Insurance 20 y/o This is not a whinge at costing too much.
Insurance 20 y/o This is not a whinge at costing too much.
Author
Discussion

RussH91

Original Poster:

363 posts

181 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Evening All.
This is not a whinge, more seeking advice on which company may help reduce it.

Have been working pretty hard recently, and was looking at something new to me. MG ZS 180 top of pile at the moment.

Looking at insurance I can buy a face lift and insure it for little over 5k. Yes it’s expensive but I’d rather spend it on something I’ve worked for. I don’t plan to put this on finance, put a personal reg on it or buy something newer because it’s the reg that matters bro and its all chicks look at.

My query is there a company which will honour my 3/4 year company car no claims? As I feel this may reduce price, and I may be looking at getting something before the end of summer

Cheers Russ



VR46

289 posts

164 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Not likely.

jimmy156

3,760 posts

208 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
5k on insurance, thats crazy man!

Seriously, you will regret it, it just isn't worth it for a mildly interesting car. Keep whatever you have got, wait a couple of years, and you should have some more sensible quotes. Or find something similarly interesting that costs less to insure.

Even if you think its a good idea now, you wont in a few years time.

davepoth

29,395 posts

220 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Worth checking with work to find out who their insurer is; if you try the same company it might be a bit more likely.

rwstokes

196 posts

165 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
if you really have your heart set on the mg, this wont dissuade you, but i am 21, and insuring a 1.8 focus (i know, alot slower) for 650 fully comp, and my insurance is 100% true, so no mums main driver rubbish as with you

the only thing is, i was looking at more interesting cars, like st170, and zs's as well, and was getting quotes for more like 1500, with 2 years no claims (my policy was always mucked about in my 1st year) so was wondering how come yours are so high? as that does seem very expensive even for that car

and im sure you have, but try mg owners club, when i was looking at zr's they had some deal that got insurance cheaper with a specific company.

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

177 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
There is NO WAY a ZS 180 can't be insured cheaper than £5k.

What insurance company are you looking at? Are you adding second/third drivers to your policy (i.e. parents or older relatives which can bring down the risk)?


Spanna

3,736 posts

197 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
jimmy156 said:
5k on insurance, thats crazy man!

Seriously, you will regret it, it just isn't worth it for a mildly interesting car. Keep whatever you have got, wait a couple of years, and you should have some more sensible quotes. Or find something similarly interesting that costs less to insure.

Even if you think its a good idea now, you wont in a few years time.
I think he meant he could both buy and insure for £5K, which sounds about right. A good facelift ZS180 is around £3K then £2K for the insurance.

Not a bad choice and if it's what you really want then go for it. I did the spending a load on a car a couple of years ago. I had a 1.8T Golf GTi with mods costing me £2K a year insurance. It was quick enough and handled well with the mods I had done, but now I regret the amount of money spunked on it.

A lot of people are going to say don't do it, build the NCB etc. I'd be a hypocrite to say this having already done what you're thinking about doing.



DrDeAtH

3,674 posts

253 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Hmmm... I read it as the OP can purchase the car AND insure for the 5k budget...

Something amiss?

Cemesis

771 posts

183 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
You would be mad to spend £5,000 on insurance. Why did you settle on the MG?

66comanche

2,369 posts

180 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Why does a 20 year old want to drive a crappy rebadged Rover 45 confused

Burbleboy

220 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Try juggling a few 'occupations' around in your quotes, may work out cheaper depending on ahem, cough, what you do!

What about a 2000 reg Honda Civic Vti (mb6 5 door model)? Same body as MG ZS and lots of parts are swoppable between the makes. Standard Civic is 170bhp and a few cosmetic mods will bring the car up-to-date looks

With decent air filter and Exhaust, can reach around 180/190 bhp..for a fraction of the cost of newer MZ ZS. Help towards your insurance?

Burbleboy

220 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
66comanche said:
Why does a 20 year old want to drive a crappy rebadged Rover 45 confused
Maybe because he may like those cars rolleyes

jimmy156

3,760 posts

208 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
Ah yes, re-reading it it looks as if Car + Insurance = 5k, which is more reasonable. OP how much out of that 5k is insurance, as it may be that its already pretty reasonable (I think i paid £800ish for insurance when i was 20) on a more boring car then the MG

RikkiGTI

677 posts

170 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
If it helps, I'm 20 year old and had the same aspiration - after a nice MG ZS 180 and even with 2 years ncb, parents in the policy, still was getting quotes between 1500 and 2000 per year, so decided to stay MG either way and got myself a ZR in the end.
Albeit it's only a bottom rung 105, but driven properly, they are seriously nippy for a 1.4 16v, and the handling is certianly very good - and I came from a mk2 golf gti beforehand so kinda know the yard stick for a good fwd handling car! And the ZR is almost up there! biggrin

So maybe consider one of these? I'm deffo looki g at ZS 180s again when I get 3 years under my belt biggrin

xRIEx

8,180 posts

169 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
As said, it's highly unlikely anyone will give a bonus 8 months claim free.

Also, you say about using experience from a company car policy - will you be stopping using a company car at that point? You generally can't claim a discount for company car experience until you stop driving on that company policy (for the same reason you can only use one lot of earned NCD on one car).

RikkiGTI

677 posts

170 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
66comanche said:
Why does a 20 year old want to drive a crappy rebadged Rover 45 confused
It's really not a crappy 'rebadged' Rover 45 is it though? There are quite a few differences.

DrDeAtH

3,674 posts

253 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
xRIEx said:
As said, it's highly unlikely anyone will give a bonus 8 months claim free.

Also, you say about using experience from a company car policy - will you be stopping using a company car at that point? You generally can't claim a discount for company car experience until you stop driving on that company policy (for the same reason you can only use one lot of earned NCD on one car).
Some companies will mirror the NCB onto a new policy....

xRIEx

8,180 posts

169 months

Thursday 7th June 2012
quotequote all
DrDeAtH said:
Some companies will mirror the NCB onto a new policy....
Some, sure, but I think they usually stipulate that the other policy has to be with them. Zurich certainly used to do that.

JREwing

17,547 posts

200 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
66comanche said:
Why does a 20 year old want to drive a crappy rebadged Rover 45 confused
Why do you want to make unsubstantiated comments?

I bet you're the sort of guy who drives an Audi, and then criticises other cars for being related to cheaper ones.

DanDC5

19,705 posts

188 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Regarding your company car insurance, was the insurance in your name or the companies name with you listed as the driver? If it was done in your name then you should be ok, if the latter than it's unlikely any company would be happy to honour it. But you never know if you don't ask.