Please please help me decide on new car / BMW
Please please help me decide on new car / BMW
Author
Discussion

menousername

Original Poster:

2,525 posts

173 months

Thursday 28th June 2012
quotequote all
Hi all

Long time viewer, new poster - enjoy hearing your expert thoughts on BMWs, seeing your pics etc

appreciate there have probably been posts like this before but I am really stuck for my next car and hope you can help

have had 3 e46s in a row, last being a 330ci coupe. Have been thinking about an x5 for a long time but continually read that the handling / feedback in the snow is actually quite poor unless you fit winter tyres... the same people who advocate winter tyres also say that they make winter driving really good in any car even their real-wheel coupes etc.

my conundrum - only real 4x4 use the x5 will get is near Christmas when I look after / pick up some elderly relatives, is the expense and hassle of winter tyres worth it? Is it best to stick with the Coupe and just invest in winter tyres for that? Usually, throughout the year, I am a low mileage driver rarely with anyone else in the car. I would struggle to give up the power and the handling, really enjoy my 330. Part of me fancies treating myself - but I always want to keep it sensible and not be too extravogant - any ideas on deccent, fun performance cars that are still sensible, please do let me know.

my budget if being sensible is 8/9k, if being a bit indulgent can go somewhere about 12k.

Have considered an e46 M3, 6 series coupe, 5 series sport (not as keen) or e90 shape 3 series. For my money, that would be an SE 3 series. On the e46 I know SE was less sought after than the M Sport but on the e90 the SE seems to be much more available.

All thoughts / inputs MOST appeciated

tks guys