To buy 525D M Sport Pre Sept 11 vs Post Sept 11...
To buy 525D M Sport Pre Sept 11 vs Post Sept 11...
Author
Discussion

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Hi all,

looking for advice on a buying decision.

I am weighing up...

USED - 525d M Sport Touring 2010 onwards model - pre Sept 2011
NEW - 525d M Sport Touring 2010 onwards model - post Sept 2011

There was a recent change to engine sizes. Pre Sept 2011 has a 3.0L 6-cylinder whereas post Sept 11 it has a 2.0L 4-cylinder.

The difference in road tax is £50 per year, so quite negligible. However the running costs of the 2.0L vs 3.0L concern me.

I have owned my current car - Volkswagen Golf GTI Edition 30 DSG 2007 - since November 2010 and have done 12,000. So 20 months to do 12,000 miles.

The models are very similar in spec up to a point, both have (excluding standard features):

Carbon Black
Oyster/Black Dakota Leather
Visibility Package
Sport automatic transmission
Extended luggage features
Ext. mirrors - folding, auto dimming
Fineline anthracite wood
Sun protection glass

USED one also has:

Extra - 19" M Double-spoke style 351M alloy wheels - £1210
Extra - Four zone climate control - £390
Extra - Media package BMW professional - £2160
Extra - Advanced parking package - £1590
Extra - Electric front seats + driver memory - £920

NEW one also has:

Standard - 18" M Double-spoke style 350M alloy wheels
Extra - Bootlid operation - powered - £430
Extra - Comfort seats, front - £1265
Extra - 12V power sockets - £45
Extra - Telephone USB audio interface - £70

Now for my finance options...

USED

The car when new cost £51480 and is now £35,395.
Trade-in: £8500
Deposit cash: £5000
Deposit card: £6000 with APR of 6.5%. I will then be able to lump sum this as and when cash allows and clear off well before monthly payments term ends.
54 payments of £375

NEW

The car new cost £47,255.

Trade-in: £12,547 (extra compared to used offer trade-in must be borrowed from profit of new car)
Deposit cash: £4,500
Discount by dealership: £2,250 (probably more as I tweaked my payments from £404 per month to £383)
47 payments of £383
Final payment of £14,116

QUESTIONS

1. Why has the USED car depreciated so much - £16,085 - when it was only UK registered April 2011.
2. I mainly do city driving in and around Glasgow. I do the occasional i.e. once or twice a month, longer drive to say Aberdeenshire or away hillwalking in the Highlands so is my concern of 2.0L vs 3.0L justified?

Help!




jrinns

406 posts

214 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
Why has the used car depreciated so much?

Because they just do ! It would never have sold for list and 50k for a 525 is quite frankly daft !

You keep the new one 4 years, it will be worth around your final payment give or take 1 - 2k

Thats the price you pay to drive around in a sub 3 year old car.

Nice cars mind and if I hadnt have got the wife an Evoque I would be looking at one, once you go over board on the spec and engine though the price just dosn't weight up.

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
jrinns said:
Why has the used car depreciated so much?

Because they just do ! It would never have sold for list and 50k for a 525 is quite frankly daft!
Agreed

jrinns said:
You keep the new one 4 years, it will be worth around your final payment give or take 1 - 2k
I want to own the car after 4 to 4.5 years otherwise I will just be starting all over again as I am now with the finance company buying it off me etc etc.

jrinns said:
Nice cars mind and if I hadnt have got the wife an Evoque I would be looking at one, once you go over board on the spec and engine though the price just dosn't weight up.
Well someone else has spec'd it up to the hilt and here I am thinking of swooping in on what they have spent initially.

I guess my fear is that in four years time will I be able to move the car on knowing that its 3.0L will be competing with engines that are 2.0L and give same 0-60 times and better fuel economy.




il sole

287 posts

175 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
[quote=jrinns]Why has the used car depreciated so much?

mainly this is due to larger cars not holding their value as well as smaller ones, but I would guess the main reason you have answered yourself (in a roundabout way). the 525d with the 3.0 engine is now a discontinued model, the new 4 cylinder will have better economy and tax implications, therefore devaluing further the older engine, and finally, it's got some expensive options which are never recouped at trade in time.

Between the 2, the used one does offer good value, but if you have to use finance, it's probably better to go new as after 3 years, you'll just be able to trade it in for another 3 year deal...

personally though, for your mileage i'd look at a used petrol. they are usually highly specced and have much lower residuals...whatever you chose, it'll be good!


gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Friday 29th June 2012
quotequote all
il sole]rinns said:
Why has the used car depreciated so much?

mainly this is due to larger cars not holding their value as well as smaller ones, but I would guess the main reason you have answered yourself (in a roundabout way). the 525d with the 3.0 engine is now a discontinued model, the new 4 cylinder will have better economy and tax implications, therefore devaluing further the older engine, and finally, it's got some expensive options which are never recouped at trade in time.
I aim to own the car after four years rather than trade in and begin the expensive cycle of buying a new car again.

il sole said:
Between the 2, the used one does offer good value, but if you have to use finance, it's probably better to go new as after 3 years, you'll just be able to trade it in for another 3 year deal...
This is where is falls down for me, continually having a monthly car payment. Be nice to pay it for a while and then own it. Not all this having a lump sum at the end to pay or trading it in, buying new, interest on monthly payments, loosing the VAT etc

il sole said:
personally though, for your mileage i'd look at a used petrol. they are usually highly specced and have much lower residuals...whatever you chose, it'll be good!
This is my thinking.

Wills2

29,933 posts

206 months

Saturday 30th June 2012
quotequote all

The 3.0 engine 525d seems to have the economy and emissions of the 530d without the performance, the F10 touring is a heavy car and needs IMHO the full fat 530d to give you the performance you'd expect of a 50k car.

For the price you have quoted there are lots of late model 530d MSport tourings available I would weigh up that choice Vs. the new 2.0d 525.

example:

http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

Oh and having the adaptive drive option transforms the car.






rassi

2,518 posts

282 months

Saturday 30th June 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
The 3.0 engine 525d seems to have the economy and emissions of the 530d without the performance, the F10 touring is a heavy car and needs IMHO the full fat 530d to give you the performance you'd expect of a 50k car.

For the price you have quoted there are lots of late model 530d MSport tourings available I would weigh up that choice Vs. the new 2.0d 525.

example:

http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

Oh and having the adaptive drive option transforms the car.





That's a cracking deal - stunning!

Wills2

29,933 posts

206 months

Saturday 30th June 2012
quotequote all
Or this Petrol 535i

http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

57k list 14 months old 36k, with the adaptive drive fitted.



Edited by Wills2 on Saturday 30th June 17:40

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
Or this Petrol 535i

http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

57k list 14 months old 36k, with the adaptive drive fitted.



Edited by Wills2 on Saturday 30th June 17:40
ohhhh, that's a peach! great spec, just a boring colour. not a bad price at all for a practically new car...

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
6 cylinders are better than 4, especially in a 5 Series. You are buying a refined executive saloon, not a cheap and cheerful beat the taxman special. Leave the 4 pots where they belong - in the 1 Series - and go for the 6 Cylinder powerplant.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
That is what I thought about that colour, but seeing Johns 550i (he is on the forum) it changed my mind, became one of my favourites.

I would want a 530 as the minimum on a 5 series if spending £35k.
And do haggle hard, I nearly bought a 2011 530d sport touring with 17k miles on it, with media prof., internet, visibility, sports auto, adaptive suspension and a few other nice bits, for £28k a couple of months back. It was up at £32k and they kept coming back with better and better offers.

In the end I went with an E350cdi, and in that 'boring' grey colour. wink


gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
The 3.0 engine 525d seems to have the economy and emissions of the 530d without the performance, the F10 touring is a heavy car and needs IMHO the full fat 530d to give you the performance you'd expect of a 50k car.
Its no slouch. The 530d is one second quicker - would I really notice that? Doubt it.

Wills2 said:
For the price you have quoted there are lots of late model 530d MSport tourings available I would weigh up that choice Vs. the new 2.0d 525.

example:

http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

Oh and having the adaptive drive option transforms the car.
I see this one is a November 2011 model. Fuel consumption figures look impressive for a 3.0L but they just aint real world.

What is real world is my recent driving...

In town i.e. stop / start etc - 33mpg
Motorway - 44mpg

Better than the VW Golf GTI Edition 30 DSG 2007 I used to have, could only get 31mpg on the motorway. Awful. Both cars were doing 80mph.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
You would certainly notice the 1 second improvement in 0-60time.
It will be significantly quicker

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Tuesday 3rd July 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
Or this Petrol 535i

http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

57k list 14 months old 36k, with the adaptive drive fitted.
I want the car I am about to make me smile when I walk up and get into it - not be sick. The look of this car just doesnt blow my hair back.

1. Aluminium roof rails - think it makes it look less classy (especially combined with that colour)
2. The 6 disc changer - for me is pointless as I would be using an iPod
3. DAB radio - again is pointless for me as I dont listen to the radio that much that I would get the use out of it plus there is plenty radio stations anyways
4. Heads up display - just think it to be unnecessary and over the top
5. Loud speaker system - the standard setup is more than adequate. It is a car not a recording studio. Road noise will always creep across your music. And playing it so loud when your supposed to be driving a refined car.
6. Piano black - just garish

Adaptive drive would be nice but would the average joe really notice. The sport model has a stiffer ride anyways. I dont find it that bad. I once had a standard Mercedes C Class something and was trying to keep up with my brother in law in an Audi S3 and the roll of the Merc just slowed me way down. I dont think this would be a problem with an M Sport BMW.

Lumbar support would be a nice addition but its not like the seats aint plush enough.

Wills2

29,933 posts

206 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
gordonhunter said:
Wills2 said:
Or this Petrol 535i

http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/bmwauc/details/0,,1156_...

57k list 14 months old 36k, with the adaptive drive fitted.
I want the car I am about to make me smile when I walk up and get into it - not be sick. The look of this car just doesnt blow my hair back.

1. Aluminium roof rails - think it makes it look less classy (especially combined with that colour)
2. The 6 disc changer - for me is pointless as I would be using an iPod
3. DAB radio - again is pointless for me as I dont listen to the radio that much that I would get the use out of it plus there is plenty radio stations anyways
4. Heads up display - just think it to be unnecessary and over the top
5. Loud speaker system - the standard setup is more than adequate. It is a car not a recording studio. Road noise will always creep across your music. And playing it so loud when your supposed to be driving a refined car.
6. Piano black - just garish

Adaptive drive would be nice but would the average joe really notice. The sport model has a stiffer ride anyways. I dont find it that bad. I once had a standard Mercedes C Class something and was trying to keep up with my brother in law in an Audi S3 and the roll of the Merc just slowed me way down. I dont think this would be a problem with an M Sport BMW.

Lumbar support would be a nice addition but its not like the seats aint plush enough.
Hi Gordon, the car was just an example based upon you thinking about a petrol version instead, rather than wow you must buy this.

As far as adaptive drive is concerned yes you will notice the difference I did it feels like a BMW with it but not without.

As for performance, 0-60 times only tell you so much, drive the 530d and decide for yourself after all they are the same price as the 525 you are looking at.

Anyway good luck with the search.

gordonhunter

Original Poster:

156 posts

193 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
Hi Gordon, the car was just an example based upon you thinking about a petrol version instead, rather than wow you must buy this.

As far as adaptive drive is concerned yes you will notice the difference I did it feels like a BMW with it but not without.

As for performance, 0-60 times only tell you so much, drive the 530d and decide for yourself after all they are the same price as the 525 you are looking at.

Anyway good luck with the search.
I have now driven the BMW for several hundred miles on winding country roads and whilst it doesnt handle like the VW Golf GTI Edition 30 which I loved I think its still very good.

So I would be very interested to see the improvements that Adaptive Drive would bring to the handling of the car.

I am coming to appreciate the usable power of the BMW when compared to the GTI Edition 30 in that out and out 0-60 pace, whilst nice to have a go at, is not particularly useful in the real world. Its more about bragging rights.

I like the overtake ability of the BMW. Its a car that is growing on me.