Teenager raped because bus fare was 20p short...
Teenager raped because bus fare was 20p short...
Author
Discussion

nelly1

Original Poster:

5,666 posts

262 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Story here... and here...

Telegraph Article said:
The rape took place last December. Michael Auty, prosecuting, said the student had been out celebrating the end of her law exams when she boarded the last bus home. He told the court: "The fare was £5. She had only £4.80. The bus driver would not waive the 20p. She asked him if he could wait while she got some money from a nearby cash machine.

He refused that request too. She was effectively turfed off the bus and left stranded at 3am."
What sort of jobsworth b@stard chucks a teenage girl off his bus at 3am for the want of 20p, and WTF didn't one of the other passengers pay while she was pleading with the heartless driver for 8 minutes?

What a tragic set of circumstances frown

Negative Creep

26,147 posts

258 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
nelly1 said:
Story here... and here...

Telegraph Article said:
The rape took place last December. Michael Auty, prosecuting, said the student had been out celebrating the end of her law exams when she boarded the last bus home. He told the court: "The fare was £5. She had only £4.80. The bus driver would not waive the 20p. She asked him if he could wait while she got some money from a nearby cash machine.

He refused that request too. She was effectively turfed off the bus and left stranded at 3am."
What sort of jobsworth b@stard chucks a teenage girl off his bus at 3am for the want of 20p, and WTF didn't one of the other passengers pay while she was pleading with the heartless driver for 8 minutes?

What a tragic set of circumstances frown
Sad outcome, but why should the bus driver have let her travel? She could not afford to travel, and it doesn't matter if she was 10p or £10 short. Or should anyone who's young and female just be given an automatic discount?

tom2019

770 posts

226 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Not really suprising..

I didnt get let on a bus once because I had a ten pound note and he had no change.

StottyZr

6,860 posts

194 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Stupid title for the thread. She was not raped because she was 20p short for the bus. Lots of emotional people who lack logic are jumping on this story, its an unfortunate situation yes, but the bus driver cannot be blamed in anyway. The rapist can, and should be held 100% accountable for what he did. I wish they'd drop this bus driver nonsense.

nelly1

Original Poster:

5,666 posts

262 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Negative Creep said:
Sad outcome, but why should the bus driver have let her travel? She could not afford to travel, and it doesn't matter if she was 10p or £10 short. Or should anyone who's young and female just be given an automatic discount?
But she offered to pay.

It would have taken a lot less than eight minutes for the driver to stop at a cash machine.

As a one-off, sort of Human gesture maybe?

StottyZr

6,860 posts

194 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
I've now actually read the circumstances, £4.80 at 3am and 20p short and he wouldn't let her on? Thats a bit harsh, I'd still be saying thats harsh if she had got home safely btw. Still standing by the previous comment smile

beanbag

7,346 posts

272 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
StottyZr said:
Stupid title for the thread. She was not raped because she was 20p short for the bus. Lots of emotional people who lack logic are jumping on this story, its an unfortunate situation yes, but the bus driver cannot be blamed in anyway. The rapist can, and should be held 100% accountable for what he did. I wish they'd drop this bus driver nonsense.
True, and as unfortunately and tragic was the outcome; There's something that's not quite right about this story. According to some articles, she begged for eight minutes and nobody wanted to help her. That simply doesn't sound normal and I get the impression there were reasons for that.

Anyhow....regardless of any of this, the rapist is 100% accountable and it's typical sensationalism by the papers.

Sheets Tabuer

21,564 posts

246 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
The girl wasn't a teenager the rapist was. A little common sense from the driver might have helped, it was 3am and she was alone.

I think the rapist should be taken out and shot simply because after he did it the moron ran to a police car to tell them he thinks a woman has been raped, good plan mate they and the victim won't suspect you will they?

sportka1

1,025 posts

186 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
why did she not pay the £4.80 and get off a few stops early?

OlberJ

14,101 posts

264 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
nelly1 said:
But she offered to pay.

It would have taken a lot less than eight minutes for the driver to stop at a cash machine.

As a one-off, sort of Human gesture maybe?
And if the girl then got raped while the bus driver stopped to let her out at the cash machine?

Negative Creep

26,147 posts

258 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
nelly1 said:
Negative Creep said:
Sad outcome, but why should the bus driver have let her travel? She could not afford to travel, and it doesn't matter if she was 10p or £10 short. Or should anyone who's young and female just be given an automatic discount?
But she offered to pay.

It would have taken a lot less than eight minutes for the driver to stop at a cash machine.

As a one-off, sort of Human gesture maybe?
The bus has a schedule to keep to. If he had agreed to wait around whilst she went off to find a cash machine everyone else on the bus would have complained and his boss would be asking why he was late. With hindsight should he have just used his discretion? Yes, but that doesn't mean he was required to, and linking the two events together makes this place sound like Musmnet

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
There's a secondary crime going on here too - £5 for a bloody bus journey?!? The operator should be thrown in jail too.

swiftpete

1,894 posts

224 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
How can the headline say teenager, then in the second paragraph say that she's 22 years old. Does nobody check these articles before publishing them?

otolith

69,814 posts

235 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
The joys of being dependent on socialised transport.

hyperblue

2,921 posts

211 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Negative Creep said:
The bus has a schedule to keep to. If he had agreed to wait around whilst she went off to find a cash machine everyone else on the bus would have complained and his boss would be asking why he was late.
Yes, the main concern on the 3am night bus is always the schedule! Most people on it hardly realise they're on a bus at that time.

nelly1

Original Poster:

5,666 posts

262 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Looks like I chose the wrong week to look for a little compassion on PH...


Dan_1981

18,130 posts

230 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
She was going to a cash machine, so we can assume she was able to withdraw at least a tenner, £14.80 gets you a fairly long way in a taxi, especially up here in the cold hard bitter north.

No-one is to blame here except for the rapist.

The poor girl should be able to walk home if she so felt the need.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Negative Creep said:
nelly1 said:
Negative Creep said:
Sad outcome, but why should the bus driver have let her travel? She could not afford to travel, and it doesn't matter if she was 10p or £10 short. Or should anyone who's young and female just be given an automatic discount?
But she offered to pay.

It would have taken a lot less than eight minutes for the driver to stop at a cash machine.

As a one-off, sort of Human gesture maybe?
The bus has a schedule to keep to. If he had agreed to wait around whilst she went off to find a cash machine everyone else on the bus would have complained and his boss would be asking why he was late. With hindsight should he have just used his discretion? Yes, but that doesn't mean he was required to, and linking the two events together makes this place sound like Musmnet
Don't forget that the bus driver has to pay any shortages in the money taken out of his wages, it happened automaticly where I used to drive. Why should he personally pay for other people's trips?

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Lets imagine a different story.
Drunken girl forced to walk home because she didn’t have money for busfare.
That’s fine, it’s probably happened to a lot of us.
I doubt there would be any sympathy at all for her.
She was an adult, she knew how much a bus costs.
She should have been prepared.

Imagine the other headlines.
Bus delayed for 10 minutes while stupid drunk girl tries to get money.
Woman attacked as she walked home because bus was 10 minutes late and she thought she has missed it.
Booze Britain – drunk girl begs for charity for bus faire, then throws up on driver.


It’s horrible that she was raped.
Absolutely horrible.
But, it’s not the bus drivers fault, nor is it the girls fault, it’s the rapists fault.



As an aside, she wasn’t kicked off for being 20p short. She wasn’t actually allowed on.
Buses, trains, trams, planes etc are all well known for not letting you on if you don’t have the correct fare – no matter what.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
Why didnt she just get on the bus and get off a couple of stops earlier?