Green/Blue on Blue
Author
Discussion

richinleeds

Original Poster:

738 posts

231 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
RIP to 3 brother's murdered by someone wearing an Afghan Police uniform just shows we can't trust any of the people we are supposed to be training.

Roll on 2014 when we can leave that place!!

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
richinleeds said:
RIP to 3 brothers murdered by someone wearing an Afghan Police uniform just shows we can't trust any of the people we are supposed to be training.

Roll on 2014 when we can leave that place!!
Is that a fair thing to say? The Afghans could no doubt say the same about us and the US, given the number of Afghans killed in error by coalition troops, not to mention those murdered in cold blood by "bad apples".

richinleeds

Original Poster:

738 posts

231 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Of course it's a fair thing to say i dont trust any of them simples they come to us to train them yet we are seeing more and more of these types of attack's

shouldbworking

4,801 posts

243 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
RIP to the soldiers involved.

and a massive 'do you even read this stuff before you print it' to the telegraph

the telegraph said:
The incident is the deadliest since 2010 when an officer two Gurkhas were killed by an Afghan soldiers. That incident came eight month after five soldiers from the Grenadier Guard battlegroup were murdered by a policeman.

Mr_B

10,480 posts

274 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
rohrl said:
Is that a fair thing to say? The Afghans could no doubt say the same about us and the US, given the number of Afghans killed in error by coalition troops, not to mention those murdered in cold blood by "bad apples".
It's a fair thing to say when the intent was relating to the number of Afghans in Police or Military uniform who kill US and UK troops. The trust issue is, is the guy next to you who is meant to be on your side, really going to shoot you in the back as soon as he gets the chance.
You've choosen to slightly distort the argument by relating it to Afghans killed in error. I guess you will no doubt mention the US Marine who went nuts and went on a killing spree, but that agin is not the same. He was a lone guy that went nuts and wasn't part of any group who planned an attack.
If you think the number of cases of rogue Afghan Police/ Miltary killing UK personel is bad, trying looking at the US media, as only attacks on UK personnel get reported here. The total is much higher for US personnel.

Asterix

24,438 posts

259 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Significantly higher for US troops.

Also, when civies and other genuine blue on blue attacks happens - those pulling the trigger tend to experience extreme grief and upset for those killed.

There was a video released not long ago of an above error made by a US pilot, the guy broke down and was distraught over the radio when he realised the mistake made.

No one should confuse that with a scumbag turning his weapon on those who trust him and are training him.

RIP for our guys.

Edited by Asterix on Monday 2nd July 11:15

percymk4

387 posts

217 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Asterix said:
Significantly higher for US troops.

Also, when civies and other genuine blue on blue attacks happens - those pulling the trigger tend to experience extreme grief and upset for those killed.

There was a video released not long ago of an above error made by a US pilot, the guy broke down and was distraught over the radio when he realised the mistake made.

No one should confuse that with a scumbag turning his weapon on those who trust him and are training him.

RIP for our guys.

Edited by Asterix on Monday 2nd July 11:15
This one?

Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RK10pqBpz8g
Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=endscreen&amp...

They start engaging at the end of the first video and there's a bit of swearing on the second video

Asterix

24,438 posts

259 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
That's the one - after they get told that it was friendlies, they begin to get upset. When the pilot is told at 3 minutes that it's one dead and one injured, the silence is deafening and what follows seems to be the language of someone who's pretty upset.

Do you think the Afghani lot give as much of a st?

Jimbeaux

33,791 posts

262 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
rohrl said:
richinleeds said:
RIP to 3 brothers murdered by someone wearing an Afghan Police uniform just shows we can't trust any of the people we are supposed to be training.

Roll on 2014 when we can leave that place!!
Is that a fair thing to say? The Afghans could no doubt say the same about us and the US, given the number of Afghans killed in error by coalition troops, not to mention those murdered in cold blood by "bad apples".
Mostly accidents versus mostly deliberate. Go look up the difference.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Jimbeaux said:
Mostly accidents versus mostly deliberate. Go look up the difference.
fk off Jim with your patronising "look up the difference". Why can't you just make your point without being such an ahole about it?

It doesn't make any difference to the family of the victim why their relative was shot anyway.

prand

6,246 posts

227 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Asterix said:
Significantly higher for US troops.

There was a video released not long ago of an above error made by a US pilot, the guy broke down and was distraught over the radio when he realised the mistake made.

Edited by Asterix on Monday 2nd July 11:15
I remember this - the flight recording of the US reserve pilot bombing the British convoy in an A10 was going "Yee haw! Take that rag head!" when scoring a direct hit, then going "Oh my gawd, oh my gawd, I feel sick, that's awful" (all paraphrased) when being told he'd hit allied vehicles.

Strange double standards I thought from the pilot/bomber - in that whichever side he was on, he was still taking people's lives. Then again I don't do this for a living.


Jimbeaux

33,791 posts

262 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
rohrl said:
Jimbeaux said:
Mostly accidents versus mostly deliberate. Go look up the difference.
fk off Jim with your patronising "look up the difference". Why can't you just make your point without being such an ahole about it?

It doesn't make any difference to the family of the victim why their relative was shot anyway.
So, you understand the difference then? The point of being an asshole was to emphasize the fact that even a simpleton should see the contrasts of the two like a flare in the night. It is an action/reaction type thing.....a statement void of the obvious will have that void filled by the cynicism it deserves.





Edited by Jimbeaux on Monday 2nd July 14:50

richinleeds

Original Poster:

738 posts

231 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
With you on this Jim, it's the hole trust thig that is worrying about these type's of attacks, we live side by side with these people all this will just mean less trust from us.

Jimbeaux

33,791 posts

262 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
richinleeds said:
With you on this Jim, it's the hole trust thig that is worrying about these type's of attacks, we live side by side with these people all this will just mean less trust from us.
True. The culture is just so different and ingrained that none of this will ever work. Even a place as far ahead of 'Stan as Egypt is about to slip into stupidness to some degree.

BOR

5,154 posts

286 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
prand said:
I remember this - the flight recording of the US reserve pilot bombing the British convoy in an A10 was going "Yee haw! Take that rag head!" when scoring a direct hit, then going "Oh my gawd, oh my gawd, I feel sick, that's awful" (all paraphrased) when being told he'd hit allied vehicles.

Strange double standards I thought from the pilot/bomber - in that whichever side he was on, he was still taking people's lives. Then again I don't do this for a living.
My thoughts exactly. Also, the pleasure evident during a sustained attack on what turned out to be a CNN camera crew was utterly revolting.

richinleeds

Original Poster:

738 posts

231 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Also there is nothing wrong with been happy about defeating your enemy imho of course

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
This song says what I think should happen.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U5YxY_CJwz4


Starfighter

5,352 posts

209 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
prand said:
Asterix said:
Significantly higher for US troops.

There was a video released not long ago of an above error made by a US pilot, the guy broke down and was distraught over the radio when he realised the mistake made.

Edited by Asterix on Monday 2nd July 11:15
I remember this - the flight recording of the US reserve pilot bombing the British convoy in an A10 was going "Yee haw! Take that rag head!" when scoring a direct hit, then going "Oh my gawd, oh my gawd, I feel sick, that's awful" (all paraphrased) when being told he'd hit allied vehicles.

Strange double standards I thought from the pilot/bomber - in that whichever side he was on, he was still taking people's lives. Then again I don't do this for a living.
The pilot (single crew aircraft) went from saving friendly lives by taking out an enemy combat vehicle to having killed his own side in seconds. I'm surprised he actually made it back in the Warthog.

MikeGTi

2,754 posts

232 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
Very sadly becoming all too common.

Even if the people carrying out these attacks are merely disgruntled with their trainers and not related to the Taliban it's doing a heck of a lot of good for the Taliban.

We can't leave soon enough IMHO.

Bill

58,913 posts

286 months

Monday 2nd July 2012
quotequote all
richinleeds said:
With you on this Jim, it's the hole trust thig that is worrying about these type's of attacks, we live side by side with these people all this will just mean less trust from us.
Which is exactly the effect they want. frown