A comment by H Metcalfe that has annoyed me - Maserati GT
A comment by H Metcalfe that has annoyed me - Maserati GT
Author
Discussion

Fantuzzi

Original Poster:

3,297 posts

177 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
"Handsome, charismatic, sporting and everyday useable...[this] is the car Maserati always promised us. Its a shame its taken five years to get here" H Metcalfe EVO on the new Maserati GT Sport.

This confused me at first, then annoyed me because it is rather contrary to anything Ive read by EVO or indeed anyone else on the Maserati Granturismo.

When it was first realised it was praised for its handling, comfort and style, yet people wished it had more power and a little more dynamic edge. Fine, even though it was never meant to be a 911/vantage rival. It was designed to be Grand Tourer in the purest sense of the word, it was for driving from Oxford to Florence for art and an icecream then back again averaging 120mph and doing so in comfort and ease. If you pass through a mountain pass along the way, press sport, have fun, but a road racer it was not. After all its called the Granturismo, the grand tourer.

Harry had one, his parting words with it.
"I only wish I was still one of those owners, for the GranTurismo was as close to being my perfect everyday car as anything I’ve ever had the pleasure of driving"

Maserati realised an S model after this, more power sharper handling. And to qoute J Simister writing for EVO
"The GranTurismo S feels a smaller, keener, more agile car...Here’s the GranTurismo as it’s meant to be."

Great, a GT without the snags EVO wrote. Perfect GT with a real sporting edge.

The MC Stradale was a bit of a bad move in my view, either adding 80kg to the GT4 car of comforts (eg a dashboard...) and billing it as GT3/scud rival or keeping the GT as a Grand Tourer but with the sharper edge and 4 seats, more bhp and agressive styling, yet retaining the GT feel. After all, journos have noted it falls short as a trackday toy due to it still rather heavy weight, yet on the roads its rather brilliant.

So in what way has the GT been an almost car? It is sharper than a DB9 or Bentley, yet was 30k cheaper, and was up there as a GT car in terms amonst them. It was priced against smaller sportier rivals so was often compaired unfairly, yet most writers acknoweldged this in tests. It always appeared to be the better choice than other soft coupes like the XKR, so I ask fellow PHers, what on earth does Harry mean by his closing comment?

Its always been the blue eyed boy of many journalists, especially EVO and especially by Harry.He has often praised it highly, buying another one after he sold his last.

Maserati have always impressed me, they set out to make a great GT and they have done so, and with EVO writing of a new Gransport set to be rather racey, it seem a perfect model line up, the GT for every day use, then the Gransport for when you feel like driving.

So its confused me rather, is he saying he wished the Maserati had been a sportier car from the start, rather than a GT, or that the package was always lacking in all respects until the Sport model?

Thanks in advance.





baptist

632 posts

287 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
I wouldnt worry about it! long as you're happy with the car, thats all that matters.


V8 GRF

7,299 posts

241 months

Wednesday 4th July 2012
quotequote all
As is typical of his type of journalist he's saying what suits him at the time to make a story.

wtdoom

3,742 posts

239 months

Thursday 5th July 2012
quotequote all
Who cares what some geezer writes ?
Enjoy YOUR car matey .

Jonty355

4,423 posts

244 months

Thursday 5th July 2012
quotequote all
Journalists dont always get it right... for example, Clarkson sold his F355! What a clown! biggrin

Colossus

337 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th July 2012
quotequote all
I haven't driven the Sport so can't speak from experience but perhaps the changes that Maserati have made are such that the car has been improved such that although he didn't know it at the time he made his earlier comments, Harry now prefers the new Sport to his GT-S. I think it has been fairly obvious that Harry has been a big fan of the GT, he has bought 2 after all, and cars often get improvements over their lifetime, this is just another example of that. It doesn't mean the older models are bad, just that if given a choice between the two, you would go for the newer car.

As others have said, I would not worry too much about what others are saying, enjoy your car for what it is, I know I am!

Guyr

2,546 posts

313 months

Thursday 5th July 2012
quotequote all
Actually there are two things Harry says that annoy me and I love Evo magazine (I have every issue printed kept in a bookcase at home).

I'll paraphrase them as.....

1 - Car X [insert here] is simply the most amazing used car/classic and is really under-appreciated. It just so happens I've recently bought one.

2 - Pagani is wonderful, everything they do is wonderful, they are so beautiful and talented, just like wonderful Horatio, will he ever notice my wanton, distant, longing affections......?

Fantuzzi

Original Poster:

3,297 posts

177 months

Friday 6th July 2012
quotequote all
Guyr said:
Actually there are two things Harry says that annoy me and I love Evo magazine (I have every issue printed kept in a bookcase at home).

I'll paraphrase them as.....

1 - Car X [insert here] is simply the most amazing used car/classic and is really under-appreciated. It just so happens I've recently bought one.

2 - Pagani is wonderful, everything they do is wonderful, they are so beautiful and talented, just like wonderful Horatio, will he ever notice my wanton, distant, longing affections......?
biggrin

EC2

1,547 posts

284 months

Saturday 7th July 2012
quotequote all
The important thing to remember is that we are all inconsistent with our views on cars but for journalists the evidence is there to keep looking at!

I recall that Harry Metcalfe said when the GTS MC Shift came out in 2008 that he would never buy one - as it was inferior gearbox wise to the GT he had owned - and then three years later he did. Personally I disagree with him on Skyhook as he state's that the fixed rate set up is better. Strange that he therefore bought a GTS with Skyhook when the GTS comes with either.

Anyway, it's great that a major magazine has a Maserati fan at the helm. Personally I feel that journalists get carried away by mid life facelifts and suspect that if you could put the pre-facelift set up on a facelift car - and vice a versa - that most people would struggle to tell the difference. Most of it is spin and personal preference which is why you need to drive a car yourself to take a view. I have a pre-facelift GTS Auto and love it. I will try a facelift car but suspect I will wait for the new GranTurismo in c2015 before I change.

Fantuzzi

Original Poster:

3,297 posts

177 months

Sunday 8th July 2012
quotequote all
EC2 said:
The important thing to remember is that we are all inconsistent with our views on cars but for journalists the evidence is there to keep looking at!

I recall that Harry Metcalfe said when the GTS MC Shift came out in 2008 that he would never buy one - as it was inferior gearbox wise to the GT he had owned - and then three years later he did. Personally I disagree with him on Skyhook as he state's that the fixed rate set up is better. Strange that he therefore bought a GTS with Skyhook when the GTS comes with either.

Anyway, it's great that a major magazine has a Maserati fan at the helm. Personally I feel that journalists get carried away by mid life facelifts and suspect that if you could put the pre-facelift set up on a facelift car - and vice a versa - that most people would struggle to tell the difference. Most of it is spin and personal preference which is why you need to drive a car yourself to take a view. I have a pre-facelift GTS Auto and love it. I will try a facelift car but suspect I will wait for the new GranTurismo in c2015 before I change.
Very true.

Worst thing is the Jag XKR (the latest one), named in the 95th greatest drivers car in their top 100, then in a issue a few mounths back, really slated it, not a good thing said about the big cat! It so stupid, same car, if I owned the car, I would have wrote in asking them how they can change their opinion from all time great to load of rubbish.

I normally rate EVO pretty well.

I know anyone will drive the cars themselves who is thinking of buying, but for goodness sake going from one extreme to another is pretty poor.

M