Battle:Los Angeles
Author
Discussion

DJRC

Original Poster:

23,563 posts

267 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Didnt this get panned when it came out?

Am watching it Sky Movies now and its not that bad. Quite watchable in fact.

Brigand

2,547 posts

200 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
OOOOOHHHH YEAAAHHHH, AMERRRRIIICAAAA!

GO MARIEEENS!

Utter dross in my opinion, just an advert for the US Marines really.

Having said that, it was one of those films that was fairly enjoyable to watch once, but I'll not be going out of my way to see it again.

Still, could be worse; it could be Skyline.

clonmult

10,529 posts

240 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Brigand said:
Still, could be worse; it could be Skyline.
Or even even worse, it could be the SyFy channel original "Battle of Los Angeles". Which is arguably even worse than Skyline.

nando

48 posts

174 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
aaaabsolute and utter cack

VEA

4,792 posts

232 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
I thought it was ok for what it is, a fairly simple, mind out, explosion ridden, america is all conquering, scifi movie...

Arun_D

2,340 posts

226 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
clonmult said:
Brigand said:
Still, could be worse; it could be Skyline.
Or even even worse, it could be the SyFy channel original "Battle of Los Angeles". Which is arguably even worse than Skyline.
This.

I thought 'Battle: Los Angeles' was quite alright.

'Battle of Los Angeles'....Not so much (from the 5mins viewing I managed)

Mr E

23,105 posts

290 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
I watched it on an aircraft. I don't recall any redeeming features?

America, fk yeah.

Allaloneatron

3,123 posts

271 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
It was so good, you were posting on PH at the same time.

Is PH becoming like twitter these days?

DJRC

Original Poster:

23,563 posts

267 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Allaloneatron said:
It was so good, you were posting on PH at the same time.

Is PH becoming like twitter these days?
Wouldnt know, never looked at the twitter site.

thebluebus

3,558 posts

248 months

Friday 1st June 2012
quotequote all
I liked Skyline much more than B:LA.

Skyline was barmy and fun and the ending is off-the-charts hilarious/awesome.

Whereas B:LA is dreary sub-Private Ryan glooming around.


I have watched Skyline more than once. I struggled to watch B:LA even once.

NismoGT

1,634 posts

221 months

Friday 1st June 2012
quotequote all
Skyline has the worst acting ever. Utterly st film.

steviegunn

1,425 posts

215 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
thebluebus said:
I liked Skyline much more than B:LA.

Skyline was barmy and fun and the ending is off-the-charts hilarious/awesome.

Whereas B:LA is dreary sub-Private Ryan glooming around.


I have watched Skyline more than once. I struggled to watch B:LA even once.
^^ My view entirely, Skyline had better effects too, I actually preferred Monsters to either of them, District 9 was on a whole different level, though at least all 4 of them avoided the utterly annoying characters of Spielberg's WotW.

Allaloneatron

3,123 posts

271 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
DJRC said:
Allaloneatron said:
It was so good, you were posting on PH at the same time.

Is PH becoming like twitter these days?
Wouldnt know, never looked at the twitter site.
Hmm Its basically as site dedicated to what you did here.


Edited by Allaloneatron on Saturday 2nd June 22:24

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
steviegunn said:
thebluebus said:
I liked Skyline much more than B:LA.

Skyline was barmy and fun and the ending is off-the-charts hilarious/awesome.

Whereas B:LA is dreary sub-Private Ryan glooming around.


I have watched Skyline more than once. I struggled to watch B:LA even once.
^^ My view entirely, Skyline had better effects too, I actually preferred Monsters to either of them, District 9 was on a whole different level, though at least all 4 of them avoided the utterly annoying characters of Spielberg's WotW.
No no no no. My view is the opposite. Skyline was shockingly bad. Battle LA was a perfectly decent war movie with aliens.

I would watch Battle LA again but never Skyline.

Negative Creep

26,144 posts

258 months

Sunday 3rd June 2012
quotequote all
Battle LA has every cliche you can imagine and is hurt by being a 12a/pg-13 film. It is however very enjoyable, and looks great on Blu Ray. Skyline on the other hand was just dreadful. Even the special fx weren't that great

thebluebus

3,558 posts

248 months

Sunday 3rd June 2012
quotequote all
Well, I'm not trying to convince you of anything - but B:LA was so joyless and straihgtfaced and serious and just dull.

Skyline was daft, yes of course - but it was excitingly silly and threw all its effects at you in bright daylight. Some of it felt somehow like they'd made a live action film version of Halo cutscenes.

Actually, in a way it felt like the whole thing was a massive prologue to a video game, where the final scene of Skyline is the moment when the gameplay starts for your character.

Anyway: w'ev. I liked it although/because it was blatantly daft. I didn't like B:LA because it was the opposite, and because Michelle Rodriguez was criminally underused.

rich85uk

4,390 posts

210 months

Sunday 3rd June 2012
quotequote all
Is it as bad as 2012?

Daniel1

2,931 posts

229 months

Monday 4th June 2012
quotequote all
I really like battle: Los Angeles. Totally acceptable war film with a serious to semi serious undertones. It didn't mind killing characters at random, which although people say you don't know the characters so you don't feel the emotion, I think is important in a war film as characters do die randomly with no warning.

I though it demonstrated the problems with dealing with death in combat situation. You can't mourn properly you just have to get on with it.

It showed how hard it must be to lead a team and how you need the right stuff, knowing your decisions have serious consequences. How training only takes you part way (the new new lieutenant) and experience makes the rest (the staff sergeant).

Lastly, even though the ending seemed a bit "oorah" you only have to read the medal of honor or Victoria cross award list to see people do some bizarre, brave and downright crazy unbelievable stuff.

I also thought skyline was ok. I thought it captured the sense of panic and futility well, the same feeling as war of the worlds was trying to convey. I dont think LA was the place to set it though, what with the bright sunshine compared to wet and dreary east coast of wotw. The slight hedonistic lifestyle of the lead characters friends as opposed to the working man of Tom Cruises character didn't help. The lack of "polish" made It seem to me to more a short story as opposed to a book although totally ruined by the ending. But you just ignore that bit and it's not that awful.

Edited by Daniel1 on Monday 4th June 08:25

Happy82

15,078 posts

200 months

Monday 4th June 2012
quotequote all
rich85uk said:
Is it as bad as 2012?
I think only Angels & Demons comes close to that badness