Compromise on engine/transmission?
Compromise on engine/transmission?
Author
Discussion

JimCross

Original Poster:

168 posts

234 months

Friday 8th June 2012
quotequote all
So, I've finally decided that an E90 3-series is the way to go. Initially I was looking for manual 330i/35i M Sport. However, it seems there are very few manuals around. So I'm left with a choice of either hanging around (possibly for a very long time) for the right car to come up, or compromising in one of two ways:
1. Go diesel - there's a lovely spec manual 330d on Autotrader at the moment
2. Go auto

I love a great sounding engine, and I also love the interaction of a manual box and the satisfaction from a great heal and toe downshift. However, I do relatively few miles (3-4k a year), most of which are on motorways/dual carriageways, with only the odd few miles on country roads every now and then for fun. Would either the auto box or the diesel be such a compromise in that case?
While a test drive gives some idea, it doesn't give an impression of how much you might miss something/get used to something over a longer period.

Has anyone else made either of these compromises and regretted it, or found it not to be that much of a big deal? How good is the auto box in manual mode?

Huff

3,448 posts

222 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
Depends on your priorities. To me, an auto petrol is a considerably more attractive idea than a diesel manual.

Yes, I like that manual interaction myself - a lot. When a few years ago I went looking for an E34 V8 the best one found, by far, was actually an auto. I really wanted a manual, but it was the whole condition/package that swung it for me - in about 15mins flat.

I still have it nearly five years later. It's just sublime on the kind of driving you are envisaging - I do about 8-10k miles/yr in it. At first I used S mode and manual hold a lot but you know what? A good auto can be a very nice thing indeed on its own merits. So if you come across the car that 'feels right' and it turns out to be an auto - go try it and be open to enjoying the experience.

rassi

2,518 posts

282 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
At a 3-4K annual mileage it would be insane to go for a diesel. Personally think a manual 330D is not ideal, you are never going to be heel & toeing in that...

At that mileage, go for an M3 if you want a manual petrol!

billywhizzzzzz

2,675 posts

174 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
I have a 56 plate 330d M Sport Touring Manual. It's a staggeringly efficient tool, an amazing chassis and engine. However, I only now do 8000 or so miles a year, and fantastic as the car is, it feels like a compromise... and I yearn for a straight six petrol. So, am selling it to get the 330i/335i manual I wished i'd bought! it is, by the way, on autotrader and PH classifieds!

tmrobinson

44 posts

179 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
I've just bought a 330d manual, waited a long time to find a decent manual to come up as most seem to be autos. Its bloody fantastic and doesn't sound bad for a oil burner but I do a lot more miles than you (20k per yr) and if i was doing your mileage I would be getting a 330i manual...

JimCross

Original Poster:

168 posts

234 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
I just had a test drive in an auto 335i. The auto wasn't too bad actually, I think I could get used to it! And the engine....what an engine! That's definitely put me off getting the diesel. Sounds fantastic and the top end is incredible!
Sadly it was a pretty tatty example, but I think that's narrowed down the search

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 9th June 2012
quotequote all
rassi said:
a manual 330D is not ideal, you are never going to be heel & toeing in that...
Except the dervs are great for heal and toe in manual spec becuase they have virtually no throttle delay (becuase they are fuel mass controlled not airmass controlled) hence they "blip down the box" in a very satisfying way actually ! I should know, i've done 157k miles in my 330d manual ;-)