To buy or not to buy, DPF issue on test drive
To buy or not to buy, DPF issue on test drive
Author
Discussion

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
Today I test drove a 2006 330d m sport, car was great on the test drive til a message flashed up on the sat nav screen saying "DPF, ok to carry on driving" listed below was "reduced power" and "take to BMW service centre", the salesman said that the car needed a dpf clear out, and this would happen when at a higher speed,(we were doing around 40mph is flowing traffic), we managed to get a clear bit of road and got up to a good speed for a while and after a 10 mins or so, the DPF message left the screen and never reappeared during the rest of the test drive.

The DPF issue is my only concern about buying the car, it's fantastic otherwise. It's being sold at a main vw dealer, they say they are going to look into it tomorrow and get back to me. Should I walk away and leave the car or is it just a case of it needing a good drive to clear the DPF??

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
The DPF is reaching the end of its life. Factor in £1600 for a new one or get them to replace it, but make sure they have replaced it.

Terminator X

20,995 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
As above, walk away unless they stump up for a new one.

TX.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
The vw dealer have taken the car in as a part ex, so they won't do nothing with it, they said they are going to look into it and if the dpf needs replacing, they will move the car on via an auction. the only warranty I would get is a standard 3 month warranty.

So that message really meant the DPF is on its way out?? Gutted, car was decently priced and was a great spec as well. I've been looking for ages and thought I'd found the right car.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
Now you know why it was decently priced. Bit off of the dealer really, they must know of the issue.

bennyboydurham

1,617 posts

205 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
The dpf does regenerate itself and given a decent run it will do so but eventually it will need replacing and its an expensive job. If the car stacks up in all other ways then see if you can come to agreement for getting it replaced, or get them to come down on price and factor it into your car finances for the future. I'm surprised that they won't give you a proper warranty. My wife's E92 came from a Land Rover dealer as a part ex and they gave us the full 1 year LR approved warranty. The only downside is that LR have to send an engineer over to the BMW dealer to sign off any warranty work. I'm surprised VW don't have a similar arrangement.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
bennyboydurham said:
The dpf does regenerate itself and given a decent run it will do so but eventually it will need replacing and its an expensive job. If the car stacks up in all other ways then see if you can come to agreement for getting it replaced, or get them to come down on price and factor it into your car finances for the future. I'm surprised that they won't give you a proper warranty. My wife's E92 came from a Land Rover dealer as a part ex and they gave us the full 1 year LR approved warranty. The only downside is that LR have to send an engineer over to the BMW dealer to sign off any warranty work. I'm surprised VW don't have a similar arrangement.
The car does stack up in other ways, it has a full BMW s/h, 83000 miles, m sport, sat nav, Bluetooth, leather, 4 decent Bridgestone tyres, sun protective glass, it's a 2006 and is up for £9990.

I suppose there is no telling how long it will last, could be a week or it could be a year, who knows. I did ask for them to guarantee they will cover it under warranty, but was told that when they look at it, if it needed replacing, then it would be removed from sale and sent to auction.

Is it possible to tell visually that it needs replacing??

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
You can't tell by visual inspection. If the car has spent its life in town, the DPF will fail sooner, as it doesn't regen as much. My 330d is on 119k at the minute and spends its life on the motorway, as did my previous 335d, and that DPF lasted until 130k.


At the end of the day, its a filter, it can only absorb so much. It can also fekk the turbo if unattended. A regen through the diagnosic is a very short term fix.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
roofer said:
You can't tell by visual inspection. If the car has spent its life in town, the DPF will fail sooner, as it doesn't regen as much. My 330d is on 119k at the minute and spends its life on the motorway, as did my previous 335d, and that DPF lasted until 130k.


At the end of the day, its a filter, it can only absorb so much. It can also fekk the turbo if unattended. A regen through the diagnosic is a very short term fix.
Thankyou very much for that info, if it can wreck the turbo, I'm going to push for it to be replaced, if they refuse, it's a case of back to the drawing board.

Do they really cost around £1600??

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
You can get them cheaper (About £700 for the part) but dealers usually charge about that to fit.

If its a main VW dealer, sale and supply of goods act covers any faults anyway, so they would have to correct it if it or the turbo failed in a given timeframe.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
roofer said:
You can get them cheaper (About £700 for the part) but dealers usually charge about that to fit.

If its a main VW dealer, sale and supply of goods act covers any faults anyway, so they would have to correct it if it or the turbo failed in a given timeframe.
£700 seems reasonable, if they were prepared to go 60/40 on £700 I would be prepared to pay a bit extra for the car, the fitting wouldn't cost them anything, I presume a VW fitter would be able to fit the part easily enough?? I would just want proof it had been replaced.

Would my offer be something they might be interested in??

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
If you don't ask, you don't get....

Neil.D

2,878 posts

237 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
The 3 reasons DPF's fail is heavy town use, short journeys and failed thermostats.
If the engine doesn't get hot enough then the regen won't start and it will clog with soot and be unable to burn it off.

The fact that u have an I drive message tells me that the thing is nearing the end of its life. The next stage will be the car in limp mode to protect itself from the increased back pressure.


E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
If the car is what you want other than the DPF issue , then you could buy the car, have the DPF removed, ECU 'patched' to prevent it going in to limphome mode, and enjoy the car with no future concern about DPF issues.

Just an option.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
E30M3SE said:
If the car is what you want other than the DPF issue , then you could buy the car, have the DPF removed, ECU 'patched' to prevent it going in to limphome mode, and enjoy the car with no future concern about DPF issues.

Just an option.
Yep, the car is what I want and what you suggest does sound interesting, what cost is involved in removing the DPF and "patching" the ECU??

Sounds an ideal option

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
Cheapest way to do it, £100 for the exhaust to be cut open DPF remove and welded back up.

Circa £300 for the ECU work.

ETA;

This crew sell a complete stainless replacement pipe and software map for £600 all in.

(No personal experience of them)

Edited by E30M3SE on Sunday 27th May 17:14

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
E30M3SE said:
Cheapest way to do it, £100 for the exhaust to be cut open DPF remove and welded back up.

Circa £300 for the ECU work.
Could be interested in that. Would the work have to be done by the same place?? As I imagine the car would go into limp mode until the ECU was "patched".

What companies would be able to do this work? I wouldn't know where to ask

Is it a common thing for people to do?? And would it cause a passing mot issue??

Sorry for all the questions

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
The way a friend of mine did this, not on a BMW but the principal is the same, wa shave an indi garage do the DPF removal and get a mobile chap to come out to the garage and sort ht ECU.

The link I've added in my previous post appear to do the whole job.

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
a4cabrio said:
Could be interested in that. Would the work have to be done by the same place?? As I imagine the car would go into limp mode until the ECU was "patched".

What companies would be able to do this work? I wouldn't know where to ask

Is it a common thing for people to do?? And would it cause a passing mot issue??

Sorry for all the questions
At present it is not a requirement of the MOT for diesels to have a DPF fitted (even if the vehicle originally had one fitted when it was originally manufactured).
So long as the vehicle passes the emissions and smoke test then it will pass (See here: http://www.bmwland.co.uk/forums/viewtopic.php?t=13... )

Be aware though that this may change in the future.

a4cabrio

Original Poster:

933 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
E30M3SE said:
The way a friend of mine did this, not on a BMW but the principal is the same, wa shave an indi garage do the DPF removal and get a mobile chap to come out to the garage and sort ht ECU.

The link I've added in my previous post appear to do the whole job.
Thanks, I'm going to go and try and get the DPF sorted with the vw dealer, hopefully we can resolve it but if not, the link you suggest will come into consideration.