E36 strange noise over 30mph - Please help!!
E36 strange noise over 30mph - Please help!!
Author
Discussion

Mark34bn

Original Poster:

827 posts

208 months

Saturday 23rd June 2012
quotequote all
Just lately my E36 328i has developed a noise. It is a very rhythmical sound, like a "wow-wow-wow-wow" as you travel on smooth road. It is speed dependent, ie, speed up so the sound rises in pitch (but not volume), slow down and it does too. The nose is there regardless of whether the car is in gear or not / clutch in or out.
There is no vibration, just the noise.
Is this the first sign of wheel bearings starting to pack it in? In the last week I have replaced all discs, pads & handbrake assys but it hasn't made any difference.

Any suggestions??

Higgs boson

1,105 posts

184 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
I think that you've probably identified the problem yourself.
You have replaced bits which have the possibility of rubbing on wheel rotation, and making the noise that you describe. Gear box / diff is unlikely.
Have you tried loading up one side and then the other, to see if noise diminishes or increases?

Mark34bn

Original Poster:

827 posts

208 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
The noise doesn't change steering left or right. This morning I was driving with just fingertips on the wheel and could feel a slight tugging in time with the noise (oo err etc!)
Could a sticking caliper have warped one of the new front discs in 50 miles?? I'll jack the front up tomorrow and see if I can find anything. Will a duff bearing be obvious by the sound it makes?

Zwolf

25,878 posts

237 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
I'd also be assuming a wheel bearing needed replacing.

AARONM3

418 posts

247 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
I had the same car many moons okay and had to replace something on the diff (I think) called a giubo- but that was more of a vibrating noise IIRC but might be worth checking. But it probably is a wheel bearing.

Higgs boson

1,105 posts

184 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Mark34bn said:
The noise doesn't change steering left or right. This morning I was driving with just fingertips on the wheel and could feel a slight tugging in time with the noise (oo err etc!)
Could a sticking caliper have warped one of the new front discs in 50 miles?? I'll jack the front up tomorrow and see if I can find anything. Will a duff bearing be obvious by the sound it makes?
Mark, the disc being affected in such a short time is highly unlikely. However, it's not unknown for a new disc to be out of true.
In the early stages of bearing failure, it can be difficult to establish which one is on the way out - sometimes it needs to be left to get worse, before a positive ID can be made.

VinceFox

20,566 posts

203 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Wheel bearing or guibo. Guibo often sounds louder if you come off throttle at speed.