Concreting over the countryside...
Concreting over the countryside...
Author
Discussion

supersingle

Original Poster:

3,205 posts

250 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
....or not.

Beeb link.

Can we have some more houses and roads and stuff now please.

Carfiend

3,186 posts

240 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Don't be silly. Don't you care about destroying the habitat of the Lesser Spotted Scrotal Swarmer? It is a fascinating insect that waits for a large mammal to come by then crawls its way up the urethra where it uses a number of barbs to lodge itself in place takes in water and minerals from the hosts urine. The final step of its life it will release millions of eggs when the host urinates and it releases its grip to be flushed out. However the barbs do not fully retract and so some bleeding and pain can occur.

turbobloke

117,552 posts

291 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
So 2.3% total.

There was a discussion on BBC Radio 2 a while back about this very question and one estimate in the studio was an earnest 60% for the 'concreted over' bits. One caller was close when they suggested 1% or less but this was dismissed.

It's fairly straightforward to estimate the area covered by roads at 1.4% so the rest i.e. buildings and other structures is just under 1% on top.

Rugbyman

1,625 posts

234 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
So why the huge difference between what we expect the % to be and what it actually is ?

Would it have something to do with all the campaigns to plant more trees - keep the green belt green - paving paradise and puting up a carpark...?

Or more to do with the fact that the majority live in the urban areas and see concrete everyday and so have naturally unbalanced view on this ?

ETA quote from article.. 'Woodland now 12.7% of the UK, the highest proportion since 1924 when records began'

Edited by Rugbyman on Friday 29th June 10:20

otolith

69,716 posts

235 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Rugbyman said:
So why the huge difference between what we expect the % to be and what it actually is ?
Because people are not evenly distributed over the country. Because people who live in the South East of England have a very parochial understanding of geography (see annual winter tyre debate).

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Rugbyman said:
So why the huge difference between what we expect the % to be and what it actually is ?

Would it have something to do with all the campaigns to plant more trees - keep the green belt green - paving paradise and puting up a carpark...?

Or more to do with the fact that the majority live in the urban areas and see concrete everyday and so have naturally unbalanced view on this ?

ETA quote from article.. 'Woodland now 12.7% of the UK, the highest proportion since 1924 when records began'
Most people don't explore our countryside, or think that leaving London for a trip to the South Downs is indicative of the rest of the UK's countryside. It's a real shame as it's relatively easy in the UK to go somewhere where you can walk/run/cycle all day offroad and often alone.

Riley Blue

23,217 posts

257 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Judging by the map, the figure for enclosed farmland would be considerably higher so how come we have to import so much food?

otolith

69,716 posts

235 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Riley Blue said:
Judging by the map, the figure for enclosed farmland would be considerably higher so how come we have to import so much food?
Largely because people want to eat (for example) asparagus in November.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Carfiend said:
Don't be silly. Don't you care about destroying the habitat of the Lesser Spotted Scrotal Swarmer? It is a fascinating insect that waits for a large mammal to come by then crawls its way up the urethra where it uses a number of barbs to lodge itself in place takes in water and minerals from the hosts urine. The final step of its life it will release millions of eggs when the host urinates and it releases its grip to be flushed out. However the barbs do not fully retract and so some bleeding and pain can occur.
You're taking the piss aren't you?

Carfiend

3,186 posts

240 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
No the Lesser Spotted Scrotal Swarmer is the one doing that.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
It's easy to sit in a traffic jam in London or Birmingham and lament the overcrowding, but it's so localised around a few cities.

The statistic that I always find surprising is that there's roughly 60 million acres of the UK, which means, give or take, an acre per person. Not per family, but per person.

This is why Malthusian gloom mongers are always wrong. Internationally we're still a fairly crowded country. And the rest of the world isn't all war zones, deserts and frozen tundra. If you look at Russia, Canada, Kazakhstan, Australia, New Zealand, and a bunch of other countries behind, there is to all intents and purposes infinite habitable land with fresh water available.

What's more, food is cheap. Ok your granny might disagree when comparing it with her day, but the amount of people you could feed on an average salary is just stupidly big, and compared with 100 years ago it would be many multiples larger now. Food has got relatively cheaper for as long as it's been traded, because technology, transport and storage have all improved tremendously, and it's quite likely they will continue to do so.

hornet

6,333 posts

281 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Rugbyman said:
So why the huge difference between what we expect the % to be and what it actually is ?

Would it have something to do with all the campaigns to plant more trees - keep the green belt green - paving paradise and puting up a carpark...?

Or more to do with the fact that the majority live in the urban areas and see concrete everyday and so have naturally unbalanced view on this ?

ETA quote from article.. 'Woodland now 12.7% of the UK, the highest proportion since 1924 when records began'

Edited by Rugbyman on Friday 29th June 10:20
Said it elsewhere, but people don't appreciate just how green London actually is. Get anywhere with a decent view and there's a staggering amount of greenery, even in the busiest areas. Sure I read somewhere that there has been a survey of exactly how many trees exist in Greater London, and it's something ludicrous like a billion. Very big number indeed.

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
The statistic that I always find surprising is that there's roughly 60 million acres of the UK, which means, give or take, an acre per person. Not per family, but per person.
Just remember that some of those acres are in places like Beckton, Middlesbrough and Lincolnshire, so someone's going to be disappointed.

"Here, an entire acre, just for you. Doesn't it sound nice? "Tower Green"."

"Er, excuse me. You appear to have given me the single sttiest bit of Middlesbrough by mistake."

stichill99

1,223 posts

212 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
You ask why do we have to import food? The true reason is because farming has been in recession for far longer than the rest of the economy(circa 1996/7) When the economy boomed agriculture was put under pressure by big business who squeezed prices to the farmer and hence the supermarkets rapid increase in margins.Ofcourse Tony and his chums didnt care because a few million donations to the Labour coffers and a knighthood or two and we were all in the jolly boys club together! It didnt matter about a few whinging yocals(not many votes there and mostly Tories anyway).Food was cheap for the masses but we are now just about to maybe sea a swing the other way.Years of no profitability and small farm dissapearance,stock numbers continually falling and now we are getting to the stage of not enough livestock to keep the abbotoirs working to capacity(The few that are left). So where do we go from here? Increased world demand would seem encouraging but its not really enough yet to make farming profitable to compare with civvy street yet.Smaller family farms were the lifeblood of the industry but with family members not interested as they see better wages and no getting up to feed stock on weekends a more attractive proposition who can blame them.



Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
ewenm said:
Rugbyman said:
So why the huge difference between what we expect the % to be and what it actually is ?

Would it have something to do with all the campaigns to plant more trees - keep the green belt green - paving paradise and puting up a carpark...?

Or more to do with the fact that the majority live in the urban areas and see concrete everyday and so have naturally unbalanced view on this ?

ETA quote from article.. 'Woodland now 12.7% of the UK, the highest proportion since 1924 when records began'
Most people don't explore our countryside, or think that leaving London for a trip to the South Downs is indicative of the rest of the UK's countryside. It's a real shame as it's relatively easy in the UK to go somewhere where you can walk/run/cycle all day offroad and often alone.
You can do that within 25 miles of Central London! I've spent 2-3 hours mountain-biking around the Surrey Hills without seeing another human being before now, albeit not at 2pm on a Saturday.

The problem with this survey is that it's frankly meaningless. Yes, there are vast areas of undeveloped countryside in the UK, but how does one set about developing it?

The Catch 22 is that nobody lives there because there are no jobs there, and there are no jobs there because nobody lives there. I'd like to live somewhere rural, but it's totally impractical for work, so I don't, and where I do live, regardless of the percentage the report claims is built on, just doesn't have the capacity for more people!

In the ideal world, we'd simply move the long-term unemployed to remote areas where it's cheaper, and free up space in the cities for people who want to work for a living (as opposed to just working to pay the rent/mortgage), but unfortunately the lefties will bleat intolerably about that.

Regiment

2,799 posts

190 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Carfiend said:
No the Lesser Spotted Scrotal Swarmer is the one doing that.
That is such a funny comeback that i have to say "Laugh Out Loud" rather than the more common, lazy acronym of LOL.

turbobloke

117,552 posts

291 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
CommanderJameson said:
AJS- said:
The statistic that I always find surprising is that there's roughly 60 million acres of the UK, which means, give or take, an acre per person. Not per family, but per person.
Just remember that some of those acres are in places like Beckton, Middlesbrough and Lincolnshire, so someone's going to be disappointed.

"Here, an entire acre, just for you. Doesn't it sound nice? "Tower Green"."

"Er, excuse me. You appear to have given me the single sttiest bit of Middlesbrough by mistake."
Curiously I was in Middlesbrough on business this week and was pleasantly surprised by the facilities and general ambiance of the Riverside Stadium, then again it was empty at the time. Apart from a Trade Union meeting in the public car park outside - nothing to do with the club apparently.

I can well imagine there are some 'tasty areas' to explore sonar

As somebody from Grimsby NE Lincs I'm not going to cast too many stones.

Riley Blue

23,217 posts

257 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
otolith said:
Riley Blue said:
Judging by the map, the figure for enclosed farmland would be considerably higher so how come we have to import so much food?
Largely because people want to eat (for example) asparagus in November.
Not me, I only eat what's in season ...Christmas pudding anyone?

vonuber

17,868 posts

196 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Incidentally, new development/greeness is not incompatable, in fact it's the standard.
Also, ecology is important, people who say it isn't need to actually stop and think beyond Daily Wail headlines.

turbobloke

117,552 posts

291 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
The Association of British Drivers was on the case many years ago.

http://www.abd.org.uk/green_and_pleasant_land.htm