N53 - are the risks as great as they seem?
Discussion
Looking at an E91 330i as a day-to-day 'family' car, but company car allowance specifies <5y.o. at commencement, which given I want a manual makes finding a suitable N52-engine'd car a near-impossibility.
But I'm a little concerned with the N53's HP fuel rail - same woes as the N54, from what I read. I know a BMW warranty will cover it (all of it???), but I'm used to reliable cars and not needing the RAC.
So...what should I know, what are people's real experiences?
But I'm a little concerned with the N53's HP fuel rail - same woes as the N54, from what I read. I know a BMW warranty will cover it (all of it???), but I'm used to reliable cars and not needing the RAC.
So...what should I know, what are people's real experiences?
We had a new 2008 330Ci no idea what N number the engine was.
Got it new September 2008 ran it till November 2011 127k in that time, never had a new car so unreliable!! It spent lots of time back for warranty work, warning lights would come on and you would be in limp mode call into nearest BM garage and when they put the key in the machine nope nothing wrong with your car!!! This happened on several occassions and my wife lost confidence in the car.
It had several sets of injectors,coil packs, 2 fuel pumps and numerous other parts. Coil packs/injectors replaced approx every 5/6k so you can see why we got fed up we spent far to much time at the garage.... Oh and when
The car from day one had a hesitant missfire when sitting at constant motorway speed that they never cured. It was in several different garages and lots of complaints to BM head office.
Tyre pressure monitor warning would come on giving false alarm in all but one instance!
Having said that the car was a great drive, it did lots of Col roads in the Alps and over the 127k averaged 33mpg (not on the onboard computer the actual worked out MPG) cruising down to the Alps at !$%kph it would return 36MPG incredable for the pace and engine size.
Miss the car not the hassle!
Got it new September 2008 ran it till November 2011 127k in that time, never had a new car so unreliable!! It spent lots of time back for warranty work, warning lights would come on and you would be in limp mode call into nearest BM garage and when they put the key in the machine nope nothing wrong with your car!!! This happened on several occassions and my wife lost confidence in the car.
It had several sets of injectors,coil packs, 2 fuel pumps and numerous other parts. Coil packs/injectors replaced approx every 5/6k so you can see why we got fed up we spent far to much time at the garage.... Oh and when
The car from day one had a hesitant missfire when sitting at constant motorway speed that they never cured. It was in several different garages and lots of complaints to BM head office.
Tyre pressure monitor warning would come on giving false alarm in all but one instance!
Having said that the car was a great drive, it did lots of Col roads in the Alps and over the 127k averaged 33mpg (not on the onboard computer the actual worked out MPG) cruising down to the Alps at !$%kph it would return 36MPG incredable for the pace and engine size.
Miss the car not the hassle!
Thanks Neil...that's the sort of story I've been hearing.
Anyone else comment? Anyone had one without problems?
Other thought is a 330d, but while it's quick enough the engine is 'easy but not exciting'...completely the opposite of a VTEC.
(Not necessarily a bad thing, just not what I'm used to and not what inspires me in a car)
Anyone else comment? Anyone had one without problems?
Other thought is a 330d, but while it's quick enough the engine is 'easy but not exciting'...completely the opposite of a VTEC.
(Not necessarily a bad thing, just not what I'm used to and not what inspires me in a car)
Well, I've got a 2008 530i, 81k miles and fingers crossed it's never missed a beat (famous last words!). Petrol in one end, servicing at the other and one of the smoothest and quietest drives there is in between. She'll also lift her skirt and play ball when called upon showing many a boy racer a clean pair of heels.
The car returns roughly 33-35 mpg and as a daily driver is a lovely smooth ointment at the end of many a crap working day.
I love it.
Simon
The car returns roughly 33-35 mpg and as a daily driver is a lovely smooth ointment at the end of many a crap working day.
I love it.
Simon
Not sure this is much help I will be but I was in a similar position to you last month, do I find an N52 or N53 engine. I ended up buying a 2006 330i touring due to:
1) Not being able find a 325i or 330i with the spec/mileage/service history I was after, &
2) Being put offer by the stories or problems.
Say the above, my grandmother has a 325i from 2009 and it has been great so far however it has only done 8,000 mile since new.
I don’t mind cars having problems and issues, it’s a machine and things will happen, but what I read was problems where very tricky to fix and sometimes, the same problem keep coming back again and again.
I guess you take a chance with any car but for me, I would rather stick some more fuel in the tank and have a tried and tested engine… (We will only to 7K a year so no need for a diesel) .
1) Not being able find a 325i or 330i with the spec/mileage/service history I was after, &
2) Being put offer by the stories or problems.
Say the above, my grandmother has a 325i from 2009 and it has been great so far however it has only done 8,000 mile since new.
I don’t mind cars having problems and issues, it’s a machine and things will happen, but what I read was problems where very tricky to fix and sometimes, the same problem keep coming back again and again.
I guess you take a chance with any car but for me, I would rather stick some more fuel in the tank and have a tried and tested engine… (We will only to 7K a year so no need for a diesel) .
Simon BB said:
Well, I've got a 2008 530i, 81k miles and fingers crossed it's never missed a beat (famous last words!). Petrol in one end, servicing at the other and one of the smoothest and quietest drives there is in between. She'll also lift her skirt and play ball when called upon showing many a boy racer a clean pair of heels.
The car returns roughly 33-35 mpg and as a daily driver is a lovely smooth ointment at the end of many a crap working day.
I love it.
Simon
Have you done the 81k in this car or did you buy secondhand?The car returns roughly 33-35 mpg and as a daily driver is a lovely smooth ointment at the end of many a crap working day.
I love it.
Simon
I would be surprised if it has not required coil packs in that mileage!!
We did love the 330Ci just not it's friendlyness with the dealers service department
:My wife chose a new X3 to replace the coupe and 27k in no mechanical problems (fingers crossed)but the door seals all round have been replaced. The fuel economy from this diesel is only slightly better than the 330Ci and it is absolutely as boring as hell to drive

havoc said:
Looking at an E91 330i as a day-to-day 'family' car, but company car allowance specifies <5y.o. at commencement, which given I want a manual makes finding a suitable N52-engine'd car a near-impossibility.
But I'm a little concerned with the N53's HP fuel rail - same woes as the N54, from what I read. I know a BMW warranty will cover it (all of it???), but I'm used to reliable cars and not needing the RAC.
So...what should I know, what are people's real experiences?
Have I not moaned enough about my BMW on NSXCB? But I'm a little concerned with the N53's HP fuel rail - same woes as the N54, from what I read. I know a BMW warranty will cover it (all of it???), but I'm used to reliable cars and not needing the RAC.
So...what should I know, what are people's real experiences?
Simon BB said:
Well, I've got a 2008 530i, 81k miles and fingers crossed it's never missed a beat (famous last words!). Petrol in one end, servicing at the other and one of the smoothest and quietest drives there is in between. She'll also lift her skirt and play ball when called upon showing many a boy racer a clean pair of heels.
The car returns roughly 33-35 mpg and as a daily driver is a lovely smooth ointment at the end of many a crap working day.
I love it.
Simon
When in 2008 did you buy it - I recall you could still pick up the N52 early on in the year?The car returns roughly 33-35 mpg and as a daily driver is a lovely smooth ointment at the end of many a crap working day.
I love it.
Simon
NoelWatson said:
When in 2008 did you buy it - I recall you could still pick up the N52 early on in the year?
N53 appeared in the E60 at the LCI in March 2007, in the E93 from introduction in March 2007 and into the E90, E91 and E92 from September 2007 build. Unless it was a late registration almost all 2008 cars are N53.NoelWatson said:
Have I not moaned enough about my BMW on NSXCB?

You have indeed Mr W...it was yours and Neil's comments there and here which prompted this thread, to be honest! The 330i is probably the most interesting 'affordable, quick, practical, fun' car out there...but the bloody car allowance regs shove me straight into N53 territory, and I'm not certain I like any of the alternatives* better than the BM, as a car to drive and be happy in.
May have to talk nicely to the HR Manager, see if she'll turn a small blind eye and pretend the 5 years really says 6...
* Legacy Spec-B has a lovely engine and chassis and big spec, but gearbox and steering aren't quite right and 25mpg average is a bit crap, really. S4's hold their value too well. Focus ST3 is the other call, and is the 'cheap, easy' option. Wife has a MkV GTi so I'm not getting any other VAG as I'll be forever comparing the two and wanting her Golf...
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


