E46 tyre size...
E46 tyre size...
Author
Discussion

DJC

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

239 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Sorry, newbie question:

I have a 318 Touring, fitted with Style 42 wheels and currently shod with 225/50/16 tyres.



In my untrained opinion, 225 width seems very much overkill for something as asthmatic as the M43 engine'd 318. In addition, the tyre size seems quite unusual and as such decent tyres seem to be £115 - £150 a corner.

The handbook suggests that 16" wheels can also be fitted with 205/55/16 tyres. Decent tyres in this size can be had for £75-£95 a corner, and the size seems a bit more suited to the car.

So, can I fit 205 width tyres on a 7J wheel? If I do, am I likely to discern any noticeable difference in ride/handling?

renoufey

2 posts

201 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
DJC said:
Sorry, newbie question:

I have a 318 Touring, fitted with Style 42 wheels and currently shod with 225/50/16 tyres.



In my untrained opinion, 225 width seems very much overkill for something as asthmatic as the M43 engine'd 318. In addition, the tyre size seems quite unusual and as such decent tyres seem to be £115 - £150 a corner.

The handbook suggests that 16" wheels can also be fitted with 205/55/16 tyres. Decent tyres in this size can be had for £75-£95 a corner, and the size seems a bit more suited to the car.

So, can I fit 205 width tyres on a 7J wheel? If I do, am I likely to discern any noticeable difference in ride/handling?
Hi,

225/50/16 is the correct size for that wheel, going from 225/50 to 205/55/16 is raising the wall height and having thinner tyres on the wheel, Not Good unless you went down to 205/40or 45

Have a look on My Tyres for prise comparison and may be look at another make of tyre like Nankang NS-2
as that is a very good mid range tyre or even Kumho Ecsta SPT KU31 another good tyre, I run Nankang Ultra Sport tyres on my e60 530d and love them in all weathers....

http://ssl.delti.com/cgi-bin/rshop.pl

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
renoufey said:
Hi,

225/50/16 is the correct size for that wheel, going from 225/50 to 205/55/16 is raising the wall height and having thinner tyres on the wheel, Not Good unless you went down to 205/40or 45
There's a 1mm rolling circumference difference between the two size.

OP, 205/55 16's will be fine.

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
renoufey said:
DJC said:
Sorry, newbie question:

I have a 318 Touring, fitted with Style 42 wheels and currently shod with 225/50/16 tyres.



In my untrained opinion, 225 width seems very much overkill for something as asthmatic as the M43 engine'd 318. In addition, the tyre size seems quite unusual and as such decent tyres seem to be £115 - £150 a corner.

The handbook suggests that 16" wheels can also be fitted with 205/55/16 tyres. Decent tyres in this size can be had for £75-£95 a corner, and the size seems a bit more suited to the car.

So, can I fit 205 width tyres on a 7J wheel? If I do, am I likely to discern any noticeable difference in ride/handling?
Hi,

225/50/16 is the correct size for that wheel, going from 225/50 to 205/55/16 is raising the wall height and having thinner tyres on the wheel, Not Good unless you went down to 205/40or 45

Have a look on My Tyres for prise comparison and may be look at another make of tyre like Nankang NS-2
as that is a very good mid range tyre or even Kumho Ecsta SPT KU31 another good tyre, I run Nankang Ultra Sport tyres on my e60 530d and love them in all weathers....

http://ssl.delti.com/cgi-bin/rshop.pl
they'll be very little difference in tyre wall size due to the smaller width of the tyre, 55% of 205 isn't much different from 50% of 225

doh - beaten to it

DJC

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

239 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Gents,

Thanks.

Next question:

Knowing the rolling radius is the same for 225/50 or 205/55 and assuming I can happily fit 205 on a 7J wheel (as per the BMW handbook), would I need to change all four tyres at the same time, or could I do it one axle at a time?

I'm aware some of the meatier BMWs have staggered sizes.

I have two tyres that will need replacing within 12 months. Rather than replace these with 225/50, could I change them to 205/55 but keep the 225/50 on the other axle until they need changing?

Second question:

If this is possible, unlikely to cause any ill effects with the handling and not dangerous, is there any preference to which axle to put the narrower width tyres on?




E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
205's on a 7" rim will be fine, changing them in pairs shouldn't cause any ill effects, I would put the 205's on the front and the 225 on the rears.