What's better, S1 Elise or VX220?
What's better, S1 Elise or VX220?
Author
Discussion

Megaflow

Original Poster:

10,801 posts

246 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
Just some idle musing's at the minute, but I am considering a toy car change next year, and I have noticed that the S2 Elise based VX220 is similar money to an S1 Elise.

Sadly the budget won't stretch to an S2 Elise. So, what's the better car an S1 Elise or a VX220?

TIA

Jasandjules

71,700 posts

250 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
Well I bought an S1....

mike9009

9,301 posts

264 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
If its a toy probably the S1 Elise. If you are planning any daily drive the vx220 would be better.

Can of worms TBH.

Wait for the HGF, badge snobbery, uncomfortable, leaking roofs, purity of drive debate to commence... Best place to ask is on SELOC!

In reality YOU need to make the decision by driving and maybe speaking face to face with some owners to make your mind up.

Mike wink

oj121

1,548 posts

193 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
IMO the S2 is a better car than the S1. Natural progress etc. The VX is based on the S2. Should be an easy one if chosen without a badge in mind.

Megaflow

Original Poster:

10,801 posts

246 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
Purely a toy, current toy is a carpet less, screen less, Westfield. The VXlise will obviously be slightly slower than it, but the Westfield is getting to the point where you can't really use it on the road, certainly not to it's full potential. Plus I have had it for something 15 years, and had previously thought I'd never sell it, but then I realised that it will have to go one day (I won't be able to drive it when I'm 80) so when does that point come and is the time right to try something different?

Like I said idle musing's at the minute, but if I do change it will be to an S1 Elise or a VX220, purely because I just want one, the question is, which is best.

Stuff like head gaskets does not bother me, as the Westfield started with a x/flow on carbs, and now has a Zetec on TB's, if an Elise pops a gasket it just end up with a Scholar 1.9 conversion, which I believe eliminates the liner movements which leads to gasket failure.

Edited by Megaflow on Saturday 2nd June 15:59

p4cks

7,258 posts

220 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
The VX220 is the thinking man's Elise.

CraigyMc

18,042 posts

257 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
The VX is a lot heavier than an S1. By default it's less tail happy than an elise too.

Other things can be fixed (suspension geometry etc) but you won't get away from the weight.

C

jl34

551 posts

258 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
If you want a car as quick as your westfield , go for a Vx220 Turbo. it's a rocket ship; with a simple remap it has double the torque of an S1 or s2 elise in Stage 2 tune.

also benefits from the upgrades to the s2 elise so the roof is much better and actually seals


Zoobeef

6,004 posts

179 months

Saturday 2nd June 2012
quotequote all
Get a vx then put it on a diet or SC the NA or get the turbo and tune. Pretty much everything has been done to these cars.

People that dont know about cars love the VX. People who do but havnt owned either say 'id rather have the elise' badge snobs!

People who have tracked their elises with VX's at the same circuit know that the vx is a good weapon when set up right.

If you ask on SELOC though your going to get the 'buy an Elise because vx220's are crap' response. Ask on vx220.org.uk and you'll get a list of pros and cons wink

Megaflow

Original Poster:

10,801 posts

246 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Apologies for the delay, been on holiday.

Interesting stuff, thanks chaps. A conversation with Mrs Megaflow on holiday revealed she thinks the VX is better looking.

Token Jock

867 posts

260 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
I had a VX after a 911 and it was brilliant. Fabulous car to drive and awesome across country.

I felt it represented fantastic value for money.

Kept it for 2.5 years and never felt I wish I'd bought an Elise, which are also great.

Got a Caterham now amongst other things but I doubt you'd be unhappy in a VX unless a badge is important to you.

Megaflow

Original Poster:

10,801 posts

246 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
Badge important? Not likely, I had a Rover when I was 21...

hehe