E46 as a daily urban driver
E46 as a daily urban driver
Author
Discussion

freenote

Original Poster:

805 posts

199 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Guys, after some advice please.

Fed up with my current French shopping trolley and needing to get back into something fun and premium.

Looking at E46 318ci. I know it's going to be lacking in power a little but I need something that won't drink too much when sat in London traffic day-in, day-out.

I have about £3500 to spend and have seen cars around 50k - 80k miles c2003 facelift model.

My questions to the experts:
- At that level is it likely to drain my wallet in maintenance? I realise it will likely cost more to run than the newer Pug but can't afford to throw thousands pa at it.
- Will it survive the trauma of short trips, business use and sitting in traffic on a daily basis?
- Anything obvious to look for when viewing?
- Would you change a '07 Pug 207 with 25k on the clock for the above?

Any other thoughts very welcome

Alex

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
i really wouldn't bother with a 318. 6 cylinder yes, 4 pot....no thanks. certainly not for that price! that's absurdly expensive for a 318; you can get a 330 for that price if you look well enough.

freenote

Original Poster:

805 posts

199 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
i really wouldn't bother with a 318. 6 cylinder yes, 4 pot....no thanks. certainly not for that price! that's absurdly expensive for a 318; you can get a 330 for that price if you look well enough.
Forgive my ignorance but given cost of fuel and the age of the car in question, doesn't it make semse for the 330 to be cheaper than a 318?

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
If you want it for town driving, definitely get an auto. My 330i's in great condition (68k), but the manual gerabox is a bit of a dog. Not just mine either...

Edited by dr_gn on Thursday 24th May 08:57

dooosuk

464 posts

256 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Been nothing wrong with the two manual gearboxes I've had on the two E46 330ci Sports I've owned.

What's 'a dog' about it?

dr_gn

16,992 posts

215 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
dooosuk said:
Been nothing wrong with the two manual gearboxes I've had on the two E46 330ci Sports I've owned.

What's 'a dog' about it?
It's all relative I guess. The three manual E-46's I've driven (test drives and my own car) have all been notchy, with long throws and a bit of a rubbery feel. Throw in the CDV and old oil and it makes setting off and changing from first to second a real chore. The gearbox on my old and knackered Honda Prelude was way better.

The lever springs/plungers also commonly fail, leaving the lever spring loaded to the right. I test drove one that had failed (hopeless) and mine's on it's way. Easy fix though apparently (once the gearbox is out!).

Luca Brasi

885 posts

205 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Buying a 330 to stand in traffic all day? Will be using quite some fuel, much better off with smaller and much more economical 207 imo.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
^^^^^
This.

freenote

Original Poster:

805 posts

199 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Luca Brasi said:
Buying a 330 to stand in traffic all day? Will be using quite some fuel, much better off with smaller and much more economical 207 imo.
I appreciate this but I need something a bit more grownup for meeting clients etc - unfortunately first impressions do count.

Luca Brasi

885 posts

205 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
freenote said:
I appreciate this but I need something a bit more grownup for meeting clients etc - unfortunately first impressions do count.
Have you considered a diesel E46?

freenote

Original Poster:

805 posts

199 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Luca Brasi said:
Have you considered a diesel E46?
Only do about 8k miles a year

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
freenote said:
Luca Brasi said:
Have you considered a diesel E46?
Only do about 8k miles a year
so if only doing 8k miles a year thus no point diesel, why not get the 330? or am i missing something?

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
318i's of that age (01 onwards) have the 2.0 Valvetronic engine which hasn't exactly covered itself with glory. Chain tensioners, crank sensors, oil leaks - they're bloody horrible things really and so ordinary to drive. Diesels are a minefield as well. For your mileage I'd look at a 2.2 litre 320Ci. They go quite well, sound lovely and aren't too savage on fuel. The 325i and 330i are probably no worse on fuel. The SE rides rather better than an M Sport.
They aren't as well built and reliable as they ought to be. Rusty front wings, shagged radiators, balljoints, tired leather and a baggy and distinctly secondhand feel mean they're often no better than your Peugeot tbh. But a nice one is a pleasant tram.

freenote

Original Poster:

805 posts

199 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
iSore said:
318i's of that age (01 onwards) have the 2.0 Valvetronic engine which hasn't exactly covered itself with glory. Chain tensioners, crank sensors, oil leaks - they're bloody horrible things really and so ordinary to drive. Diesels are a minefield as well. For your mileage I'd look at a 2.2 litre 320Ci. They go quite well, sound lovely and aren't too savage on fuel. The 325i and 330i are probably no worse on fuel. The SE rides rather better than an M Sport.
They aren't as well built and reliable as they ought to be. Rusty front wings, shagged radiators, balljoints, tired leather and a baggy and distinctly secondhand feel mean they're often no better than your Peugeot tbh. But a nice one is a pleasant tram.
Very helpful...many thanks.

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
i really wouldn't bother with a 318. 6 cylinder yes, 4 pot....no thanks. certainly not for that price! that's absurdly expensive for a 318; you can get a 330 for that price if you look well enough.
Not a facelift Coupe you won't.

Though my personal view is that if you spend all day in traffic then who cares how big the engine is or how many MPG it does? You can't be doing 20k a year sat in a queue so you presumably dont drive far enough for it to be a big deal.

Vroomer

1,889 posts

211 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
An E46 330i will give you 30mpg on a run, but with lots of town driving you'll struggle to get much over 20mpg.

stevesuk

1,377 posts

213 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
Vroomer said:
An E46 330i will give you 30mpg on a run, but with lots of town driving you'll struggle to get much over 20mpg.
Took my 2002 E46 330 Ci on a nice run up to Teddington in Middlesex from here in Poole, Dorset for work yesterday.

Since I left in plenty of time (and was being paid a fixed rate per mile on expenses), I didn't rush. Just sat in the nice comfy seat, with the aircon on full blast and had a relaxing cruise up the M27/M3, usually between 65 and 75mph.

Encountered a bit of traffic and sat in a few jams (especially in Teddington), but by the time I pulled on to my driveway after 200 miles of driving, the trip computer was reading 37.6 MPG... it had been reading well over 38 MPG earlier in the journey, and the range computer had been suggesting I'd be good for over 500 miles (maybe a little optimistic!)

So when driven gently, they will return pretty decent MPG. Especially when you consider the size and age of the engine.

On shorter journeys, I typically see somewhere between 25 and 30mpg. But then Poole isn't a very busy place. I suspect in the centre of a big city in lots of stop/start traffic, it would be a lot worse.

Mines a manual. My experience with the auto (I used to have a 320 Ci) is that on a motorway run you can achieve very similar MPG to the manual, but round town its a fair bit worse.

I did the same journey not long ago in a brand new Enterprise Ford Focus 1.6 Diesel (with loads of eco features like auto stop/start). To be honest, although it was better on fuel round town, once out on the motorway it was slow and not that much more economic than the 330i (not worth driving a small diesel for anyway!) - I think I've rather have my BMW thank you smile

corvus

431 posts

183 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
Luca Brasi said:
Buying a 330 to stand in traffic all day? Will be using quite some fuel, much better off with smaller and much more economical 207 imo.
I agree. A waste of a car like the 330 to start stop in town traffic. It needs to stretch it's legs. Better off with something like a Mini for town use and fun driving.

Vroomer

1,889 posts

211 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
stevesuk said:
Vroomer said:
An E46 330i will give you 30mpg on a run, but with lots of town driving you'll struggle to get much over 20mpg.
Took my 2002 E46 330 Ci on a nice run up to Teddington in Middlesex from here in Poole, Dorset for work yesterday.

Since I left in plenty of time (and was being paid a fixed rate per mile on expenses), I didn't rush. Just sat in the nice comfy seat, with the aircon on full blast and had a relaxing cruise up the M27/M3, usually between 65 and 75mph.

Encountered a bit of traffic and sat in a few jams (especially in Teddington), but by the time I pulled on to my driveway after 200 miles of driving, the trip computer was reading 37.6 MPG... it had been reading well over 38 MPG earlier in the journey, and the range computer had been suggesting I'd be good for over 500 miles (maybe a little optimistic!)

So when driven gently, they will return pretty decent MPG. Especially when you consider the size and age of the engine.

On shorter journeys, I typically see somewhere between 25 and 30mpg. But then Poole isn't a very busy place. I suspect in the centre of a big city in lots of stop/start traffic, it would be a lot worse.

Mines a manual. My experience with the auto (I used to have a 320 Ci) is that on a motorway run you can achieve very similar MPG to the manual, but round town its a fair bit worse.

I did the same journey not long ago in a brand new Enterprise Ford Focus 1.6 Diesel (with loads of eco features like auto stop/start). To be honest, although it was better on fuel round town, once out on the motorway it was slow and not that much more economic than the 330i (not worth driving a small diesel for anyway!) - I think I've rather have my BMW thank you smile
Should have made it clear – I was talking about an auto.

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
corvus said:
I agree. A waste of a car like the 330 to start stop in town traffic. It needs to stretch it's legs. Better off with something like a Mini for town use and fun driving.
I find my 530 lovely in town traffic. It's comfortable, relaxing and its fuel consumption becomes an irrelevence when the journey is short. I'd imagine the 330i will be much the same. Far better than sitting in a pokey little hatchback.