Musings - looking for input?
Musings - looking for input?
Author
Discussion

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
I've just got back from test driving a 458 and this has left me thinking. I've presently got a 911 as day to day transport and manual LP550 for weekends....however to be honest, I love the experience of the LP so tend to commute in that a fair bit too now. I like the sound, attention, just it being a bit of a wild car.

The 458 left me thinking about 3 potential options, each with pro's and con's:

1) Keep the LP550, keep the 911, don't get the 458 - cheapest option
2) Keep the LP550, get the 458 - drive round in 2 supercars, massive waste of money, most fun option, but I'd feel guilty tbh as it's a bit excessive.
3) Get the 458, swap in the LP and the 911, use the 458 as your only car (as it was honestly this practical I felt) - reasonably sensible option....best of both worlds with the DSG box.

The LP is awesome but a manual in traffic is a bit of a ballache. The Porsche is awesome but not as much of an experience as the Lambo. The 458 is in between - I think the LP is a prettier, better looking car, but the 458....you can just drive it like an auto if you're tootling around in traffic, or if you really want to go for it, you can put your foot down and it flies.

What would everyone else do? I have no wife / kids, young bloke so no need for back seats etc...

andrew

10,367 posts

223 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
lambo and 911 works for me

911 costs less than half as much to run, and so it makes economic sense to keep it and use it whenever possible

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
Be economical later in life, once you've died. If you can handle the cost, LP and 458 without thinking twice.

Enricogto

646 posts

176 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
redcard

We are on PH!
The answer is obvious!
Nice coupling, one is RWD for fun, the other 4WD for when it snows!

458 + 550 = bounce

AndyBrew

2,774 posts

250 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
Justices said:
Be economical later in life, once you've died. If you can handle the cost, LP and 458 without thinking twice.
This!

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
The main downsides I can think of, of going 458 + 550 are:

1) Silly amount to be spending on cars when you could buy another house etc. rent them out etc...
2) You'd always be going to the supermarket / everywhere in a supercar, so every parking dent and ding would be very annoying, and the chances of the car getting damaged are pretty high (e.g. imagine leaving it in a typical multi-story)

The plus points:

1) You would feel like a legend every day, and be very happy
2) You'd always be in a cool car
3) You'd only be doing 6k miles in each of them (pretty normal milage for the brands)

The 458 makes a lot of sense as an everyday supercar due to the gearbox, warranty and free servicing...on the other hand all those pale in comparison to the depreciation which would probably be £30k first year I'd guess. Far better value to run around in a 911.

munch997

2,325 posts

218 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
Enricogto said:
redcard

We are on PH!
The answer is obvious!
Nice coupling, one is RWD for fun, the other 4WD for when it snows!

458 + 550 = bounce
This would mean keeping the turbo surely as the LP550 is RWD.... biggrin

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
kbf1981 said:
The only points:

1) You would feel like a legend every day, and be very happy
2) You'd always be in a cool car
3) You'd only be doing a minimum of 6k miles in each of them (pretty normal milage for the brands)
You could take a bicycle to work and use the money saved to buy more property, start another business, invest money elsewhere too.

The only thing you need in this world is your health and your supercar/s. Legendary status awaits thee..

AyBee

11,363 posts

233 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
[Sensible hat]I think I'd have to keep the LP frown You seem slightly worried about the depreciation on the 458 (true?) and so keeping the LP would suit best. Think you need to look at replacing the 911 with something that will enable you to keep the LP as a fun car though [/Sensible hat]

Extremely envious that you are looking at 458s and LPs at only 6 years older than me frownhehe

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
ditch the porsche for a gtr and keep the lp550....

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
In that company the Porsche has to go.

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
70proof said:
ditch the porsche for a gtr and keep the lp550....
Have you tried a GTR? What'd you think?

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Tuesday 5th June 2012
quotequote all
sone said:
In that company the Porsche has to go.
It's such a good car, I do really like it, I think I've just had too many in a row now and am looking for a bit of a change!

Over the past couple days I've been thinking (in no particular order):
- 458
- GT3 (looks too dull without the stripes to me)
- GT3 RS
- Turbo S
- V12V
- Cayman R

.....think I just want a change. Not entirely sure what suits. 458 fits all the boxes but is also a crazy money to be spending on a car as a daily driver (imo). The Porsches....I quite fancy a Turbo S...but then once the buzz of that speed has worn off, will I be bored again? Cayman R was on the list as I loved my first Cayman, that was a laugh. V12V I quite fancy and is near on £100k cheaper than the 458.

Not really into the Maserati's......I like smaller, chuckable cars. Anything else I should be thinking about?

Edited by kbf1981 on Tuesday 5th June 23:22

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
kbf1981 said:
Have you tried a GTR? What'd you think?
not yet, but i aim to, drive one and buy the t-shirt.... this is an interesting read...
http://www.stuttgart9.co.uk/forum/japanese-rice/57...

<3s to 60, 7s to 100mph!!!... might lose out to other cars above 100mph, but below 100 you will need a hypercar to have as much low down grunt....
http://www.germancarforum.com/community/threads/fi...

Edited by 70proof on Wednesday 6th June 08:35

Schnellmann

1,893 posts

235 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
Justices said:
Be economical later in life, once you've died. If you can handle the cost, LP and 458 without thinking twice.
Don't understand this approach. Unless you have unlimited resources then losing money on depreciation is just limiting your future options. Personally I'd much rather buy something that is going to hold its value and put the money saved towards the next purchase. Having a 458 would be great....but having something like (just as an example) a Scud now and an F40 in two years, would be much better.

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
I don't think given this dilemma I'd have just two cars. I love super cars but they're a pita when it comes to parking unwanted attention etc.
I'd probably still forget the Porsche but have a smoking Audi, rs6 etc and from the money I'd saved by not putting miles on the other two the Audi would pay for itself.
Besides driving a supercar for me anyway would take that special feel away.

Just my humble.

AndrewD

7,659 posts

315 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
Schnellmann said:
Don't understand this approach. Unless you have unlimited resources then losing money on depreciation is just limiting your future options. Personally I'd much rather buy something that is going to hold its value and put the money saved towards the next purchase. Having a 458 would be great....but having something like (just as an example) a Scud now and an F40 in two years, would be much better.
Who says either a Scud or an F40 will hold their value?

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
Schnellmann said:
Justices said:
Be economical later in life, once you've died. If you can handle the cost, LP and 458 without thinking twice.
Don't understand this approach. Unless you have unlimited resources then losing money on depreciation is just limiting your future options. Personally I'd much rather buy something that is going to hold its value and put the money saved towards the next purchase. Having a 458 would be great....but having something like (just as an example) a Scud now and an F40 in two years, would be much better.
I have thought about the Scud....bound to lose less money than a 458 but then not as practical for day to day. It does sound amazing though. What do you think will happen with values on those? £125k get's a good one in the UK but I heard they were down at £100k in EU now.

Not really into the idea of driving a more normal car day to day - I'd never drive it. I only really park in 3-4 places....home, work, gym...shopping somewhere / super market. 90% of my time is spent at work ha!

kryten22uk

2,350 posts

262 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
kbf1981 said:
The Porsches....I quite fancy a Turbo S...but then once the buzz of that speed has worn off, will I be bored again?
Definitely. I got bored with my 997TT after 6months.

kbf1981

Original Poster:

2,351 posts

231 months

Wednesday 6th June 2012
quotequote all
sone said:
I don't think given this dilemma I'd have just two cars. I love super cars but they're a pita when it comes to parking unwanted attention etc.
I'd probably still forget the Porsche but have a smoking Audi, rs6 etc and from the money I'd saved by not putting miles on the other two the Audi would pay for itself.
Besides driving a supercar for me anyway would take that special feel away.

Just my humble.
To be honest I really like driving the LP day to day....it just feels more exciting, and I like the attention. Sounds bad but, you like the sound, the experience, the silly speed, people taking pics as you drive past. It's just a great experience that cheers you up and you feel amazing every time you drive it.

I miss that when I'm in the Porsche. The Porsche is a better car in many respects - in case entertainment system, sat nav, all that stuff, is much better, but it doesn't make me feel as good as when I drive the LP....The LP makes you feel like a rock star, the Porsche is an excellent and very fast car.