E91 325i - does this sound like a faulty thermostat?
E91 325i - does this sound like a faulty thermostat?
Author
Discussion

stevesuk

Original Poster:

1,377 posts

213 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Hi all,

Been trying to diagnose a dive in fuel economy on our 2005 E91 325i (N52 petrol engine, manual gearbox).

When we first got the car, it managed high 30s MPG on a long motorway run, and high 20s MPG on shorter journeys. However, now we struggle to get 30 MPG on a run (even if trying to drive with economy in mind), and its more like 20 MPG round town. Getting to the point where we're struggling to get 300 miles out of a tank of fuel. By comparison, my E46 330 Ci can manage 38 MPG on a motorway run - so its not driving style.

Since its running fine and we have no warning lights, I am wondering if the thermostat isn't letting the car get up to the correct running temperature. So today I used the diagnostics mode on the OBC to display the water temperature on a 15 minute drive. The water temperature quickly gets up to say 95C, but then it drops off to more like 75C, before settling at between 80C and 82C.

I'm assuming the quick rise to 95C is correct (car warming up from cold), but should it then dive back down to the 70s/80C? Especially considering its about 25C outside today.

We have a warranty (BMW extended warranty) on the car, but I'd like to go to the dealer with some level of confidence that the thermostat may be faulty - otherwise I guess if I just book it in and say "the MPG has been rubbish lately" they'll probably just tell me no fault was found and charge me for diagnostics.

Anyone know what the correct running water temperature should be for the N52 engine? And could the engine running too cold account for poor fuel economy?

Cheers,

Steve.

the_kato

411 posts

218 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
It shouldn't drop. Sounds like a thermostat to me

My e46 320D had rubbish fuel economy and the temp gauge would sit to the left of upright. OBC indicated a 60c temp when the normal operating temp of an M47 motor is 90c. Had the main stat and the EGR stat changed and it cured the problem

Saw an increase of 5mpg according to the OBC

Obviously it's a different car to yours, but the principle will be the same

stevesuk

Original Poster:

1,377 posts

213 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks. Another thing I noticed is that I can't recall the last time I heard the cooling fan kick-in when sat in traffic. Another reason to suspect its not running at the right temperature?

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
if it's anything like my E38 it should sit at approx 93 degrees.

you'll hate me for asking this but what happens when you turn the heaters on? does the temperature drop further still?

i had a thermostat fail on my E38 about 6 months ago. baring in mind this was in winter the coolant temp wouldn't get to 75 degrees if i had the heaters on, if i turned them off it would JUST about hit 85, 90 at the most, as soon as i turned the heaters up it would drop to below 70. changed the thermostat and since then it rises to about 95-96 or so then drops to 93 and stays there without fail (give or take 1 or 2 degrees).

if it drops with using the heaters it sounds like thermostat. odd that it gets up to temp in the first place though (suggesting it is initially closed but then perhaps just stays open until the car is turned off???

stevesuk

Original Poster:

1,377 posts

213 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
Hmmm, have done some more research and found this...

another forum said:
The E90 is kind of special in that the magnesium engine with the new thermal management (heated thermostat and electric waterpump - electronically controlled) has a far wider range of operating temperature. To increase fuel efficiency and power output, the operating water temperature is intentionally regulated by the ECU to temperatures between 75deg C and 125 deg C depending on driving conditions. Slow driving in traffic with little demand for power will make the ECU run the water hot to improve fuel efficiency, high power demand will have the ECU regulate the water temp to low values to improve power output
So the ECU purposefully regulates the temperatures of the cooling system depending on driving conditions! I'll do some more testing and see if I get anywhere near the 125 C it mentions. I guess that if you're bimbling along the motorway at say 65mph, the engine should be running for efficiency rather than performance, so if the above info is correct, should be running hot, not cold.

Sounds far too complicated, I'll stick with the M54 engine in my 330 Ci I think... the cooling system maybe made of chocolate, but at least its fairly simple smile

Edited to add: apparently this is why the E90 doesn't have a temperature gauge, because it should apparently be jumping all over the place due to the ECU warming and cooling

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Saturday 26th May 2012
quotequote all
i highly doubt that's why it doesn't have a temp gauge. the gauges are very simple anyway, slap bang on middle is at 75 degrees, mine has reached over 100 degrees before and it was still slap bang in the middle of the gauge....it's there to tell you when it's cold, and when it's hot....anything in between is middle.

yours certainly doesn't sound right though. it is silly they don't have a temp gauge. i'd just run it on the display most of the time to be honest. the M3 has no coolant gauge but it does have an oil temp gauge.

stevesuk

Original Poster:

1,377 posts

213 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
yours certainly doesn't sound right though. it is silly they don't have a temp gauge. i'd just run it on the display most of the time to be honest. the M3 has no coolant gauge but it does have an oil temp gauge.
Went for another drive yesterday. After 15 miles of driving mainly on fast A roads/dual carriageway, the diagnostics was reading between 75 and 80C coolant temperature, and still poor MPG (23 MPG on a journey like that with fairly light traffic... I'd be expecting from something like a 540i smile ).

So booked it in to the dealer, who are looking at it on Friday - was cheerfully informed that if no fault was found, there'd be a £111 diagnostics fee to pay. But, if they do find a fault covered by the BMW warranty (and we have the comprehensive warranty with no excess, so I'd hope so), it won't cost us a penny. So I'm kind of hoping they find a fault now... Its definitely way down on fuel economy, so even if there's nothing wrong with the thermostat, something is borked.

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
75-80 degrees isn't too bad, but it's colder than it should be.

FWIW i went for a drive today and after just shy of 3 miles the coolant was at 93 degrees.

when my thermostat failed it was a bit worse than yours, it would sit at around 65-70 and take ages to get there. fuel economy was certainly down and after about 400 miles i changed it. it might have been running colder than yours because i was running it through winter in sub 0 temps.

best of luck! you should see what happens to the temp when you try turning the heaters on to see if it drops.

stevesuk

Original Poster:

1,377 posts

213 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
best of luck! you should see what happens to the temp when you try turning the heaters on to see if it drops.
Yeah, even before starting the engine, the coolant temperature was already at more than 20C, which I guess it wouldn't be in the middle of winter. I wasn't too popular when I suggested that we should switch the heater on when it was 25C outside, so haven't tried that yet smile

Just hoping it does turn out to be a fault, rather the weight of my wife's right foot (she's the main driver of the car ... although I've also driven it and got similar MPG). When we first got it, we once did an A-Road/motorway journey of some 50-60 miles, and the trip computer was reading 40 MPG as we pulled in to the car park at the other end. These days, you struggle to hit 31 MPG on a similar type of journey - so something must be wrong.

Thermostats in general seem to be a common failure on all BMWs. The previous owner of my E46 stuck a new one in 2 or 3 years ago.

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
stevesuk said:
Sounds far too complicated, I'll stick with the M54 engine in my 330 Ci I think... the cooling system maybe made of chocolate, but at least its fairly simple smile
The M54 has the same type of thermostat, and so does the M62 V8 (although not the 8 series)

The middle of the temp needle on cars with them is a large dead spot for somewhere between 80-115'C, so it isn't analogue temperature, but more operating temperature.

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
It will be the stat or stats.
I had low running at 78 ish on mine.
Fuel economy was crap too.
I changed the egr stat myself as it's a piece of pish to do and takes 10 mins and I could blow through it so it was duff.
Still didn't solve my low running but the temp did go up a little.
Had the main stat changed and this solved my crap running,went from 80 ish to 90-94 when upto temp.

One of the hurdles mind is the bloody garages not listening.I had an indy tell me nothing was wrong with my stat because they had it running at 90,parked in a garage at idle.FFS.
I told them to take it out and watch the temp plummet.I could get it upto 90 sat on my drive at idle.
It needs to stay at around and above 88.(or whatever your main stats are rated for on the 325i)

Not everyone is aware the stats are a bit crap so you might have that problem ^^^

stevesuk

Original Poster:

1,377 posts

213 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks, you also have the problem that the service reception play Chinese whispers with the description of the fault to give them, and what they actually write on the job card for the technician. Tempted to leave a note in the car with my mobile number!

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
It was more a case of the technicians/mechanic type people wondering why I wanted my main stat changed when they could get the car upto 90 odd degrees sat in the garage at idle. rolleyes

I had to tell them to take the car out and watch the temps plummet way under 88 so therefore the car is not maintaining it's optimum running temps as it should.I.e the thermostat is kaput so replace it.


TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
There's been a few cases like that as not reaching full operating temperature isn't modelled or recorded in the ECU as a fault, despite the fact it will stop DPF regens and cause problems.

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
There's been a few cases like that as not reaching full operating temperature isn't modelled or recorded in the ECU as a fault, despite the fact it will stop DPF regens and cause problems.
this is why they should all be fitted with a temp gauge, i suspect most people wouldn't notice accept for poorer economy. it's bad really as it accelerates engine wear too, one of the reasons i got mine sorted as soon as i realised it wasn't the cold weather causing it.

stevesuk

Original Poster:

1,377 posts

213 months

Friday 1st June 2012
quotequote all
Update: well its been in to the dealer today and apparently there's nothing wrong with it. When I mentioned the diagnostics screen reporting coolant temperature of 75C-80C, I was asked how I knew that when there was no temperature gauge, and wasn't I looking at the outside temperature reading (I suspect the human race would be extinct if it was 75C outside, but hey!).

So no nearer resolving the problem. They claim they took it out for a road test and managed 37 MPG which is some 6 or 7 MPG more than we've managed for a long time.

Anyway, nothing to pay and they valeted the car inside and out - so it wasn't a completely negative experience smile

All I can do is to keep watching those temps and monitoring MPG I guess...

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Friday 1st June 2012
quotequote all
Get the coolant temp on the obc hidden menu (test 7) and take it for a drive with all the heaters and air con completely off. See what it gets up to after a good 15-20mins on the motorway. Then turn air con or heaters on full and see what happens and report back. Also note how long it takes to get to its max temp.

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
75-80 is bobbins,especially in this warmer weather. Trying to explain the problem to these people is like banging your head against a wall.Bmw garages should be aware of the stats,my local one has plenty in stock.Reason being they replace a lot of them.

I would do what E38 ross has said.Access the hidden menus and pull up the coolant temp screen.I havent got a link to hand,just google E90 hidden menu and you should find instructions.Its how I keep an eye on my temps.

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
I've just gone into the hidden menu on the M3 and something is annoying. On my E38 once you unlock it, it stays unlocked once you lock the car and leave it for when you come back. The e92 m3 seems different, I can get in easy enough but once you turn the car off, lock it etc then come back its locked again so you keep having to unlock it. Any ideas if you can keep it unlocked, or am I missing something?

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Sunday 3rd June 2012
quotequote all
You have to unlock the menus on the Exx each time the ignition is turned off.