Afghanistan - The Great Game
Author
Discussion

Eric Mc

Original Poster:

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Anyone watch these two programmes?

They were shown on BBC 2 on Monday and Wednesday night and are on the iPlayer. Well worth a look to get some historic background on the country and its effect on the great world powwers.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
I managed to catch most of them.
Absolutely love Rory's style.
I have studied a little bit of UK Imperial history and love documentaries on them (Schama's sticks out).
The arrogance of the Imperial mindset still manages to baffle and amaze.
Quite funny/sad/wretched how the same mistakes are constantly made, and people still believe now in that Imperial (we'll give them democracy and they'll bloody well like it and love us!) mindset.

Eric Mc

Original Poster:

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Ihink there were only two episodes anyway.

I thought they were excellent.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Ahh, what I meant was that I managed to catch most of the two episodes.
Yes it was most excellent, the absolute failure and moronic behaviour of the British. And then the modernising came from within, if only he had been supported instead if ignored!biggrin

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
I saw them and thought they were great. Flashman and the great game is good too if you want to read something a bit more lighthearted during this era.

ChasMill

270 posts

247 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Great TV, well worth a look if you have any interest in the history of Afghan and how it is repeating itself.

Simpo Two

93,078 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Halb said:
I have studied a little bit of UK Imperial history and love documentaries on them (Schama's sticks out). The arrogance of the Imperial mindset still manages to baffle and amaze.
Arrogance or confidence? It got us the biggest Empire the world has ever seen, starting with Elizabeth I and ending with WW1.


I find 'imperial' sadly used as a negative now.

Shay HTFC

3,588 posts

220 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Halb said:
I have studied a little bit of UK Imperial history and love documentaries on them (Schama's sticks out). The arrogance of the Imperial mindset still manages to baffle and amaze.
Arrogance or confidence? It got us the biggest Empire the world has ever seen, starting with Elizabeth I and ending with WW1.


I find 'imperial' sadly used as a negative now.
Whats sad about using imperial as a negative now? The attitudes that were commonplace then just don't exist in any positive light today. Attitudes towards using direct power to control others have changed.

Marching around the world and forcing whole nations of people under British rule... hardly positive once you look at it from any viewpoint other than a historic British one.

And I would agree that thinking we have the right to just go around the world doing as we please, could be classed as arrogant (as well as confident)

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Arrogance. biggrin

Eric Mc

Original Poster:

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
Arrogance

Confidence

Paranoia

All of the above apply to imperial powers. It was certainly paranoia about Russia's intentions that got Britain involved in Afghanistan in the 1800s.

It was paranoia by the Soviets that got them involved in the late 1970s.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Thursday 31st May 2012
quotequote all
It was sherbet ab-dabs that got the Americans involved.

The reflection of the Russian soldiers on the current antics was interesting.

What I thought was telling (and typical) was the second fella from the Brits, after Secunder, I forget his name thought he was more culturally adept and military sound than Secunder, but still didn't have a real clue.biggrin