exhaust, except the noise is definitely engine side, ie. in front of me. It is also persistent at an 80mph cruise, and sometimes actually gets louder on the overrun. I'm thinking of perhaps some sort of exhaust manifold gasket leak? Is it a common thing you guys have heard of?
Also, I could do with a new key as the one I have is looking a bit tired and the lock button is a bit dodgy. It's a three-button type (big round lock button, smaller unlock and boot release, all rubberised black). Is it possible to simply get a different case, cut the key to suit and transplant the innards?
Nice looking car - congratulations.
I've had an '02 330i Sport for about a month now (1000 miles in) and it ain't the most refined engine in the world in terms of noise levels. Could be exhaust...I dunno I can't put my finger on it. There's something not quite right about the noise levels in the car at anything over 30mph.
One other thing: Did you check the rear subframe mounts for cracks?
I've had an '02 330i Sport for about a month now (1000 miles in) and it ain't the most refined engine in the world in terms of noise levels. Could be exhaust...I dunno I can't put my finger on it. There's something not quite right about the noise levels in the car at anything over 30mph.
One other thing: Did you check the rear subframe mounts for cracks?
Thanks, dr_gn! I'm very happy with it so far, and as I say, I'll get a proper thread up soon. Incredibly busy at the minute! The main reason I was concerned about the engine noise is that it does not correlate with what I remember these engines sounding like, my housemate agrees that it's not singing like it should, and a bit of YouTube analysis kind of confirms it. I have a surprisingly deep, growly sort of sound from even moderate load at low revs that doesn't really change in volume or pitch even if you wrap it right round the dial. Doesn't seem right at all. It's also extremely loud at a cold start.
Thanks for the link, Rabbo, looks like a decent service - have you used them yourself? Ideally I'd like something I can buy in and do myself because I can't be without the key for any considerable period, though. Just wondering whether this car would object to that being done.
Thanks for the link, Rabbo, looks like a decent service - have you used them yourself? Ideally I'd like something I can buy in and do myself because I can't be without the key for any considerable period, though. Just wondering whether this car would object to that being done.
McSam said:
Thanks, dr_gn! I'm very happy with it so far, and as I say, I'll get a proper thread up soon. Incredibly busy at the minute! The main reason I was concerned about the engine noise is that it does not correlate with what I remember these engines sounding like, my housemate agrees that it's not singing like it should, and a bit of YouTube analysis kind of confirms it. I have a surprisingly deep, growly sort of sound from even moderate load at low revs that doesn't really change in volume or pitch even if you wrap it right round the dial. Doesn't seem right at all. It's also extremely loud at a cold start.
Thanks for the link, Rabbo, looks like a decent service - have you used them yourself? Ideally I'd like something I can buy in and do myself because I can't be without the key for any considerable period, though. Just wondering whether this car would object to that being done.
This might be complete balls, but on mine there's a thing in the manifold to adjust the inlet tract length - maybe that's faulty if it's fitted on yours? Also there's some kind of flap valve in the rear silencer I think...ditto.Thanks for the link, Rabbo, looks like a decent service - have you used them yourself? Ideally I'd like something I can buy in and do myself because I can't be without the key for any considerable period, though. Just wondering whether this car would object to that being done.
Sorry I'm still finding my way around these cars, but I'm sure the experts will chip in soon enough.
dr_gn said:
This might be complete balls, but on mine there's a thing in the manifold to adjust the inlet tract length - maybe that's faulty if it's fitted on yours? Also there's some kind of flap valve in the rear silencer I think...ditto.
Sorry I'm still finding my way around these cars, but I'm sure the experts will chip in soon enough.
Hmmm.. It's a possibility, if the inlet tract was constantly set in its high revs position it would cause some interesting sound qualities and would also explain why it feels slightly lacking in urge in the lower end of the rev range. Makes sense. As the noise seems to be very distinctly coming from the engine side rather than the exhaust end, it seems less likely to be anything aft of the cats.Sorry I'm still finding my way around these cars, but I'm sure the experts will chip in soon enough.
Thanks for that, let the Googling commence

McSam said:
dr_gn said:
This might be complete balls, but on mine there's a thing in the manifold to adjust the inlet tract length - maybe that's faulty if it's fitted on yours? Also there's some kind of flap valve in the rear silencer I think...ditto.
Sorry I'm still finding my way around these cars, but I'm sure the experts will chip in soon enough.
Hmmm.. It's a possibility, if the inlet tract was constantly set in its high revs position it would cause some interesting sound qualities and would also explain why it feels slightly lacking in urge in the lower end of the rev range. Makes sense. As the noise seems to be very distinctly coming from the engine side rather than the exhaust end, it seems less likely to be anything aft of the cats.Sorry I'm still finding my way around these cars, but I'm sure the experts will chip in soon enough.
Thanks for that, let the Googling commence

From what I've read it's pretty easy to remove and have a poke around. Worth a try.
ETA, it's not something completely daft like not having a air filter element is it?
Edited by dr_gn on Tuesday 22 May 23:27
Ahah, the DISA valve, I knew that term from looking into other stuff! I see there is indeed a lot on YouTube so I'll pull it out and have a look. Thanks a lot for the heads up, promising stuff
and yes, I do actually need to have a butchers at the air filter too because if it's chavtastic or has a great big hole in it that would also explain the symptoms 
While I'm at it, I don't know how many of you guys have manual E46 sixes, but mine is quite.. agricultural in its gearshift. The Audi ('96 A4 2.6) was lovely, but this is a long throw and quite a lot of effort. I have the usual little niggles with fifth, but it's more how much force I have to use to get it into the gate that makes me wonder. Would a proper gearbox oil flush help me, or do "they all do that, Sir"?
I forgot to answer about the rear subframe - I haven't had a proper look but it sure as hell feels sound and had been looked after by specialists throughout its life, so I'm not too worried but will check it out thoroughly soon.
and yes, I do actually need to have a butchers at the air filter too because if it's chavtastic or has a great big hole in it that would also explain the symptoms 
While I'm at it, I don't know how many of you guys have manual E46 sixes, but mine is quite.. agricultural in its gearshift. The Audi ('96 A4 2.6) was lovely, but this is a long throw and quite a lot of effort. I have the usual little niggles with fifth, but it's more how much force I have to use to get it into the gate that makes me wonder. Would a proper gearbox oil flush help me, or do "they all do that, Sir"?
I forgot to answer about the rear subframe - I haven't had a proper look but it sure as hell feels sound and had been looked after by specialists throughout its life, so I'm not too worried but will check it out thoroughly soon.
McSam said:
Ahah, the DISA valve, I knew that term from looking into other stuff! I see there is indeed a lot on YouTube so I'll pull it out and have a look. Thanks a lot for the heads up, promising stuff
and yes, I do actually need to have a butchers at the air filter too because if it's chavtastic or has a great big hole in it that would also explain the symptoms 
While I'm at it, I don't know how many of you guys have manual E46 sixes, but mine is quite.. agricultural in its gearshift. The Audi ('96 A4 2.6) was lovely, but this is a long throw and quite a lot of effort. I have the usual little niggles with fifth, but it's more how much force I have to use to get it into the gate that makes me wonder. Would a proper gearbox oil flush help me, or do "they all do that, Sir"?
I forgot to answer about the rear subframe - I haven't had a proper look but it sure as hell feels sound and had been looked after by specialists throughout its life, so I'm not too worried but will check it out thoroughly soon.
Gearbox - Mines the worst part of the car (a bit notchy, difficult to change smoothly 1st - 2nd), especially after the rifle-bolt action of my old Prelude. The summary of advice seems to be:
and yes, I do actually need to have a butchers at the air filter too because if it's chavtastic or has a great big hole in it that would also explain the symptoms 
While I'm at it, I don't know how many of you guys have manual E46 sixes, but mine is quite.. agricultural in its gearshift. The Audi ('96 A4 2.6) was lovely, but this is a long throw and quite a lot of effort. I have the usual little niggles with fifth, but it's more how much force I have to use to get it into the gate that makes me wonder. Would a proper gearbox oil flush help me, or do "they all do that, Sir"?
I forgot to answer about the rear subframe - I haven't had a proper look but it sure as hell feels sound and had been looked after by specialists throughout its life, so I'm not too worried but will check it out thoroughly soon.
1) Change the gearbox oil.
2) If it's fitted, remove the clutch damper valve (CDV).
These two things made a huge improvement to mine.
3) Technique - it's taken me weeks to get used to the 1st to 2nd shift on mine. I find shifting at 2500 - 3000rpm is best - seems to like higher revs. Keep the lever pushed over to the left while changing - don't let it try to centre at all (I found a bit of 'thumb downwards' action helps).
4) There is a known issue with gate springs sticking/breaking and pushing the lever fully over to the right by default. It's a 5 minute job (one the gearbox is out!).
I think the fact is they're not great gearboxes...
kev b said:
The manual gearbox/clutch is the worst feature of the 2.8 3 series, that's why mine has an autobox, if that helps at all.
Go away 
dr_gn, it's nice to know that it can at least be improved a bit! Mine has 135,000 miles and I'd be very surprised if the gearbox oil has been changed, so I'll make that a priority and get it done when I service it in a couple of weeks. Shall also look into this CDV you mention - where do I locate that, if you've done it yourself?

I have noticed that first to second is a little awkward, my technique is usually very definite in going directly between the gates rather than pissing about letting it centre, and I do my gearchanges quickly enough that the revs don't drop below what's needed in the next gear. I have noticed a distinct "thud" from the gearbox when engaging gears, though, which interestingly doesn't seem to correlate with clutch movement - depress the clutch fully, move from say second to third and you can hear it whump as it disengages one then again as the next comes in. Odd.
I did know about the issue with it liking to centre below fifth, which has caught me out a couple of times dropping fifth to third approaching roundabouts! Almost used to that now. It's a little disappointing as the Audi's gearbox is superb, and if you're going to sell it as the "ultimate driving machine", why's it got a very long throw on a lumpy 'box?
Doing some investigation of the whole inlet tract this afternoon when I wash it, cheers for all your ideas

If you can get the car on a lift or axle stands you could check the gearbox and engine mountings for wear/cracking then check the rubber propshaft joint and the diff mounting bushes. The last two are most likely, also look at the driveshaft cv joints and check for play in the diff, check/ change the diff for leaks and change the oil whilst you are there, they only need 1 litre. There are a number of specialist manual gearbox oils that can make the box smoother, especially when cold. Also your clutch may be sticking or have worn springs, have someone press the pedal whilst you are underneath and listen for ominous noises.Better check the subframe mountings as well whilst you are at it, in fact check everything! HTH - I'm going for a drive in my slick changing auto now, I hope you can find the problem with your tractor box - Kev
McSam said:
kev b said:
The manual gearbox/clutch is the worst feature of the 2.8 3 series, that's why mine has an autobox, if that helps at all.
Go away 
dr_gn, it's nice to know that it can at least be improved a bit! Mine has 135,000 miles and I'd be very surprised if the gearbox oil has been changed, so I'll make that a priority and get it done when I service it in a couple of weeks. Shall also look into this CDV you mention - where do I locate that, if you've done it yourself?

I have noticed that first to second is a little awkward, my technique is usually very definite in going directly between the gates rather than pissing about letting it centre, and I do my gearchanges quickly enough that the revs don't drop below what's needed in the next gear. I have noticed a distinct "thud" from the gearbox when engaging gears, though, which interestingly doesn't seem to correlate with clutch movement - depress the clutch fully, move from say second to third and you can hear it whump as it disengages one then again as the next comes in. Odd.
I did know about the issue with it liking to centre below fifth, which has caught me out a couple of times dropping fifth to third approaching roundabouts! Almost used to that now. It's a little disappointing as the Audi's gearbox is superb, and if you're going to sell it as the "ultimate driving machine", why's it got a very long throw on a lumpy 'box?
Doing some investigation of the whole inlet tract this afternoon when I wash it, cheers for all your ideas

ETA you might find this useful:
http://www.pistonheads.com/xforums/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Basically, the cooling system should be thoroughly checked. Mine looked fine at a glance, but I went ahead and replaced the rad, pump etc. I was glad I did becasue when the rad. was removed, the lower tubes virtually fell out of the bottom even though the visible bits at the top looked fine. Also beware that if you look from the front you're looking at the aircon condenser not the rad!
Edited by dr_gn on Wednesday 23 May 12:03
Thanks a lot for the hit list, Kev - I'll be having it up on ramps as soon as exams are done in four weeks' time. All makes good sense for diagnosing the thud I've been getting.
Thanks also for that link, dr_gn - I think I'd actually seen that thread before but now it bears new revelance, and I did hear about radiators on these cars. I'll look into the history to see about the water pump. I can feel a checklist coming on!
I've just had a bit of a poke around and seen that the air filter is a standard part and in decent condition, maybe 20,000 average miles, so I'll replace it when doing other stuff but it's not causing me any of the noise problems. No apparent leaks in the intake system - what we're getting, though, is a very distinct loud blowing sort of noise from the exhaust side of the engine, which is most noticable when starting from cold but sounds like it's what's causing the noise issues throughout the rev range. How hard is it to get a look down there? All quite obscured as the engine is now.
There's also a faint rattling sort of thing coming from the inlet side, which could be in the manifold itself, though I didn't get to take much apart so couldn't find it for sure. I need to look in more detail at DISA stuff to work out exactly where the unit is in my car and how I could for example cut power to it to see if it quietens things.
If this video is accurate, I think I have pulled the plug on the DISA with the engine running and had no change. The rattling didn't seem to come from the black oblong box he indicates in the video.
Thanks also for that link, dr_gn - I think I'd actually seen that thread before but now it bears new revelance, and I did hear about radiators on these cars. I'll look into the history to see about the water pump. I can feel a checklist coming on!
I've just had a bit of a poke around and seen that the air filter is a standard part and in decent condition, maybe 20,000 average miles, so I'll replace it when doing other stuff but it's not causing me any of the noise problems. No apparent leaks in the intake system - what we're getting, though, is a very distinct loud blowing sort of noise from the exhaust side of the engine, which is most noticable when starting from cold but sounds like it's what's causing the noise issues throughout the rev range. How hard is it to get a look down there? All quite obscured as the engine is now.
There's also a faint rattling sort of thing coming from the inlet side, which could be in the manifold itself, though I didn't get to take much apart so couldn't find it for sure. I need to look in more detail at DISA stuff to work out exactly where the unit is in my car and how I could for example cut power to it to see if it quietens things.
If this video is accurate, I think I have pulled the plug on the DISA with the engine running and had no change. The rattling didn't seem to come from the black oblong box he indicates in the video.
Edited by McSam on Wednesday 23 May 14:57
Once you have it on stands, take off the undertray, easy peasy with a crosshead screwdriver, the exhaust manifold is then easier to see. As a bonus you can also look under the inlet manfold for leaks/splits in the piping. Are you doing this work yourself? If you have to pay someone to do it all for you then you might need deep pockets,there can be a lot of work on a high mileage E46. Good Luck - Kev B
You can see everything you need up on stands,I just repaired my floorpan whilst the car was on stands, get a good light and a mirror and you are good to go. ETA if you have to remove the downpipes from the manifolds take it somewhere to loosen the nuts with gas bottles first and save yourself hours of grief ( ask me how I know)
I made some ramps out of pairs of 100mm x 100mm x 1m long timber and some wedges. You can drive the front of the car on, then put the rear ones under and raise the car a useful amount that way. Never sure where to put axle stands on mine. They don't seem to fit too well under the jacking points, and if you do use them, where do you jack the car?
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



