528i or 530i
528i or 530i
Author
Discussion

Bezza1969

Original Poster:

777 posts

179 months

Saturday 23rd June 2012
quotequote all
Following my thread from the end of last year, Im still getting that 528i itch, but wondering whether its worth pushing the boat out for a 530i. Trouble is, I dont like the sport models and actually want a manual SE, which is a rare old beast in a 530, but more common in a 528, as BMW only introduced the sport in about 1999 or 2000. Is the 530 worth the extra, as 528s are getting cheaper and cheaper. Period road tests showed the 530i wasnt much quicker than the 528i despite the claimed extra 38 BHP, which always surprised me...any views?

ajb85

1,124 posts

173 months

Saturday 23rd June 2012
quotequote all
Don't think there's a gret deal in it. All the 6 cylunder BMs are great, And certainly the 2.8 was the best of its time. They suffer very little mechanically, the occasional dodgy thermostat and cooling systems affect both 530 and 528.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Saturday 23rd June 2012
quotequote all
What's your budget?

Bezza1969

Original Poster:

777 posts

179 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Well, I was hoping to get a "cheapee" for a grand or a bit more, which I guess excludes the 530i, which starts at about 2K at the moment! There's a one owner 528i manual on E bay with 93K miles on it and FSH, up for £1095. Thats a lot of quality motor for the money

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Obviously the 530i is superior but thats because it replaced the 528i so therefore is to be expected. That said the 528i is hardly 'bad', infact its 'very good' and you won't feel small changed. With such a small budget I'd be loath to stretch even harder to get a 530i as you'll be eating into the contingency fund its important to maintain with a car like this.

Personally I struggle to see the point in a £1k E39 - you buy a £1k car because you want something cheap, keeping an old E39 on the road, especially one thats 10-15 years old and selling for a grand, isn't really 'cheap' - but if thats what you want to do then it has to be a 528i really.

Infact if you do want to spend more I'd stick with the 528i. A lovely 528i is a better car than a sheddy 530i.

rumple

15,422 posts

182 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
They are the same car, one has a little bit more go but thats it, just find the best example you can and buy it.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
I would get the 528 on your budget then.. but yeah they can cost you the same and more every year of ownership., if properly looked after.

OldSkoolRS

7,296 posts

210 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
If the difference is the same as for the Z3, then the 2.8 may be slightly less economical and the longer stroke on the 3.0 gives more torque (plus 40PS or so). If it's a question of having a scruffy 3.0 or a tidy 2.8, then whatever small saving on fuel the 3.0 gives could be wiped out by any repairs, so I'd still go for the 2.8 if the budget it tight and you want a 6 cylinder petrol.

Mustard

6,992 posts

276 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Or compromise

Facelift 525i same bhp as 528i just slightly less torque

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Mustard said:
Or compromise

Facelift 525i same bhp as 528i just slightly less torque
Still a stretch from his rock bottom budget though.

Mustard

6,992 posts

276 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Mustard said:
Or compromise

Facelift 525i same bhp as 528i just slightly less torque
Still a stretch from his rock bottom budget though.
I guess, for a grand or so a 530i was never in the running, low twos for a decent 525i, high twos for a decent 530i

A bag? Just buy the best you can find regardless of engine!

saturnuranus

80 posts

219 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Or do what I did and find a 540 for a grand. Nothing went wrong.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
saturnuranus said:
Or do what I did and find a 540 for a grand. Nothing went wrong.
Thats odd, because in your profile you recommend against it?

saturnuranus said:
I bought the cheapest one I could find and then spent time & money fixing up loose/knocky bits. My advice? Avoid the very cheapest and spend about twice the amount of the bottom feeders.

Bezza1969

Original Poster:

777 posts

179 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Personally I struggle to see the point in a £1k E39 - you buy a £1k car because you want something cheap, keeping an old E39 on the road, especially one thats 10-15 years old and selling for a grand, isn't really 'cheap' - but if thats what you want to do then it has to be a 528i really.

.
This was going to be my next question, are they really expensive to keep on the road. I mean if you find a leggy one thats had the usual shocks, new clutch, etc done, what would make it expensive to keep going for the years to come...The other thing Ive noticed is that £2K 528s seem to have similar mileage to many of the 1K ones, or if not, its just the difference between a 100K mile car and one with 140K and the latter is more likely to have many parts replaced...

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
Bezza1969 said:
This was going to be my next question, are they really expensive to keep on the road. I mean if you find a leggy one thats had the usual shocks, new clutch, etc done, what would make it expensive to keep going for the years to come...The other thing Ive noticed is that £2K 528s seem to have similar mileage to many of the 1K ones, or if not, its just the difference between a 100K mile car and one with 140K and the latter is more likely to have many parts replaced...
I bought mine at 4 years old and its now 10. I don't think I've been particularly unlucky yet, and I've detailed all my costs in my profile if you are interested smile

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 24th June 2012
quotequote all
They arn't terribly expensive generally*



  • If it decides to be kind and break at spaced out intervals smile But seriously, expect £150-£300 bills here and there, in my experience they crop up 3-4 times a year.

saturnuranus

80 posts

219 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
saturnuranus said:
Or do what I did and find a 540 for a grand. Nothing went wrong.
Thats odd, because in your profile you recommend against it?
Yea, smiley probably gone AWOL from the end of my post. It was a great motor, but in my experience they (v. cheap E39) aren't cheap to run if you like to keep your car tip top. More money for a well serviced machine would be money well spent.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 25th June 2012
quotequote all
For a grand, an old P-S plate 528i is the way to go. They're pretty unloved now so you may well find a decent one for £600 on Ebay etc. Single vanos (pre 9/98 build) are probably more reliable as the Vanos unit is less inclined to wear out and the breather system is simpler. Also buy a manual gearbox car, one less thing to go wrong.
For a grand I'd look for a really tidy 1996-98 example and be prepared to throw it away if the engine sts itself. They're great cars but are not very good 'bangers' to be run on a shoestring budget.