2.8 fan blades and vibrations
2.8 fan blades and vibrations
Author
Discussion

Dino D

Original Poster:

1,953 posts

252 months

Monday 18th June 2012
quotequote all
On my Z3 2.8 today I heard a noise as if I went over some plastic bottles or cans and thought nothing of it. 30 mins later stopped at te lights and notice the car is moving about as if being buffeted or something is oscillating and loose making the car shake.

Checked the gauges and revs and engine was fine, no misfire or anything.

When I stop I get a chance to open the bonnet And have a look and see the enging is vibrating causing the sensations but no misfire.

Looked at the fan as I have had the viscous coupling replaced a few months and many miles back and noticed three blades missing.

So need a new plastic fan for sure but is it the broken blades causing the vibration or is it the vibration causing the fan to break.

My searching on the net talks about fans shafts, engine mounts or just brittle fans giving up the ghost..

Any thoughts or experiences?

Will get it over to a garage when I can and will not use it until sorted.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 18th June 2012
quotequote all
Its the imbalance or the fan, new one will sort it.

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Monday 18th June 2012
quotequote all
I've not got a Z3 but I have had the exact same problem on My E36 328i.

Whilst checking the oil one day, I noticed the fan shroud was loose and a couple of blades were missing off the fan. I figured that the shroud had come loose and had dropped onto the fan.

I had the fan replaced and the shroud refitted correctly by BMW and a week later I found the new fan had blades missing and the fan shroud was pretty much in pieces.

I cut the remains of the shroud away and took the car back to BMW.

Turns out the engine mounts were shot and it was allowing the engine to move around enough to cause the fan to hit the shroud!
I had to replace the fan for a second time, along with the engine mounts and the complete fan shroud.
I was shown the old engine mounts and they were incredibly cracked and perished!

(To be fair to BMW, I got a decent discount on the second lot of work due to them not spotting that the engine mounts were shot the first time round smile )

So if I were you, I'd get your engine mounts checked/replaced at the same time as the fan or you could easily be having to buy another fan shortly afterwards.

rumple

15,421 posts

182 months

Tuesday 19th June 2012
quotequote all
Also check you haven't damaged a power steering pipe, I kinked one on my 328 and it caused exactly the same symptoms.

Dino D

Original Poster:

1,953 posts

252 months

Wednesday 20th June 2012
quotequote all
Ordered a new fan from BMW and will have it fitted Friday by my mechanic and have him check engine mounts then.

Mechanic seems to think that maybe the fan was damaged when another mechanic I used changed the viscous fan coupling.
Should have gone down the electric fan route back them looking at how this is adding up too! Hindsight is a wonderful thing!

Would I not notice something if the engine mounts where that far gone?

If the mounts are gone then the next question will be OEM or uprated mounts...

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Wednesday 20th June 2012
quotequote all
Dino D said:
Mechanic seems to think that maybe the fan was damaged when another mechanic I used changed the viscous fan coupling.
Should have gone down the electric fan route back them looking at how this is adding up too! Hindsight is a wonderful thing!
I'd be surprised if it was damaged by the other mechanic TBH, it's not exactly the most complicated job to swap the fan assembly over to the new viscous coupling, but it's not impossible that that's what happened.

As for the electric fan route, I'm not convinced it's that much of an advantage over the viscous fan TBH. The Americans tend to rave about it like it unleashes an extra 100BHP due to there being no drag on the engine, but I'm not convinced it's worth it.

"Ah but the viscous fan can fail as the viscous liquid gets old!", they'll say - yeah, after 10 years plus! Plenty of electric fans have failed after a similar period too though due to motors seizing, thermo switches failing, electrical shorts etc., etc.

Dino D said:
Would I not notice something if the engine mounts where that far gone?
you might notice a bit more vibration than usual if they're severely gone but it's not guaranteed. (When Mine went, I didn't notice anything untoward and the car felt no different with the new mounts fitted).

When the mounts go, what tends to happen is that the engine twists and shifts with when the throttle is applied and on throttle lift off. This doesn't cause the engine to constantly bounce around in the engine bay though, it just tends to lean over a bit with the engine torque.

I'm not sure about the Z3 but on the E36, the fan shroud (mounted to the radiator), sits pretty close to the (engine mounted) fan, so it doesn't take that much engine movement to cause the damage.

Dino D said:
If the mounts are gone then the next question will be OEM or uprated mounts...
If it were Me, I'd go with OEM. I paid @ £40 each from BMW and they should last 10 years plus (My original mounts had lasted 13 years and 137,000 miles).